The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill

Alex Hern reports on the calls from the Financial Times to drop the NHS bill. Although they are attacking from the right, this will pile yet more pressure on the government.

 

The pro-NHS reform Financial Times has published a leader today pushing for the government to drop the “mess” that is the health and social care bill.

The paper begins by attacking the prime minister for failing to live up to his manifesto pledge to avoid top-down reorganisations of the NHS, but then praises the ultimate objectives of the bill. It lays the blame for its failings squarely at the feet of the “political skill”, or lack thereof, of the government, and Andrew Lansley in particular.

The leader concludes (£):

There is no easy escape from the mess the government has created. But its objective should be to pursue the course that offers the best chance of securing the substance of the reforms.

Dropping the bill and pursuing change without omnibus legislation looks on balance the better bet, even if it comes at a cost. The NHS is already adapting to the new structures. Some bureaucratic machinery might have to be rebuilt. Mr Lansley’s position would be weakened – perhaps fatally.

Although the FT is pro-reform, wrongly believing that “if the NHS is to become more efficient, as it must, there should be more clinical involvement in healthcare commissioning”, they have joined the CPHVA, RCGP, CSP, UNISON, UNITE, GMB, RCM, RCN, BMA, RCP, RCR, MiP, COT, IHSM and the Faculty of Public Health in calling for the government to drop the bill.

In May last year, Nick Clegg announced:

No bill is better than a bad bill.

Now that the consensus is that this is a bad bill, the time has come for him to live up to his words and join the coalition to save the NHS.

See also:

Ten reasons peers should vote against Lansley’s anti-NHS billShamik Das, October 12th 2011

Miliband goes on attack as fight to save the NHS stepped upShamik Das, February 6th 2012

Sign my petition to drop Lansley’s monsterDr Kailash Chand OBE, November 24th 2011

Don’t believe the spin – the health reforms are Cameron’s just as much as Lansley’sShamik Das, February 8th 2012

Lord Owen turns on coalition health plansWill Straw, January 19th 2011

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

41 Responses to “The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill”

  1. Adam McGibbon

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  2. MrHuish

    RT @leftfootfwd: The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/r9hpUERi by @alexhern

  3. Tom Vine

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  4. Daniel Wood

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  5. Andreas Baader

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  6. hilary fawcett

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  7. Fiona Montgomery

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  8. Pink Humanist

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  9. Dave Madden

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  10. Karen Webb

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  11. Political Planet

    The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill: Alex Hern reports on the calls from the Financial Times to d… http://t.co/TGkkfSry

  12. Pulp Ark

    The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill http://t.co/tDosA7xw #Public_Services_for_All #Andrew_Lansley #muslim #tcot #sioa

  13. Patron Press - #P2

    #UK : The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill http://t.co/7wvX2yPv

  14. Dave Russell

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  15. Pucci D

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  16. Pamela Heywood

    The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill http://t.co/NEu5mbeP

  17. Hens4Freedom

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  18. John Jackson

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  19. Joseph Burnett

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  20. Rosie Walters

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  21. Yrotitna

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  22. Lisa Sprince

    The Financial Times joins the calls to #dropthebill (and hints it wants #lansleyout): http://t.co/6Uv5fLpo by @alexhern #savetheNHS

  23. Simon Berriman

    RT @leftfootfwd: The Financial Times comes out against the #NHS bill http://t.co/dfNtWCpm

  24. Michael

    Pro-NHS reform FT pushes for the government to drop the “mess” that is the health and social care bill – http://t.co/Wr5I89LB

  25. Brian Moylan

    RT @TheRightArticle: Pro-NHS reform FT pushes for government to drop the “mess” that is the health & social care bill http://t.co/nu2ccL3H

  26. Johnny Chatterton

    I'm over the moon about this: "The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill"
    http://t.co/8jSQOKxR

  27. Carolyn Anderson

    The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill | Left Foot Forward http://t.co/xkV2fjxs

  28. Sarah Amani

    The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill http://t.co/a3IsdZT1 #nhsreform

  29. Andy Payne

    More & more voices are speaking out > The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill #savethenhs http://t.co/B7ShV3sQ

  30. Celia Kelly

    RT @leftfootfwd: The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill http://t.co/BKmhqwDK

  31. robert morgan

    RT @leftfootfwd: The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill http://t.co/E7AQCxBz

  32. Underthebed

    RT @leftfootfwd: The Financial Times comes out http://t.co/XgzOZg2Q

  33. Underthebed

    @chrisWhite_MP
    http://t.co/XgzOZg2Q

    #DropTheBill

  34. Yrotitna

    More & more voices are speaking out > The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill #savethenhs http://t.co/B7ShV3sQ

  35. Jo Bates

    Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill | Left Foot Forward http://t.co/p8oMfIrs

  36. Chris Salter

    RT @leftfootfwd: The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill http://t.co/vJ929aU3 #ppnews

  37. ConHome: Drop the Health Bill | Left Foot Forward

    […] know the health profession is against the bill. We know the public are suspicious. We know it will make more bureaucracy not […]

  38. What does QE3 mean for the real economy? | Left Foot Forward

    […] The Financial Times comes out against the NHS bill – Alex Hern, February 9th […]

  39. Fredricketts

    Let’s start, with a reform to the NHS, where the NHS, stops treating foreign illegal’s, that are being treated… http://t.co/keLPRDpv

  40. Even GPs implementing Cameron’s health reforms have come out against them | Left Foot Forward

    […] CSP, UNISON, UNITE, GMB, RCM, RCN, BMA, RCP, RCR, MiP, COT, IHSM and the Faculty of Public Health oppose the health and social care bill, health workers are backing the […]

  41. cameronsfollys

    Feb 9th 2012: The #Financial #Times comes out against the #NHS #bill http://t.co/NTHQVfke [Hmm!]

Leave a Reply