The government has got it totally wrong on higher education funding - it’s time for Labour to propose an alternative.
.
By Rory Weal
Figures released yesterday show that university applications from UK students for courses starting this autumn have fallen by 8.9 per cent. The drop coincides with the increase in tuition fees, to £9,000 a year, which the current cohort will be the first to experience.
These figures stand in stark contrast to the government line when tuition fees were increased in November 2010, when education secretary Michael Gove told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme:
“I believe that [higher fees] won’t put off students. They will make a rational decision on the benefits that accrue to them [from going to university].”
Yesterday’s figures have disproved Gove’s assertion that the prospect of having over £27,000 worth of debt will not deter students from applying.
These statistics show that the prospect of carrying such an extraordinary debt before even leaving university is making many young people, who would have previously considered going to university, reconsider.
What is equally notable is the differentiation in applications from England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. In England, tuition fees are at £9,000 a year, whereas in Wales and Northern Ireland fees stand at £3,465, and there are no fees for Scottish students applying to university.
Application figures clearly show that the slump is far more dramatic in England, with Scotland experience a far less significant fall. England has seen by far the most substantial reduction, down 10% compared with the same point last year. The other declines are of 2% in Scotland, 3% in Wales and 5% in Northern Ireland.
• Putting an individual through university generates £227k for the economy 9 Jun 2012
• A small mercy for the marching students of tomorrow 9 Nov 2011
• Coalition continues being wrong, wrong, wrong on its own tuition fees policy 7 Nov 2011
This clearly shows a strong link between increasing fees and declining applications. The government’s previous attempts to claim that the fee rise will not deter students has been shown to be totally incorrect.
Sally Hunt, leader of the UCU lecturers’ union, attacked the government for their pivotal role in seeing universities become inaccessible to many young people, saying:
“These figures once again highlight the folly of hiking up tuition fees to £9,000 and making England one of the most expensive countries in the world in which to access higher education.”
She went on to criticise the double standards of the Tory-led government, which gives lip-service to social mobility but in reality is making the situation far worse, saying:
“This government can talk all it likes about improving social mobility but how will erecting punitive financial barriers help our best and brightest get on?”
These figures are evidence of a government that is blocking the ability for young people to get on in life. The increase in tuition fees is just one element of a wider mix of measures which are ending any pretence that young people can still do well regardless of their background.
The scrapping of EMA has made education unaffordable for many young people while the slashing of youth centres has taken away an essential resource from kids from deprived areas. Now we see that increasing the cost of education has meant that many young people are simply not applying to stay on into higher education.
In light of these figures, Labour needs to be pushing for a radical overhaul of the regressive and unfair tuition fee system with a new mechanism, which Ed Miliband supported in his leadership campaign: a graduate tax.
Such a tax would get rid of the deterrent caused by the threat of taking on masses of debt and encourage young people to apply for university, not least those from disadvantaged backgrounds.
The government has got it totally wrong on higher education funding. It’s time for Labour to propose an alternative.
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 124 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
40 Responses to “Fall in applications undermines government claims fee rise will not deter students”
Will Slater
What a load of rubbish. I can tell you now, I asked my cousin if she was going to Uni, she isn’t political, she doesn’t care about that.
Me: Will you still be going to Uni?
Cousin: No, when you went it was £3000 or whatever, I don’t like the look of £9000 a year on my head with interest.
Also I would like to add, no one tells Sixth Form and College students they will have interest charged on top of their debt… Good luck paying for a mortgage and a car kids!
Poor people cannot afford Uni. Simple fact. I am from Oldham, North West England. Now Uni is a waste of time like anything else… No hope at all for anyone under 25
Leon Duveen
It’s not the Tuition Fees themselves that have caused the problem, as all those who have looked at it carefully agree that the actual cost of the loans under the new system will be LESS to most students, certainly fairer, than the old system.
No the problem is the constant harping on about the up front cost (which is not paid by the student but by the state) by the press, the Labour Party and groups like Left Foot Forward.
Selohesra
Perhaps if Miliband and co had acted a bit more responsibly and pointed out that you would only repay the loan if you got decent job and earned over certain thresholds – ie pretty similar to a graduate tax then more would actually understand how loans worked. Milibands blatent oportunism and scaremongering must play some part if student numbers drop off
marc
RT @leftfootfwd: Fall in applications undermines government claims fee rise will not deter students, writes @RoryWeal: http://t.co/KBM1z3jv
Alex Braithwaite
RT @leftfootfwd: Fall in applications undermines government claims fee rise will not deter students http://t.co/L03k6iN3