Mayors seeking reselection would have their 'contribution to campaigning' assessed by the NEC
Labour’s National Executive Committee (NEC) is set to discuss proposals on making its regional mayor’s more accountable to the party. According to a report from LabourList, proposals put to the NEC would see Labour mayors required to write reports for their regional executive committees (RECs), and the RECs to in turn report to the NEC on mayors’ ‘contribution to campaigning’ .
The Party has defended the changes saying not only would they make mayors more accountable but also modernise processes to recognise the increased importance of metro mayors and link them better to existing party structures.
LabourList reports that under the proposals, Labour’s regional mayors could also face “disciplinary action” if they do not pay a two per cent levy on their salaries to the party.
These proposals have led to concerns being raised by some who claim they would ‘centralise power’ within the NEC, ‘stifle diversity of thought’ and undermined the ‘autonomy’ of elected representatives.
Jess Barnard, a member of Labour’s NEC on the left of the party told, Left Foot Forward: “The proposed changes to increase control over regional mayors are a consistent display of top-down control of the NEC against local democracy and the autonomy of elected representatives.
“Instead of empowering our mayors, who are amongst the most popular local politicians in their areas, to deliver for their communities, the leadership seems intent on centralising power within the NEC, stifling diversity of thought and local accountability.
“This approach is not only at odds with Labour’s supposed commitment to devolution but risks further alienating regional voters who value genuine local representation, after years of being left behind by the Tory administrations.
“Labour should focus on building trust, not tightening its grip.”
However, her claims have been questioned by other NEC members, including Jane Thomas.
Thomas told LFF: “I welcome the fact that the Party is taking governance and accountability seriously. By next May the whole of the Yorkshire and the Humber region will be covered by elected mayors so it is only right and proper there is adequate scrutiny of the role, along with alignment of policies and campaigns”
LabourList has had sight of the document set to be discussed by the NEC. According to its reporting, the document says: “Due to their size and nature of the role, neither regional mayors nor police and crime commissioners have a direct link to an existing party unit in the same way that MPs (CLPs), councillors (branch) or council leaders (local government committees). This has resulted in a perceived lack of clarity and inconsistency regarding accountability to the party.
“In line with the rights and responsibilities of all elected members, regional mayors are subject [to] a two percent levy on elected member’s salary, including all payments flowing directly from elected office. The party should ask the Association of Labour Councillors to ensure this is complied with in all cases, enforced with appropriate disciplinary action if required.”
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 117 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.