Miliband: “Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further”

Ed Miliband and Ed Balls have accused the Conservative party of trying to drive the last government further away from regulating the activity of the City of London.

Labour leader Ed Miliband and shadow chancellor Ed Balls have accused the Conservative party of trying to drive the last government further away from regulating the activity of the City of London.

Miliband today apologised for Labour’s part in allowing the ‘boom’ to get out of control before the economic crash, but was quick to remind critics that economies globally were affected.

“It is true to say that governments around the world got regulation wrong and the Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further.

“So this was something that politicians, economists, central bank governors, regulators, all got wrong collectively.”

His comments were in sync with recently appointed shadow chancellor Ed Balls’s regular column in Tribune magazine, out today, which similarly pointed out that lacklustre regulation of the City was the mistake of the Conservative party as well as Labour:

“Of course we didn’t get everything right. On regulation, Britain, America and the rest of Europe underestimated the risks.

“We should have ignored the calls from the Conservative Party and others – who at the time complained we were being too tough on the City – and been tougher still.”

As Left Foot Forward reported earlier today, George Osborne’s u-turns and change in rhetoric surrounding bank regulation is enough to make your head spin. In the good times, before the current government was elected, the then shadow chancellor hailed Ireland as:

“A shining example of the art of the possible in long-term economic policymaking.”

He went on, in the same Times article, to blame “chronic overregulation” for Britain “being left behind”; perhaps a euphemism for being left behind in the queue at the IMF. Idolising Ireland’s laissez-faire approach to the financial industry may be not be Osborne’s only misjudgement. The coalition’s prop of blaming the last government is nearing its sell-by date, and so may the Plan A approach to bringing down the deficit.

As Will Straw wrote for Left Foot Forward earlier this week, the Institute for Fiscal Studies’ most recent report highlighted the need for the government to consider an alternative, slower pase of fiscal consolidation – in other words, a Plan B.

Whether Mr Osborne is secretly putting an alternative arrangement together or not, tightening regulation of the financial sector will not, politically, be a policy for a chancellor who wishes to be remembered well by the Conservative elite.

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

27 Responses to “Miliband: “Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further””

  1. Ma

    RT @leftfootfwd: Miliband: "Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further" http://bit.ly/e8NV0I reports @Clairee_French

  2. Amanda Ramsay

    RT @leftfootfwd: Miliband: "Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further" http://bit.ly/e8NV0I reports @Clairee_French

  3. Shamik Das

    RT @leftfootfwd: @Ed_Miliband: "Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further" http://bit.ly/e8NV0I ft. @EdBallsMP (via @Clairee_French)

  4. Claire French

    RT @leftfootfwd: Miliband: "Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further" http://bit.ly/e8NV0I reports @Clairee_French

  5. Alex Belardinelli

    RT @leftfootfwd: Miliband: "Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further" http://bit.ly/e8NV0I reports @Clairee_French

  6. Richard Johnson

    RT @abelardinelli: RT @leftfootfwd: Miliband: "Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further" http://bit.ly/e8NV0I reports @Clairee_F …

  7. Malcolm Evison

    RT @leftfootfwd: Miliband: "Tories were encouraging us to deregulate further" http://bit.ly/garDz8

  8. Robert

    Are labour saying they were listening to the Tories, because Labour did deregulate, who was in charge Labour or the Tories or was it like we mostly thought Labour took what they thought was best and used it.

    I can remember the Tories saying something and the labour party using it.

    Lets just hope that in the following years something can be done to end this idea that banks cannot fail because they can and they should.

  9. Henry

    This is an attempt to set right the lies which the Tories and the media keep telling purposefully:”it’s all Labour’s fault.”
    Nope, it is not. Both Labour and Tories wanted and supported deregulation but now Labour are the only ones who are honest enough to admit this. I think Labour is in a cleansing process. They sort out their mistakes and will come up with better solutions and a new political programm soon.
    The Tories try to blame everything that goes wrong on Labour. But this starts looking pathetic. Labour (G.Brown) had gotten Britain out of the financial crisis an the economy was GROWING again at a moderate rate. Remember G.Brown saying in this Cameron-Clegg-Brown TV discussion:”If you take six billion Pounds out of the economy in an economic crisis you cause a recession.” This is soooo true.
    Shortly afterwards the Tories came to power. And the Tories cut cut cut. Allegedly Britain must cut the deficit as soon as possible. This is wrong of course. Debts have to be paid back IN TIME not immediately. And now barely one year later the economy is SHRINKING because of the Tories’ cuts.
    In my humble opinion Britain would do much better with Labour’s economic knowledge.

  10. Mr. Sensible

    Ed’s right; the whole regulatory system failed, and Labour should have done more.

    But for the Tories to say that Labour should have regulated more is political opportunism.

  11. sunny hundal

    @misselliemae This is Ed M a couple of days ago. http://bit.ly/fz5Ccd – what do you disagree with out of that?

  12. Tory dependence on City money should come as no surprise | Left Foot Forward

    […] with the revelation last week that, in opposition, they were encouraging the Labour government to deregulate further, the latter may be […]

  13. Miliband fails to nail Cameron on bankers, greed and regulation | Left Foot Forward

    […] the same David Cameron, who alongside George Osborne, were pressing that same government to deregulate further, complaining Labour were being too tough on the City – a point Miliband failed to […]

  14. Cormac Hollingsworth

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  15. Watching You

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  16. Al Boswell

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  17. Catherine Sharpe

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  18. David Gillon

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  19. Thom Hodkinson

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  20. Catherine Brunton

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  21. Phil Titley

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  22. Amiza

    And remember, the delightful Mr Osborne wanted the last Labour government to DEREGULATE FURTHER: http://t.co/0SULdsty #PMQs

  23. Beverley Clack

    Gd debate in the Commons on RBS, & fine words frm Mark Hoban – but remember, Tories wanted Labour 2 deregulate further: http://t.co/0SULdsty

  24. Cristiano Di Carlo

    Gd debate in the Commons on RBS, & fine words frm Mark Hoban – but remember, Tories wanted Labour 2 deregulate further: http://t.co/0SULdsty

  25. James Stewart

    Gd debate in the Commons on RBS, & fine words frm Mark Hoban – but remember, Tories wanted Labour 2 deregulate further: http://t.co/0SULdsty

  26. salardeen

    Gd debate in the Commons on RBS, & fine words frm Mark Hoban – but remember, Tories wanted Labour 2 deregulate further: http://t.co/0SULdsty

  27. Darryl Hansard

    Gd debate in the Commons on RBS, & fine words frm Mark Hoban – but remember, Tories wanted Labour 2 deregulate further: http://t.co/0SULdsty

Leave a Reply