Calling time on warped reporting: Yes, we’re East Asians. No, we’re not tied to the Chinese Communist Party

Harmful media stereotypes are exacerbating the everyday racism faced by British East Asians, writes Sarah Owen MP.

If you live in the UK and look Chinese, you will be well-accustomed to casual stereotyping. But one form of racism has become especially painful recently: the assumption that anyone with Chinese heritage is a supporter of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). 

I chair Chinese for Labour (CfL), one of the twenty Socialist Societies formally affiliated with the Labour Party (alongside the Jewish Labour Movement, LGBT+ Labour and the Fabians). We campaign for greater political engagement amongst British Chinese, East and Southeast Asian communities; and campaign on issues relevant to them.

This has included supporting the pro-democracy movement in Hong Kong; highlighting human rights abuses of Uighurs in Xinjiang; and supporting the calls from Labour’s front bench for more robust responses on these issues.

Despite this, our organisation often comes under greater scrutiny from those who are – rightly – wary of CCP influence in British politics. At last year’s Party Conference, members of Chinese for Labour were asked several times who funds us (clue: it’s not the CCP). However, while the average Party member can be forgiven for not researching our aims, we would expect a national newspaper to know better. 

That’s why we were taken aback when The Times recently published a piece alleging that Chinese for Labour has been “infiltrated” by the CCP.

Even more surprising was the racist generalisations used as ‘evidence’. In the piece, Australian author Clive Hamilton says: “With names like ‘Chinese for Labour’…they are part of the CCP’s programme of injecting people they trust into positions of political influence”.

This is a textbook example of conflating the Chinese people, and people of Chinese heritage in Britain, with the authoritarian Chinese government. In making so explicit the inference from our organisation’s Chinese-ness to an alleged relationship with the CCP, Mr Hamilton “said the quiet part loud”. No effort was made to disguise the racial generalisation underlying his claim. 

The article also cites meetings between CfL and a representative from China’s United Front Work Department, the governmental office which manages relations with overseas individuals and organisations.

While we are under no false impressions as to the conflicts between our aims and those of the UFWD, it is inevitable that in working to support Chinese communities in Britain, we have some communication with Chinese officials.  In fact, any official communication any person, organisation or indeed Government makes will mean some contact with a CCP representative. Given it is a one-party state, which nearly every official has to be a member of, it would be hard not to.

The double standard is this: if you go to China or have to communicate with Chinese officials, it is ok if you’re ‘white’ but not if you’re ‘yellow’.

In May 2019, British government officials took a trade trip to China – the 20 strong delegation included the permanent secretaries of the departments for business; digital and culture; exiting the EU; trade and so on. They met their counterparts in the Chinese government.

Nowhere have we seen suggestions these delegates have been ‘infiltrated’ or are doing the dealings of the CCP.  Indeed, we shouldn’t. Because like it or not, the idea that we can tackle global issues like climate change without conversations with China, is not the reality we currently live in.

The Times’ article was lazy journalism. You only have to scroll through Chinese for Labour’s Twitter feed, glance at our website’s blog, or flick through the leaflets at our Conference stall to know what we stand for. Either their paper didn’t bother, or they ignored the evidence for the sake of a click-bait headline. 

However, this wasn’t just a harmless journalistic error. If respected British newspapers act as though all Chinese-heritage people are tied to China’s current administration, they will be pushed out of mainstream political spaces – even individuals who are campaigning for the freedoms of their relatives and friends in Hong Kong and Xinjiang.

There needs to be a grown up voice from the UK that ensures that tough criticism of the Chinese State does not slip into racism against the Chinese and East Asian citizens who are an integral part of our diverse culture.

Sarah Owen MP is Chair of Chinese for Labour.

Disclosure: Sonny Leong CBE, also a Chair of CfL, sits on Left Foot Forward’s board.

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

Comments are closed.