SNP warns Cameron to stay out of referendum debate

Alex Salmond believes a second referendum is inevitable


The SNP has warned David Cameron that it is not his role to ‘dictate’ to Scotland when and if it can hold a further referendum on independence.

Speaking on the Andrew Marr programme on Sunday, the former first minister and now MP for Gordon Alex Salmond, argued that ‘a second independence referendum is inevitable’.

In doing so, he cited the prospect of a failure to deliver in full the ‘vow’ made to Scottish voters ahead of the last independence vote, the EU referendum and the UK government’s welfare reforms as potential triggers for a further vote on Scotland’s future.

Responding to the comments during his visit to South East Asia however, David Cameron sought to rule out a second vote during the course of the current parliament. Asked if he would rule out another referendum before the next UK general election in 2020, Cameron responded bluntly, “yes”. He continued:

“I think it is important that a referendum is legal and fair and properly constituted and that’s what we had and it was decisive so I don’t see the need for another one.”

Asked what would happen if Scotland legislated for a referendum on its own, the prime minister replied:

“I took a very clear approach that these things must be legitimate and that’s my view.”

Responding to the prime minister’s statement however, a spokesperson for the SNP commented:

“The SNP are not planning another referendum, but equally it is not in the gift of any politician or party to rule it out indefinitely.

“The timing of any future referendum is a matter for the people of Scotland to decide – and not for a Tory prime minister to dictate.”

The issue is likely to come to a head at the SNP’s conference in October, when delegates are expected to debate the prospect of including a commitment to a second referendum in the party’s manifesto for the 2016 elections to Holyrood.

But speaking to pro-independence newspaper The National, one former leader of the SNP has warned the current incumbent not to commit to a second vote until it is felt it could be won.

Gordon Wilson, who led the party from 1979 to 1990, said the first minister should ‘by all means keep the option open’, but defy any calls for a ‘fixed time commitment’.

Wilson, now director of the pro-independence think tank Options for Scotland, explained:

“The time is not yet ripe. Support for independence is falling, indeed sunk to 43 per cent while support for the SNP itself is rising.

“Patience is required. It would be a strategic error to commit to a referendum until you know you are going to win.”

He continued:

“It will take a lot of character to resist the calls from enthusiastic but inexperienced new members or even those experienced hands who raise the matter prematurely.

“That is the mark of a political leader.”

Ed Jacobs is a contributing editor to Left Foot Forward. Follow him on Twitter

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

11 Responses to “SNP warns Cameron to stay out of referendum debate”

  1. Selohesra

    Salmond must realise that Scots dont have bottle to vote yes – they need to extend vote in the next referendum to entire UK ( it affects us all) – I’m sure the English wont be so feint hearted about weaning Scotland from our English teat.

  2. Jude42

    Lucky Scotland – we have to wait on the wisdom (?) of pro-consul Theresa Villiers before the time for a referendum can be declared appropriate. It’s called being a colony…

  3. stevep

    Having split the UK left vote and ushering the Conservatives in for another five years, Salmond`s utterances to Cameron smacks of the boiler in the Titanic calling the kettle black.


    If Scotland leaves the Union voluntarily then we will have border contols. Scotland will have no guarantee that they can trade with the EU. And England could refuse entry from Scotland into England. Scotland has to decide if they want to be a little isolated country living on shortbread and whisky.


    2 million people voted for the Union. Not all us Scots are narrowback Nat sis that want to dwell on Wullyum Wallace. The Nat sis have shown they have no respect for democracy and the will of the people.

  6. Jude42

    How odd, James. I could have sworn I heard the SNP leader the other day saying that they accepted the decision of the referendum. I’ll have to check my meds…


    They accepted it until they got over the shock then they said us no voters were conned. I was always voting NO irrespective of all the crap about extra powers. Scotland is now almost a centralised dictatorship. Salmond struts around like Kim Jock Eck a dictator in a fourth world country.

  8. Mark Myword

    Holyrood does not have the legal power to call a referendum without Westminster’s agreement. Any attempt to call such a referedum would be beset by legal challenges, the normal election mechanisms would be refused, and there would be boycotts of the vote itself if it ever went ahead. Nevertheless, if it did go ahead, and there was a yes vote, would Holyrood declare UDI and make itself a pariah state in the EU because the Westminster Government could never accept such a result as legitimate?

  9. Jude42

    James, James – a ‘centralised dictatorship’ that was elected by the people? I’m afraid my mental gymnastics aren’t up to that particular contortion

  10. rollo_tommasi

    How do you think the third reich came to power?

  11. Jude42

    Good point, rt. But I feel a bit uneasy comparing Nicola Sturgeon to Adolf Hitler….

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.