A 2003 report by Ken Clarke argued that a Supremacy Act, similar to the UK Sovereignty Act proposed today, would be "fundamentally incompatible" with EU membership.
A 2003 report by Ken Clarke argued that a Supremacy Act, similar to the UK Sovereignty Act proposed today by David Cameron, would be “fundamentally incompatible” with EU membership and a “recipe for anarchy”.
The report (no longer on the Internet but available for download here), published by the Tory Europe Network, argued that:
“Throughout our eighteen years in Government, we always accepted that the European Union could not possibly work without its law taking priority over national laws within its own competence. There has never been any serious doubt that for us to purport to reverse this principle by an Act of Parliament would be fundamentally incompatible with our continued membership of the Union, and would be taken as an immediate signal of our withdrawal from full membership.
“Ideas such as a ‘supremacy act’ asserting the superiority of British law or giving the British courts the power to overrule judgements of the European Court of Justice undermine one of the fundamentals of the European Union – the universal application of EU law which actually needs to be strengthened in some areas to ensure that every State obeys the rules.
“Without a universally applicable and enforceable body of European law, the European single market simply could not function as it does. British businesses can treat the other [members] – as part of their ‘home market’ safe in the knowledge that common standards and rules apply. And of course an attempt to end the supremacy of EU law in areas where it does not suit us implies that we would be happy to see other EU countries do the same. But this would mean that areas where even anti-Europeans agree that common legal standards benefit us could also be under threat. It is a recipe for anarchy.”
David Cameron said today:
“So as well as making sure that further power cannot be handed to the EU without a referendum, we will also introduce a new law, in the form of a United Kingdom Sovereignty Bill, to make it clear that ultimate authority stays in this country, in our Parliament.”
A spokesman for Ken Clarke told Left Foot Forward, “The United Kingdom Sovereignty Bill promised today by David Cameron does not do any of the things that Ken Clarke was criticising in his 2003 paper. As David has made clear, the Bill would not mean striking down individual items of EU legislation but would provide ultimate constitutional safeguards against any attempts by EU judges to erode our sovereignty. Ken fully supports this and the series of measures announced today for which the Conservative Party will seek a mandate at the next general election. “
16 Responses to “Clarke in 2003: Supremacy Act “fundamentally incompatible” with EU membership”
Jon Worth
Excellent research to dig this up! Well done LFF team…
@unseen – in theory, yes, in practice it has never been tested at all. The single market without supremacy of EU law doesn’t work.
Sunder Katwala
Ken Clarke backs Sovereignty Act; he has assurances from Cameron it doesn't do what it pretends to http://bit.ly/JCVhW (@LeftFootFwd)
GuyAitchison
RT @nextleft: Ken Clarke backs Sovereignty Act; he has assurances from Cameron it doesn't do what it pretends to http://bit.ly/JCVhW
Liam Murray
You’re either misrepresenting Cameron’s ‘Sovereignty Act’ or misunderstanding it. Jon says:
“The single market without supremacy of EU law doesn’t work”
Absolutely – and the Sovereignty act doesn’t question the supremacy of EU law once it’s been drawn up and agreed across 27 members states. All Cameron’s proposal does is force any UK government embarking on that road to seek approval via a referendum.
Still much to criticise there and questions about whether it’s workable but absolutely nothing in this post or Clarke’s response to today’s announcement which demonstrates a sovereignty act is incompatible with EU membership.
All of which, ironically enough, makes the sleight of hand in your post title very ‘Daily Mail’…
kris castle
RT @nextleft: Ken Clarke backs Sovereignty Act; he has assurances from Cameron it doesn't do what it pretends to http://bit.ly/JCVhW