Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia

Ed Jacobs examines the Conservative party’s rhetoric on Wales, and how it doesn’t match up with their actions, and looks at the future of Scottish Conservatism.

In her speech to the party faithful in Manchester, the Conservative Secretary of State for Wales, Cheryl Gillan yesterday launched an outspoken attack on the Labour government in Cardiff Bay, declaring to delegates:

“Under Labour you wait longer for hospital treatment. Less money is spent on school pupils than in England. And the Welsh economy is weaker than every other part of the United Kingdom. Labour’s legislative programme is timid and uninspiring. Their plan for government vague. Labour is tinkering at the edges.

“They’re not using the powers they’ve got. Or getting to grips with the challenges facing our country.

Her remarks were echoed by Andrew Davies, leader of the Conservatives in Wales.

Their remarks however highlighted what amounts to a sheer hypocrisy within the party over its attitudes to the devolved bodies, as whilst Scotland Office minister, David Mundell, used his contribution to the conference to attack the SNP for being prepared to take the praise when good things happen whilst seeking to blame London for all that goes wrong, in Wales both Cheryl Gillan and Andrew Davies seem guilty of selective memory, failing to recognise their own responsibilities.

Firstly, in stimulating the economy, the Welsh government remains hampered by its inability to vary taxes as well as the UK government’s decision to hand Wales a substantially worse spending review settlement than the devolved bodies in Scotland and Northern Ireland.

Gillan’s remarks also failed to recognise Carwyn Jones’ pledge within his Programme for Government to establish a new Welsh Jobs Fund with a commitment that it would support 4,000 young people into employment. This as the UK Government faced criticism for its failed economic strategy by Andrew Tyrie, Conservative chair of the Treasury select committee.

On NHS Waiting Lists, Gillan failed to remind delegates that under her own Government, waiting times within the NHS in England are themselves on the rise whilst even the respected Kings Fund was forced to apologise for having got it’s numbers wrong over NHS spending in Wales.

Indeed, as Andrew Davies argued that the NHS in Wales was facing cuts worth £1 billion, so too is the NHS in England. Writing for the Spectator’s “Coffee House” blog, Fraser Nelson explained:

“Before the election, the Conservatives promised they’d “protect” the NHS, which they defined as increasing its real-terms budget year-on-year. This is a rather dangerous promise because it makes ministers hostage to inflation.

“Now that inflation has surged, expectations have been revised upwards, and it looks like the NHS budget will suffer a real-terms cut. In its monthly update of City consensus forecasts, the Treasury has released new figures for inflation over the next five years. Apply the latest inflation figures to health spending in the last budget and it implies a £1bn shortfall.

On school spending meanwhile, as the Telegraph reported in October last year that the school’s budget in England would increase by a meagre 0.1%, the Government in Cardiff Bay has pledged (page 12) to increase spending on schools by 1% above the block grant received from London.

Whilst Labour in Wales undoubtedly has lessons to learn from its time in power and how to best use its new found legislative powers, Gillan’s attack was an abject failure to recognise the impact that her own Government’s decisions are having on Wales. Little wonder that Shadow Welsh Secretary Peter Hain responded:

At the heart of the problem faced by our country is the lack of economic growth. As a result there are no job opportunities. The Tories will inflict another lost generation on our young people unless action is taken to reverse the Chancellor’s strategy.

Even senior Tory MPs are now critical of George Osborne’s approach. Welsh Labour has always said the deep and fast cuts are hurting Wales but not working. They are not working for the economy, not working for jobs and not working for the Police.

The one sensible thing that Cheryl Gillan could do in Manchester is to put the case for jobs and economic growth in Wales. I fear we will be disappointed as history has taught us the hard lesson that the Tories do not care about Wales.

In Scotland meanwhile, as David Cameron called for political parties to unite in taking on Alex Salmond’s campaign for independence it was his own party’s future in Scotland which seemed to be getting delegates fired up.

Ahead of a hustings event in Manchester involving the four candidates  bidding to take the helm of centre-right politics north of the border, the party’s only MP in Scotland, the Scotland Office Minister, David Mundell broke a vow of silence in attacking leading candidate, Murdo Fraser’s pledge to establish a completely new, independent centre-right force at Holyrood.

