Media Watch: Tale of two kitchens hides the fact the Mail got it wrong

Yesterday Miliband's kitchen proved his socialism, but today it reveals his affluence


If at first you don’t succeed, try something else. So runs the mantra of the right-wing press, who after saying that footage of Ed Miliband’s kitchen, shown by the BBC on Tuesday, was a warning of the dystopian society we can expect from a Labour government, were unfazed by the news that this wasn’t his kitchen at all.

Far from retreating from yesterday’s bizarre column by Sarah Vine, who attacked the room’s ‘communist-style egalitarian lino’, the Daily Mail has moved on to sneering at Moneybags Miliband’s two-kitchen decadence.

It reports: “The poky room the couple were pictured in, albeit with an oven and hob, was revealed last night by a family friend to be a ‘functional kitchenette’ for ‘tea and quick snacks’.

“The revelation opened up the Labour leader to claims that he was trying to make his family life look more humble than it is, even though his home is reputed to be worth £2.5million.”

It goes on to quote Tory MP Nigel Adams, who adds: “Clearly there’s no cost of living crisis for ‘Two Kitchens’ Miliband. […]

“Red Ed can try as much as he likes to portray himself as a man of the people but the only people he’s in touch with are the North London metropolitan elite.”

The Mail even quotes Vine’s piece in order to crow about how right they were – despite the fact that they got it completely wrong.

Vine did wonder if the small room pictured was really the Miliband’s kitchen, but that didn’t stop her from going on to draw bizarre conclusions from it anyway. (Her piece being incoherent and self-contradictory is hardly a point for the Mail.) 

So one day the kitchen photo is a key insight into Miliband’s ‘socialist’ politics, the next it’s Labour propaganda to hide his secret affluence. And the Mail was right all along. We have always been at war with North London…

Meanwhile, the paper today ran a cuddly piece on the Sun‘s interview with Samantha Cameron, who spoke about supporting her hubby and Comic Relief, in marked contrast to their stiff write-up of the BBC’s interview with Miliband’s wife, Justine. (Vine’s column yesterday described Justine as a ‘cerebral’ and humourless feminist.)

A teasing but less gloating piece in the Times (‘Revealed: Ed’s two-kitchen secret’) suggests the non-kitchen was only filmed because the BBC needed a ‘linking shot’ for their interview footage, though it notes Miliband was photographed in the smaller room in a 2011 story for the Guardian. So it’s not clear whether the charge that Miliband wanted to hide the larger kitchen has merit (Labour has so far declined to comment on the story.)

But since this whole ‘tale of two kitchens’ started with the Mail‘s attempt to make political hay with the BBC interview, it is extraordinary that they should so breezily re-write their mistake to attack an ‘elitist’ Miliband whose Mansion tax – despised by the Mail – would take money from his and other £2million-plus properties to fund the NHS. That’s the real ‘secret’ at the heart of this storm in a teacup.

Adam Barnett is a staff writer at Left Foot Forward. Follow him on Twitter

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

10 Responses to “Media Watch: Tale of two kitchens hides the fact the Mail got it wrong”

  1. madasafish

    Don’t be dumb.. He’s an MP. He’ll reclaim Mansion Tax on his expenses.

  2. working class

    on his an her income they will not be perturbed by the mansion tax , like they neither worry about the cost of living in general, champagne socialists living in amongst the lovies,and elite in poor old north london , well hampstead at least

  3. Cole

    If he can (which I doubt), so can Mrs Michael Gove who wrote the article. The Goves have a nice Bayswater/Notting Hill pad apparently, but you can be sure you’ll not have sneering comments about that in the Mail.

  4. AlanGiles

    Most politicians are fakes and phoneys – Miliband is no better and no worse than the rest, just playing to the gallery

  5. Dixies Mayor

    Is this Sarah Vine married to Mr. Gove?

  6. meredithtax

    Hey, nothing’s too good for the working class!

  7. Guest

    Ah, you know the rules for your fellows. My my.

  8. Bob Taylor

    I am not sure that any discussion re politicians’ kitchens is in any way relevant to the issues that need dealing with in this country. Have we really reached such a nadir in our level of political discussion that an entire article (or series of articles) about kitchens as an indicator of political intent can be taken seriously by anyone?

  9. Leon Wolfeson

    Unfortunately, negative campaigning tends to work.

  10. DianeHain

    I saw Sarah Vine, Michael Gove’s wife, on BBC This Week. What a shallow piece of work she was, emphasising with Justine on her role as Ed M’s wife, and her need to support her husband and finding similarities of view with her because she is in the same position (that’s a laugh for a start, Gove’s on his way down, Ed’s on his way up), then, when taken to task for her piece in The Mail, justified it because it was ‘amusing’. This had even the normally Tory soulmate, Portillo cringing at her behaviour. If this is what comfortable female journalists do for a living, then I would put that profession along side the venomous lowly second hand car salesman of old, say anything to get a deal & leave the buyer with a crud & debt. Isn’t that exactly what the Tories are doing to the country whilst all the time telling us that they are mending the fence. I don’t know how the woman can look herself in the mirror, she celebrates the worse aspect of any sex, but worse because she calls herself woman, she is a bitch through and through, and she celebrates it. She can’t therefore try the good woman bit when it suits her and her comeuppance on This Week is a good lesson.

Leave a Reply