The government's rejection of stimulus measures to promote growth has left the British economy static, with declining growth and increasing inflation.
Although there were no substantial changes to economic policy in the UK during the last month, the chances of further steps being taken to support growth increased.
The IMF, in its annual review of the UK economy, called on the Bank of England to cut interest rates from their record low level of 0.5 per cent and to increase the level of quantitative easing. At its June meeting, the Monetary Policy Committee ignored this advice and left interest rates and the amount of QE unchanged, perhaps because its members are worried about inflation continuing to exceed their forecasts.
However, it seems inevitable that monetary policy will be eased again over the summer months, unless there is an unexpected rebound in economic activity. Meanwhile, the IMF also said the Chancellor should look at fiscal measures to boost growth. These should include shifting spending from areas that have a relatively low impact on demand to those that have a high impact, such as infrastructure spending.
In addition, if the economy remains weak, the IMF now believes that the Chancellor should slow the pace of deficit reduction.
Over the last year and a half, the UK economy has performed far less well than expected. Inflation has remained stubbornly high and, according to the official data, there has been no growth in real GDP.
Economists and politicians dispute the causes of this underperformance, variously blaming the government’s fiscal policy, high commodity prices and the crisis in the euro zone. In fact, all three have played a part.
Some economists have also disputed the picture shown by the official statistics, claiming that the economy is not as weak as suggested by the real GDP data. They argue that business surveys are a more reliable measure of economic activity in the short-term and point in particular to the monthly purchasing managers’ surveys, which suggest the economy continued to expand over the last 18 months, albeit at a subdued pace.
As supporting evidence, they highlight the employment data, arguing that increases in private sector employment are inconsistent with an economy that is not growing.
• Economic Update – February 2012: Double dipped 7 February 2012
• Economic update – January 2012: Outlook not all bad 9 January 2012
Historically, there have been periods when the evidence from business surveys has diverged from the official GDP statistics and later revisions have shown that the surveys were right and the official data wrong. But, as the statisticians point out, that there is no systematic bias to pessimism or optimism in their initial estimates and their best guess is that the UK is indeed back in recession.
Only time will tell which side is right. But there is no disputing the fact that growth has been sluggish at best and is unlikely to pick up pace in the next few quarters.
GDP down 0.3% in first quarter
Revised figures show real GDP contracted by 0.3% in the first quarter of 2012, a little more than the preliminary estimate of a 0.2% fall. This confirmed the economy is back in recession. Construction output dropped by 4.8%, probably largely as a result of the government’s cuts to its capital expenditure programme.
This drop was reflected in falls in investment spending and inventory building. Net exports were also negative for growth, so the failure of the economy to grow is reflected in its failure to rebalance towards export and investment-led growth.
Employment up – but only for part-time workers
Employment in the latest three months, to March 2012, was 105,000 higher than in the previous three months (though it was still down 7,000 compared to a year earlier). But the number of full-time workers was down 13,000 in the latest three months, while part-time working increased by 118,000.
Much of this increase in part-time working is involuntary. A record 1.42 million of the UK’s 7.99 million part-time workers say they want to work full-time. There has also been a big increase in self-employment (89,000 in the last three months), which might also be involuntary. See Figure 1:
On the Labour Force Survey (LFS) measure, unemployment fell by 45,000 over the latest quarter. As a result, unemployment in the three months to March was down to 2.63 million, or 8.2% of the labour force. However, long-term unemployment increased by 27,000 to 887,000 – its highest level since 1996 – and could top 1 million before the end of the year.
The claimant count measure of unemployment fell by 13,700 in April and revised figures show that it also fell in March. Here too, there has been a fall recently in short-term unemployment and an increase in long-term unemployment.
Retail sales slump
After a 2.0% increase in March, the volume of retail sales slumped by 2.3% in April. Sales in March were boosted by panic buying of petrol at the end of the month and good weather. In April petrol sales fell sharply and poor weather hit sales of footwear and clothing. Discerning the underlying trend in sales is difficult when special factors are having such a big effect, but it appears to have slowed a little after an increase around the turn of the year.
Consumer confidence very low
Consumer confidence increased a little in May as households reported improved sentiment about the outlook for the economy and their own finances. But it remains at a historically very low level.
Manufacturing output not growing
Manufacturing output was up 0.9% in March, but this followed a 1.1% fall in February. Output over the last three months was unchanged from its level in the previous three months, with seven sectors reporting increases and six declines. The underlying trend in output appears to be flat, as it has been for well over a year.
Business surveys mixed
The CIPS purchasing managers’ index for manufacturing slumped in May to 45.9 – its lowest level since May 2009 and the second biggest drop in the survey’s 20-year history – suggesting the sector is firmly back in recession. The construction indicator also fell in May, though only modestly. Meanwhile, the services index was unchanged at 53.3, suggesting the sector continues to expand at a slow pace.
Inflation down to 3.0%
Consumer price inflation fell from 3.5% in March to 3.0% in April – its lowest level since February 2010. The big drop was largely the result of the different timing of Easter in 2011 and 2012 (which has a big effect on travel costs, particularly air fares). Inflation is likely to remain within 1 percentage point of its 2% target for the remainder of 2012 and should fall further in coming months, though it has proved sticky recently. See Figure 2:
Average earnings increased by just 0.6% in the year to the three months ending in March, the lowest rate of increase since March-May 2009, when earnings were hit by large cuts in bonuses in the financial sector. Regular earnings, which exclude bonuses, were up only 1.6% and in the public sector are increasing at the slowest rate on record.
Export growth hit by euro zone crisis
Export volumes (excluding oil and erratic items) were unchanged in the year to the three months ending in March. Exports to the rest of the European Union fell by 4%, with the weakness concentrated in recent months, which suggests the euro zone crisis is starting to have an effect on the UK economy. Exports to the rest of the world were up 5%.
Government borrowing jumps in April
Public sector net borrowing (excluding financial interventions) was -£16.5 (i.e. a surplus) in April, but this included a transfer to government of £28 billion as part of changes to the Royal Mail pension scheme. If this is excluded, net borrowing was significantly higher than in April 2011.
Interest rates remain at 0.5%; QE at £325 billion
The Monetary Policy Committee left interest rates at 0.5% in June and the scale of quantitative easing (QE) at £325 billion. This was despite the minutes of May’s meeting showing there was serious consideration given to an easing of policy, and subsequent calls from the IMF for such a move. Members may still be a little worried by inflation’s failure to fall as rapidly as expected.
Financial markets became more risk averse
Equity markets dropped sharply during May and the FTSE-100 ended the month at its lowest level for over six months. Bond yields also fell and the yield on a 10-year gilt was down from 2.2% to 1.6% – its lowest ever level. See Figure 3:
Meanwhile, sterling fell against the US dollar but was up against a weak euro. All these moves can be explained primarily by increased concerns about the euro zone, particularly speculation that Greece would be forced to leave it.
As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.
We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.