‘Cash for Cameron’: Minister quizzed on whether health bill was bought

During today's Parliamentary debate on the ‘Cash for Cameron’ scandal, minister Francis Maude was quizzed on the potential buying of the health bill.

E-mail-sign-up Donate



During today’s emergency Parliamentary debate on the ‘Cash for Cameron’ scandal, Cabinet Office minister Francis Maude, towards the end of an hour-long grilling from backbenchers over which policies may have been influenced by donations, was quizzed on the possibility that private health companies had bought influence over the health and social care bill.

Maude was asked by Ronnie Campbell (Labour, Blyth Valley):

“Can the minister give us details of any health companies, private health companies that were trying to influence the bill, have met in Downing Street for lunch, particularly Alpha Healthcare, which gave half a million pounds to the Liberal Party?”

Failing to answer the charge directly, he replied:

“Mr Speaker I can guarantee that there will be a great deal more transparency about what any health companies, dealings they’ve had with government and with ministers than there will be about the health service unions’ dealings with the Labour Party.”

Watch it:

This is not the first time the probity of the health bill, and that of Andrew Lansley, has been called into question in the House.

As Left Foot Forward reported last October, Lansley was asked by Kerry McCarthy (Labour, Bristol East):

“Given the Secretary of State’s own known connections with private healthcare companies, can the Secretary of State assure the House that he has been as transparent as possible about the influence of private healthcare companies on the passage of the health bill?”

It was an implication he strenuously denied.

However, the Daily Telegraph last year disclosed:

Andrew Lansley bankrolled by private healthcare provider…

John Nash, the chairman of Care UK, gave £21,000 to fund Andrew Lansley’s personal office in November. Mr Nash, a private equity tycoon, also manages several other businesses providing services to the NHS and stands to be one of the biggest beneficiaries of Conservative policies to increase the use of private health providers.

With the Sunday Mirror revealing:

A private health firm with close Tory links has won a £53million prison hospitals contract… ­despite an NHS bid offering a better service.

Care UK’s then boss John Nash and wife Caroline donated £200,000 to the Conservatives before the general election, including £21,000 to health secretary Andrew Lansley’s ­private office.

Now the company has won the huge contract to run health services for 5,000 prisoners at eight jails in north east England – with its cheaper, lower quality bid.


See also:

Cameron remains silent on dinner party guestlist – what does he have to hide? 26 Mar 2012

Has Lansley misled the House over links to private health? 28 Oct 2011

Exposed: Lansley’s NHS reform cheerleaders 16 Mar 2011

Under the microscope: Lansley’s private healthcare supporters 19 Jan 2011

Lansley’s links with health insurance industry 6 Oct 2010


With 40 peers who voted on the health bill known to have private sector health interests, and the Liberal Democrats now dragged into the H&SCB mire over their £500,000 donation from Alpha Healthcare, the ‘Cash for Cameron’ scandal could potentially get a whole lot worse than merely the (already shocking) idea the super-rich can buy a cut in the top rate of tax, but that private health companies can seek to kill the NHS by donating big money to a Tory health secretary and the Lib Dems.

We will have more on the questions over the potential corruption of the health and social care bill later this week on Left Foot Forward.


Sign-up to our weekly email • Donate to Left Foot Forward

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by becoming a Left Foot Forward Supporter today.