Simon Hughes’ progressive claims don’t stack up

Simon Hughes thinks the Lib Dems are guiding the coalition in a progressive direction. But the economic damage done to Britain's communities - including his own - overshadow any good.

Simon Hughes MP, Douglas Alexander MP, Sian Berry, and Will Straw take part in a debate at tomorrow’s Fabian Society conference: ‘Challengers or collaborators:can progressives influence the coalition?’

In his column for last week’s New Statesman, Simon Hughes set out what he saw as the progressive influence of the Liberal Democrats in the coalition. Some of these reforms deserve credit and support, but the economic damage done to Britain’s communities – including his own – overshadow any good that is taking place.

Simon Hughes made a bold claim at the start of his article:

“We start the year not just in government but ensuring every week that progressive policy is agreed upon and implemented.”

While on Sky this morning, Hughes said:

“the Liberal Democrat contribution to government is to make sure we have a more liberal Britain & a fairer Britain economically”

Certainly there are many progressives who will support the advances in “constitutional and political reform” that Hughes cites. House of Lords reform is unfinished business from the previous government, a referendum on AV is Labour policy, and further devolution for Wales is a positive step. The coalition should also be praised for “abolishing identity cards, reducing detention without trial and having an independent inquiry into allegations of torture.” But these are hardly issues of concern to most voters.

It is on the economy – voters’ number one issue by a factor of four to one – that Hughes’ claims fall flat. In Southwark, the area Hughes has represented since a bitter by-election victory in 1983 and where I live, the damage to the community could not be clearer:

– 3,267 young people will lose out to the Government’s decision to scrap Education Maintenance Allowances (EMA).

– Southwark Council faces a headline 8.44% cut in its Budget in 2011-12 – close to the maximum level of 8.9%.

– There are 9,320 disabled people aged 16-64 in Southwark who will be affected by the Government’s arbitrary (and possibly illegal) plans to cut Disability Living Allowance by 20%. Of these 3,490 will be hit by the scrapping of the low rate care payments

– 1,340 housing benefit recipients will lose out due to the Government’s reforms which Hughes says he opposes but is yet to vote against.

– 3,100 families will be affected by the cuts to the childcare element of the working tax credit which will cost families up to £1,300 per year.

– every constituent will face an average bill of £389 from the VAT rise which Simon Hughes supported on June 28th despite saying “I hope that the Chancellor’s hearing the voices that say VAT is not the right tax to change in the Budget next week” just 13 days earlier.

– students living on the campuses in his constituency have already expressed their concerns with his broken promise on tuition fees by occupying his office.

Unlike his boss, Hughes avoided the temptation to blame the cuts on the erroneous claim that Britain was on the brink of a “sovereign debt crisis“. Instead, he parcels blame among “the legacy created by the international economic crisis, the greed of the banks” and rather vaguely “the decisions of the last government” which could mean either the light-touch regulation of the City or Labour’s spending plans – both supported by his party.

But there is an alternative to what Hughes’ government is imposing on his constituents. Hughes makes no attempt to justify the pace or scale of the cuts, which he opposed before he supported. Against this backdrop, the diluted rise in capital gains tax which brings in just £725m in 2011-12 means very little. Meanwhile, the as yet uncosted pledge to raise the tax threshold to £10,000 is a regressive and expensive way of targeting support at the low paid. It’s still early days in the coalition’s five years but as Simon Hughes’ constituents will tell him, his influence does not appear to be adding up to much.

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

21 Responses to “Simon Hughes’ progressive claims don’t stack up”

  1. Shamik Das

    RT @leftfootfwd: Simon Hughes' progressive claims don't stack up: http://bit.ly/dPabm8 writes @wdjstraw ahead of 2mrw's #fab11 conference

  2. Saggydaddy

    RT @leftfootfwd: Simon Hughes' progressive claims don't stack up: http://bit.ly/dPabm8 writes @wdjstraw

  3. Sunder Katwala

    RT @shamikdas: RT @leftfootfwd: Simon Hughes' progressive claims don't stack up: http://bit.ly/dPabm8 writes @wdjstraw ahead of 2mrw's # …

  4. Mr. Sensible

    I’m afraid this is very common from the LibDems.

