Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says male-dominated boards will fall behind

The UK government will not support quotas to get more women into the boardroom - as a report says all-male companies will fall behind.

E-mail-sign-up Donate

 

.

Theresa May has told the European Commission that the UK will not support EU quotas to drive more women into the boardroom, even though a government report said all-male companies would fall behind their rivals.

Boardroom-womanThe report, from the Department of Business, said that considering 70% of consumer purchasing decisions are made by women, companies who fail to represent women fully in their boardrooms will lose touch with their customers:

“Continually recruiting individuals who share the same backgrounds and experiences creates a ‘groupthink’ mentality within the board, which runs the risk of making flawed decisions because there are no fresh or different perspectives.

“Ultimately, of course, such businesses will be unable to stay ahead of the game.””

Regardless of this advice, the home secretary and minister for women and equalities wrote to the commission on Monday, claiming that quotas are “burdensome” and the “voluntary approach is reaping rewards”:

“We abandoned the last government’s approach of simply trying to dictate how people should behave. We are encouraging firms to use women’s talents by helping them see the business benefits. But we must allow them to get on with their job.”

The government’s refusal to support quotas comes only two months after David Cameron said he would not rule out quotas to get women into high-level jobs.

At a summit in Stockholm, the prime minister said:

“The evidence is that there is a positive link between women in leadership and business performance, so if we fail to unlock the potential of women in the labour market, we’re not only failing those individuals, we’re failing our whole economy.

“So I want to get ideas in Stockholm that we can take back to London to explore if they could help us get more women into British boardrooms, boosting profits and contributing to the economic growth we all urgently need.”

 


See also:

New OECD data shows how far Britain lags behind in women’s boardroom representation 5 May 2012

Women, politics and the crisis: We cannot ignore gender in politics 16 Jan 2012

Boris is turning back the clock for women in London 14 Nov 2011


 

The refusal of support from May comes after the European Union justice commissioner Viviane Reding began a consultation into whether firms should be forced to appoint a percentage of women into senior positions.

Reding told the Guardian:

“It’s no secret that in countries where there are legal quotas [for representation on boards], the figures have grown substantially. In countries without obligatory quotas, progress is slow.

Norway is at the forefront of equal representation in the boardroom, after a 2003 law was passed requiring 40% of board members to be women. The percentage of women in board positions in Norway is now above target, at 42%. Iceland has also enforced a boardroom quota of 40% to be fulfilled by 2013.

In March, Left Foot Forward reported new data from the OECD showing the UK is severely lagging behind 21 other countries who had a higher representation of women in their boardrooms.

In the introduction to his ‘Women on Boards’ report, Lord Davies also rejected the idea of quotas, even though the report itself highlighted many advantages of having women in the boardroom:

Female directors enhance board independence. Women take their non-executive director roles more seriously, preparing more conscientiously for meetings. Women ask the awkward questions more often, decisions are less likely to be nodded through and so are likely to be better.

Boards are often criticised for having similar board members, with similar backgrounds, education and networks. Such homogeneity among directors is more likely to produce ‘group-think’. Women bring different perspectives and voices to the table, to the debate and to the decisions.

Kate Green, shadow equalities minister, today responded to May’s rejection of support:

“The minister for women Theresa May promised to help more working women and women in business, but warm words are not enough. The reality is that the Tory-led Government’s policies are holding both women and the economy back.”

The Tories are avoiding helping women into the boardroom by using their favourite ‘red tape’ excuse, whereas in reality it appears they just don’t want to enforce regulation upon their good friends, the greedy fat cats.

 


Sign-up to our weekly email • Donate to Left Foot Forward

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

20 Responses to “Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says male-dominated boards will fall behind”

  1. Catherine Max

    Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says all-male boards will fall behind, reports @KatieDagger: http://t.co/hpwEFFBD

  2. Matthew Graham

    Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says male-dominated boards will fall behind, reports @KatieDagger: http://t.co/hpwEFFBD

  3. Mario Creatura

    Remain unconvinced about the necessity of positive discrimination “@leftfootfwd: Tories denounce boardroom quotas: http://t.co/oCGWs6DD”

  4. Political Planet

    Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says male-dominated boards will fall behind: The UK government will … http://t.co/sNfV1L0Y

  5. leftlinks

    Left Foot Forward – Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says male-dominated boards will… http://t.co/247PyEJX

  6. Joanne Cash

    Don't often link @leftfootfwd but we are making a mistake on female boardroom quotas + loser is British business http://t.co/ojPQd6UH

  7. Selohesra

    Quotas are bad idea – you should get the position because you are the best candidate not just to fill up quotas. All women shortlists dont work either – ask Mrs Dromey

  8. Shamik Das

    Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says male-dominated boards will fall behind, reports @KatieDagger: http://t.co/hpwEFFBD

  9. Matthew O'Flynn

    Remain unconvinced about the necessity of positive discrimination “@leftfootfwd: Tories denounce boardroom quotas: http://t.co/oCGWs6DD”

  10. Benjamin

    Spot on. Also look at how Theresa May and Baroness Warsi have cabinet positions yet are both completely useless

  11. Anonymous

    This is funny, and nonsense.

    “The report, from the Department of Business, said that considering 70% of consumer purchasing decisions are made by women, companies who fail to represent women fully in their boardrooms will lose touch with their customers”.

    That’s what they have marketing, and other, departments for.

    Will the next argument be that companies selling into male dominated industries must have fewer women on their boards ‘to fully understand their customers”.

    There may be a political argument; I have yet to see a convincing economic one,

  12. Anonymous

    Well yes, but that’s not because they’re women. The entire cabinet is no better.

  13. Selohesra

    Indeed – if it was down to quotas Warsi would tick two boxes – all she would need to do is lose a limb & become a lesbian and she would have the full set – but she still wouldn’t be the best person for the job

  14. JC

    So where would you invest your pension? A company that has quotas on who can and can’t do certain jobs, or one that’s run by its management in order to make money?

  15. Anonymous

    A scam or a scam? I’d take a pension which isn’t a scam in the first place.

  16. Anne Baldwin

    Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says male-dominated boards will fall behind, reports @KatieDagger: http://t.co/hpwEFFBD

  17. Look Left – The evil of Assad, u-turns galore and the failure of austerity | Left Foot Forward

    […] secretary Theresa May, who this week said the UK would not support European Union quotas for women on company boards – despite a […]

  18. Colne Valley Labour

    Tories denounce boardroom quotas, as report says male-dominated boards will fall behind, reports @KatieDagger: http://t.co/hpwEFFBD

  19. Women have been in the British cabinet for 83 years, but the fight for representation isn’t over | Left Foot Forward

    […] live in fear of a repeat if another woman reaches the top. However, time and time again, research suggests that a gender balance is more efficient in areas like business, so why are these rules not applied […]

Leave a Reply