Fine words Mr Cameron, now it’s time for action on infrastructure investment

Ahead of the budget, Shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury Rachel Reeves calls on the government to act fast on infrastructure investment to boost the economy.

E-mail-sign-up Donate



Rachel Reeves MP (Labour, Leeds West) is the Shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury

Yesterday the prime minister made another speech about his government’s commitment to investing in Britain’s infrastructure, livened up with lofty rhetoric about emulating the Victorians’ vision, some shadow boxing about “vested interests and bureaucratic hurdles”, and a headline-grabbing “feasibility study” into the private financing of road improvements that, as shadow transport secretary Maria Eagle points out, raises more questions than it answers.

He isn’t wrong to highlight the urgent need to step up investment in our transport, energy and communications systems to boost jobs and growth and lay the foundations for our future economic strength. The trouble is, we’ve heard much of this before – with little yet to show for it.

A full five months ago (£), faced by mounting evidence his government’s austerity measures had choked off the recovery, sent unemployment soaring, and added £158 billion to planned borrowing, David Cameron announced a new “focus on updating our infrastructure”.

He said:

“In terms of job creation today, getting construction projects off the ground is critical. So this autumn, the government is on an all-out mission to unblock the system and get projects underway.”

Nick Clegg announced soon afterwards the successful bids for the second round of the government’s £1.4 billion Regional Growth Fund – in his words, a “boost to business, which will jump start growth and create jobs in the places that really need it”.

But by the end of February this year, it turned out that just £190 million of the £1.4 billion Regional Growth Funding announced by the deputy prime minister has actually reached the projects that have been promised help, with the other 73 per cent of approved bids still awaiting final sign off and disbursement.

The Times has reported that 40 per cent of the winning bids from the first round have not been signed off – 11 months after they were first announced.


See also:

Left and right should unite to support the creation of a National Infrastructure Bank 16 Mar 2012

Cable: Coalition lacks “a compelling vision of where the country is heading” 6 Mar 2012

Miliband: British Investment Bank could provide government banking for entrepreneurs when market fails 3 Feb 2012

Mandelson weighs in behind National Investment Bank 27 Jan 2012

The economy is crying out for more investment; we need a British Investment Bank 14 Jan 2012


And the centrepiece of George Osborne’s autumn statement was an announcement of another £5 billion cut from current spending programmes that “in the short term” would be used “to fund capital investments in infrastructure, regional growth and education as well as help for young people to find work”.

But scrutiny of the Treasury figures (pdf) reveals not a penny of this additional funding has yet been spent; only 16 per cent of it is due to come on stream in the coming financial year; and almost 45 per cent won’t be spent until 2014-15, the last year of the parliament.

Many of the projects that featured in Osborne’s speech won’t even get underway before then and some have yet to have their funding, planning permission or private partners confirmed. Meanwhile the promised platform to facilitate pension fund investment in priority infrastructure projects was only a Memorandum of Understanding, on which we await further progress.

No wonder both the Office of Budget Responsibility and the Institute for Fiscal Studies judged the impact of these announcements on growth prospects to be negligible.

Add to this picture the fact that, as shadow education secretary Stephen Twigg has highlighted, 18 months after Michael Gove tore up the Building Schools for the Future programme, we’ve seen repeated delays to its downsized replacement plan, with the first projects now unlikely to be tendered before June this year.

And, as shadow energy and climate change secretary Caroline Flint has pointed out, UK investment in green energy is still way below 2009 levels, with government figures suggesting very little pick up in 2011 – and we won’t have a proper Green Investment Bank with borrowing powers until 2016 at the earliest.

It is clear that after cutting too far and too fast resulted in stalling growth and soaring unemployment, this government’s newfound commitment to investment in infrastructure is too little, too late – but the need for action is urgent.

Office for National Statistics figures (pdf) show a 10 per cent drop in construction output in December, followed by another 12 per cent in January.

The Construction Products Association found this “extremely disconcerting”, noting:

“The government has made much play on private sector construction leading the recovery, as the public sector cuts begin to bite. Unfortunately from the ONS data out today, this recovery is just not happening.”

With growth stalled and unemployment rising, Labour is calling on the chancellor to use this budget to genuinely bring forward infrastructure investment so we can put people to work now on projects that would jump-start the economy now, help us get the deficit down over the medium term, as well as underpinning our economic development for the decades ahead.

Combined with other measures to stimulate demand and expand employment, it would also create the confidence we need to get private investment moving too.

In his speech yesterday David Cameron said his purpose was to “engineer a Horizon Shift” – but the problem is that the investment, jobs and growth he keeps promising are constantly shifting beyond the horizon.

The construction industry, the business struggling in a bleak trading environment, and the million young people looking for work don’t need another speech about the dim and distant future; they need a real plan of action that delivers jobs and growth now.


Sign-up to our weekly email • Donate to Left Foot Forward

21 Responses to “Fine words Mr Cameron, now it’s time for action on infrastructure investment”

  1. Anonymous

    Just which bit of ‘there is no money left’ don’t you get?

    Look at Vince’s plan.

    1. Borrow lots of money
    2. Give it to the numpties at RBS
    3. RBS will invest it where Vince tells them to invest.
    4. The public take the loss.

    Which bit of ‘growth won’t solve it’ don’t you get?

    If one unemployed person takes 12K a year in benefits, (Housing benefit included), and pays 3K a year in taxation when employed, that’s a 15K benefit in getting them back to work, for the government finances. Get a million back to work, and that is 15bn a year. The deficit is 150 bn. Where are you going to get the other 9 million unemployed from, and where are the jobs?

    Since that doesn’t work, why don’t you come clean and say, look the plan is to hit the ordinary working person for the money.

  2. Prateek Buch

    err, so what would you do that is different…?

  3. NonnyMouse

    When you ‘bring forward’ investment you leave a big hole in future spending.

    Labour ‘brought forward’ spending from today to 2009 and that is part of the reason why growth is slower today.

    When will Labour learn?

  4. keith ferguson

    Frm earlier, read Shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury @RachelReevesMP’s call for action on infrastructure investment

  5. Rachel Reeves

    Frm earlier, read Shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury @RachelReevesMP’s call for action on infrastructure investment

Comments are closed.