Why a General Election isn’t going to solve Britain’s Brexit mess

It’s clear that we need an election - but after we have solved Brexit, not as a solution for Brexit.

On Thursday night, Boris Johnson announced he would be actively seeking a General Election to be held on December 12th – with the assumption being the EU would now offer the UK an extension to Article 50. 

A cynic may suggest that with the hype around an election, Boris Johnson just wants to ensure the new cycle is focused on whether Labour will grant him an election – as opposed to the fact that it means he has just broken the promise on which he built his career as Prime Minister.

He has spent months ensuring that we would have left the European Union on October 31st, and with less than a week to go, finally the government has to admit that isn’t going to happen.

It is an enormous climb-down, and James Cleverly must be unplugging that huge clock in Conservative Party HQ as we speak. 

But with all this talk of an election as the way forward to solve Brexit, can we be sure that’s what it would actually do? 

The Parliament we have now very much seems to represent the country – divided. The country doesn’t seem to be getting any less divided. How can we be sure the next Parliament won’t represent that as well? British Election Study analysis shows we’re on track for the most volatile election in decades.

What are we going to go if we spend all this money and time on an election, only for it to deliver a Parliament equally unable to make decisions?

The most recent solid evidence we have for this is the results of the European elections, with the Liberal Democrats and the Brexit Party gaining votes at the expense of the two main parties. The Tories might be ahead in the polls and confident of victory – but so was Theresa May. And it’s clear to everyone that the country is more divided on Brexit now, than it was in 2017. 

What’s also clear is that, unlike what ended up happening in 2017, any upcoming election will be dominated by Brexit. This is not good for democracy – elections are a chance for parties to put their visions to the country on a range of policy ideas.

If Brexit dominates, voters will be deprived of the legislative agenda they are voting for. When this stage of Brexit is done, whoever is in government may be enacting policies that weren’t properly discussed during the election campaign. Will people really know the sort of government they are voting for, if Brexit is all they base their vote on? 

It’s clear that we need an election – but after we have solved Brexit, not as a solution for Brexit, because there is no guarantee that it would be one.

Another hung Parliament is very possible, with vote splitting on both sides of the debate. That would only put us in even more of a mess now, and mean an election was a huge waste of time. 

The more sensible path for the country would be to have a People’s Vote, have the country answer the question on Brexit in and of itself, when it can be focused on and discussed in isolation.

Yes, we need a general election after: but it should be through the prism of knowing where our country wants to go on Brexit, not just guessing.

We cannot leave Brexit to the confusion of a General Election. MPs, on either side of the debate, trying to figure out the best way forward to the country should consider the only real, guaranteed way to get us out of this mess: a People’s Vote now, and an election later. 

Kira Lewis is an activist with For our Future’s Sake (FFS).

(See also: “An election is the least terrible option right now“)

Like this article? Left Foot Forward relies on support from readers to sustain our progressive journalism. Can you become a supporter for £5 a month?

8 Responses to “Why a General Election isn’t going to solve Britain’s Brexit mess”

  1. Tom Sacold

    It would help if the Labour Party put socialism and the interests of the working-class first by supporting a socialist Brexit to get us out of the capitalist club.

  2. Matt

    I’d agree but the votes aren’t there for a second referendum now. It’s going to be a GE and if Labour don’t win we are stuffed.

  3. ad

    Corbyn will never allow a People’s Vote. On Boris’s Deal, or any other. Corbyn wants a Brexit that either he controls, or that he can blame on the Conservative Party.

  4. Chester Draws

    The more sensible path for the country would be to have a People’s Vote, have the country answer the question on Brexit in and of itself,

    I believe we had one of those already. I caused the problem.

    A “People’s Vote” isn’t a solution, because the wording of the question will determine the outcome. If asked “Do you wish to leave the EU”, then a majority will vote “Yes”, but that gets us nowhere.

    If the question is “Do you wish to leave the EU on these very specific terms we have selected to ensure you vote No”, then another result will occur. But that is to game the result towards what you want, at the expense of what the people want.

  5. Julia Gibb

    Everyone is ignoring the elephant in the room!

    a) It has nothing to do with policy on Brexit or any other issue. The general public do not like Corbyn, they do not trust Corbyn, they will not vote for Corbyn.
    2) They see divided political party. If his own party don’t back him why should I.

    Regardless of how wonderful you think the man is you cannot win with him as leader. Please don’t respond with “the media attacks him”. It doesn’t matter WHY. He will not win public support. Success requires a new leader such as Stammer who will win over the public.

  6. ng

    Go out and vote, you plebs. It doesnt matter who for, we are ALL in the ruling class and you are the plebs. We don’t care who you vote for its all the same ruling class, we use different party names to fool you. And you keep voting for us! mugs

  7. ng

    Go out and vote, you plebs. It doesnt matter who for, we are ALL in the ruling class and you are the plebs. We don’t care who you vote for, we use different party names to fool you. And you keep voting for us! mugs

  8. ng

    vote, you plebs. It doesn’t matter who for, we are ALL in the ruling class and you are the plebs. We don’t care who you vote for, we use different party names to fool you. And you keep voting for us! ha ha ha

Leave a Reply