Writing for Scotland on Sunday, Mundell, who came out in support of Ruth Davidson’s bid for the top post in Scotland, explained:

I cannot support the disbanding of our party. It is a betrayal of our stalwart members and activists and the 420,000 people who voted Conservative at the UK general election.

“I had intended to remain neutral in this election contest, given my position as our only MP, and a government minister, but I cannot continue to remain silent. The prospect of winding-up SCUP and the threat of a serious split is too great.

“Let’s make radical changes, but let’s do so on the basis of building, not destroying. Then we can turn to the issues that really face Scotland.”

Yet for all the internal leadership navel gazing within both Scottish Labour and the Conservatives, what matters is not the organisational structures of the party’s, but producing a strong, coherent campaign in favour of Scotland remaining part of the union.  As the Sunday Herald warned in a comment piece:

“With a referendum on independence scheduled to take place in the second half of the current parliamentary session, and as the SNP juggernaut gathers momentum, there is a real need for reasoned and rigorous debate at Holyrood so that all the main issues can be rehearsed and aired.

“This can only come from decent opposition leadership, and that is why the Tories and Labour have to get it right – not just for the sake of their parties, but also for the sake of the country.”

Meanwhile, following a call by the Committee on Standards in Public Life for an end to the practice of “double jobbing” in Northern Ireland, Northern Ireland Secretary, Owen Paterson has pledged to use legislation if need be to ban the practices of members sitting as both MPs and MLAs.

See also:

Welsh government outlines vision for “fairer and more prosperous country”Ed Jacobs, September 28th 2011

Scottish Labour needs a new Donald DewarEd Jacobs, September 26th 2011

Memo to Mr Cameron – look to Scotland, where unemployment is fallingEd Jacobs, September 14th 2011

IoD: Wales feels like it’s back in recessionEd Jacobs, July 26th 2011

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

11 Responses to “Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia”

  1. Keith MacNider

    Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia: http://t.co/pFiChVU2 writes @EdJacobs1985 #ToryCon #CPC11

  2. Dan Couval

    Tory Welsh secretary's speech a demonstration of selective amnesia: … seem guilty of selective memory, failing… http://t.co/8U6u4bbX

  3. Ed Jacobs

    RT @leftfootfwd: Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia http://t.co/cvv2fOlZ

  4. Political Planet

    Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia: Ed Jacobs examines the Conservative party’s … http://t.co/WxDJy4zr

  5. Brian Moylan

    RT @edjacobs1985: RT @leftfootfwd: Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia http://t.co/60l6FrsR

  6. Michael

    Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia l Left Foot Forward – http://j.mp/oQYc0t

  7. Robert the crip

    But of course we in Wales are seeing a long period of decline I was down at Pembroke went over to Milford Haven to see Friends. Dear god you want to see American type ghost towns go down to those two, it needs a coat of paint and a lot of poly filler and some human being, go to the area around the Welsh Assembly what a difference. when the assembly was being built the took money from the EU which was supposed to be spent on area of decimation and spent it doing up the area around the Assembly even spending millions to knock down a building which affects AM view of the new water park they built. They even spent millions to get an architect to design where ten trees should be planted. That cost three million.

    The Welsh Assembly are master as spending as in England.

    But hospital waiting times are now up to Thatcher period, doctors appointments can take months and if you need to see a specialist your told the best way is to pay your £220.

    Thatcher is beginning to look better all the time, but yes we do get free prescriptions, but to many times we are hearing it cost to much it may have to end.

    But unless we get jobs before long sadly I can see the Tories making head ways into Wales

  8. Richard

    Three million to decide where to plant ten trees, poor Robert, I fear your mind has been irrecoverably poisioned with laughably prepoesterous ‘facts’ published by the Tory propaganda. For the sake of your soul and your family, friends and fellow countrymen, seek help fast before we have another mass murder on our hands.

  9. Anon E Mouse

    Richard – I have lived and worked in South Wales for the last 20 years and can assure you the waiting times at local hospitals are fiddled and are on the up.

    How long have you lived here btw?

  10. Wales calls for second u-turn on coastguard closures as Salmond hits out at Huhne | Left Foot Forward

    […] Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia – Ed Jacobs, October 3rd […]

  11. Welsh Labour has big decisions to make in face of budget gridlock | Left Foot Forward

    […] Tory Welsh secretary’s speech a demonstration of selective amnesia – Ed Jacobs, October 3rd […]

Leave a Reply