Two cheers for the Scottish First Minister, who puts her contemporaries to shame
‘The person with the most thought-through plan, as evidenced by the past 48 hours, is astonishingly, Nicola Sturgeon, the First Minister of Scotland.’
So said Sky News political editor Faisal Islam yesterday, after describing how a Tory MP told him the Leave campaign has ‘no plan’ for Brexit.
Why ‘astonishingly’? Islam probably meant that Scotland has largely been a hostage in this referendum, one its political leaders never wanted, and in which Scots gave a 62 per cent vote for Remain.
Given the circumstances then, we might be surprised Scotland’s First Minister appears the politician best prepared for the fallout.
But there are also positive reasons to argue Nicola Sturgeon is the only political leader who has behaved like one since the UK voted on Thursday.
In her post-result speech, and several TV interviews, Sturgeon has seized the initiative where others seemed impotent, with proposals for Scotland’s future relations with both the EU and Britain.
She has vowed to honour the decision of Scottish voters by fighting to keep Scotland in the EU, and mooted a second referendum on Scottish Independence, given the UK outside the EU is not what Scots voted for in 2014.
Sturgeon has even suggested asking the Scottish Parliament to vote down a ‘motion of consent’ for leaving the EU – potentially blocking Brexit for the whole UK – in the name of ‘doing what is best for Scotland’.
These bold ideas could backfire – Scotland’s economy would likely suffer outside the UK, for example – but they at least have popular support and a certain internal logic.
Meanwhile, David Cameron has resigned, George Osborne went missing for three days, and Boris Johnson seems almost sorry about the result of the referendum.
And of course, Jeremy Corbyn has been roundly pasted for his weak role in the EU referendum, triggering a mass exodus of shadow cabinet members and direct challenges to his position.
It’s worth noting that Nicola Sturgeon has only been in post for 18 months, yet managed to dominate last year’s general election debates, and emerges post-Brexit as the only leader with purpose, resolve and backbone.
This says nothing of her domestic policies, which have been slammed for doing to little to tackle inequality, or the SNP’s nationalism, (as distinct from simply wanting independence), which I believe should be a problem for any progressive.
But while British leaders have, on the whole, given the public very little to be proud of during this referendum, Nicola Sturgeon has shown what political leadership looks like.
Two cheers then for the Scottish First Minister, for providing an honourable exception, and making us feel like there’s at least someone in charge.
Adam Barnett is staff writer for Left Foot Forward. Follow him on Twitter @AdamBarnett13
10 Responses to “Nicola Sturgeon shows what political leadership looks like post-Brexit”
Julian Kelly
“This says nothing of her domestic policies, which have been slammed for doing to little to tackle inequality, or the SNP’s nationalism, (as distinct from simply wanting independence), which I believe should be a problem for any progressive.”
Nope. Slamming of domestic policies? No one of any note in Scotland has slammed anything the SNP has done for quite some time. This is born out by the highest approval rating of any party leader, the huge majority the SNP gained in the recent Scottish Parliamentary elections, the vast majority of Scottish councils which are controlled by the SNP and the landslide result for the SNP at the last general election. The SNP have been protecting Scotland from the worst excesses of Westminster for quite some time now, they do it well and the people of Scotland recognise this by voting them in again and again.
You should probably also stop conflating Scottish nationalism with less savoury versions. I know it’s a difficult concept but our nationalist left-of-centre Scottish civil society is in no way similar to the little Englander thugs I’ve been seeing on the news over the weekend. This is born out by the huge disparity between the way Scotland votes and the rest of the UK.
Apart from that one dubious sentence your blog post was quite accurate.
Jim Linden
See factual video by Jim Sillars (https://vimeo.com/171632386) – still of the same opinion?
Ray Allott
Let us all hope that the lunacy of the English brexit voters will be blocked by Scotland and we remain a member of the EU.
Ross Armour
Agree with this article entirely. Not an SNP supporter but Sturgeon has been in a league of her own the last few days in terms of providing political leadership. It’s got me thinking about Scottish independence which I’ve never done before
Jimmy Glesga
It was obvious she and her Nat sis would take this line. They are not democrats. They trashed those of us who voted to remain in the Union. They took part in a British referendum and cannot
accept the result. We in Scotland who support the Union will be marginalised by these Nat si fanatics.