  5. Daniel Pitt

    RT @leftfootfwd: Simon Hughes' progressive claims don't stack up: http://bit.ly/dPabm8 writes @wdjstraw

  6. Cornelius Griffiths

    Who is at #fab11 then? Is Hughes actually literally really speaking? https://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/01/simon-hughes-broken-promises/

  7. Bern O'Donoghue

    RT @leftfootfwd: Simon Hughes' progressive claims don't stack up http://bit.ly/gTL3OE Great article worth passing on, pls RT

  8. Simon Hughes: "I oppose EMA cut, housing benefit cut and NHS reforms" | Left Foot Forward

    […] was this last test Straw accused the coalition government of comprehensively failing. As outlined here, 3,267 students in his constituency will be affected by the abolition of Education Maintenance […]

  9. gretzer vill ha modernare t盲vlingskl盲der

    gretzer vill ha modernare t盲vlingskl盲der

    toms toms 10004761 蠁慰蠀尉喂伪 lacoste online outlet dames tassen mijn sinterklaas cadeaus the millennial blogger wejnxin hip hop coltrui losse trui hoodies vrouwen mode zelf uw eigen fauteuil samenstellen online of in de winkel vrouwen witte eendendons par…

  10. convertible flat shopping bag in yellow printed matt leather

    convertible flat shopping bag in yellow printed matt leather

    cheap robin fuck batman funny t shirt ganesh elephant bracelet sets stackable bracelets beaded bracelets bead bracelets gift for her gift for mom stack bracelets billabong wallet mens fendi costume da bagno boxer corto uomo j1y portafoglio di pelle di…

  11. john deere gray beanie ski skull hat cap skully cool style winter hat euc

    john deere gray beanie ski skull hat cap skully cool style winter hat euc

    mochilas maternales en mercado libre marshall major bluetooth tenis stan smith mujer lista de aparatos que funcionan con electricidad maletas ryanair cubanas de oro con diamantes precio 屑芯褞褖邪褟褋褟 屑邪褕懈薪泻邪 写谢褟 褋褌褉懈卸泻懈 胁芯谢芯褋 胁褟蟹邪薪邪褟 卸械薪褋泻邪褟 褕邪锌泻邪 alyaska 褋…

  12. For Galaxy J1 J2 J3 J330 J4 J5 J6 J7 J730 J8 2015 2016 2017 2018 mini Pro Soft TPU Quinn Phone Black Girl Negra Sexy Hot Woman

    For Galaxy J1 J2 J3 J330 J4 J5 J6 J7 J730 J8 2015 2016 2017 2018 mini Pro Soft TPU Quinn Phone Black Girl Negra Sexy Hot Woman

    Muhammad Ali Boxing Silicone Case Cover For LG K50 Q6 Q7 Q8 Q60 X Power 2 3 Nexus 5 5X V10 V20 V30 V40 Q Stylus TPU Print Cover Case 221b Sherlock Holmes For Huawei Honor Mate Nova Note 20 20s 30 5 5I 5T 6 7I 7C 8A 8X 9X 10 Pro Lite Play TPU Mobile Pho…

  13. reebok nano 2.0 for sale

    reebok nano 2.0 for sale

    tartan t shirt dress bright colored sundresses pointed shoes fluff yeah slide pink dawn nike janoski black and red nike air max ltd 3 black 魏慰渭蟺蟻蔚蟽蔚蟻 伪蔚蟻慰蟽 100 位喂蟿蟻伪 蟿喂渭蔚蟽 under armour mens goldgear granite fleece jacket 1280878 under armour womens hig…

  14. sund kage uden sukker og mel

    sund kage uden sukker og mel

    纬谓蠅蟻委蟽蟿蔚 蟿蠋蟻伪 蟿慰 伪谓伪谓蔚蠅渭苇谓慰 魏伪蟿维蟽蟿畏渭伪 term么metro digital infravermelho 60 500 c st 600.2 incoterm internal humidity temperature detector kako provjeriti je li napon uklju膷en. kako ispravno izmjeriti interfon copii rigi 1000 reer 谞注诇讬 住讗拽讜谞讬 诇谞砖讬诐 sauco…

  15. hamburg herren billiger ecco soft

    hamburg herren billiger ecco soft

    prada shopper kleiderkreisel puma rucksack pioneer backpack pleaser plateau stiefel sky 1020 schwarz online g眉nstig kaufen fell boots stiefel halbstiefel 2 st眉ck damen unterhemd damen baumwolle dehnbar geripptes t shirt best for kids violett jersey spa…

  16. fitflop femme shoes f sporty baskets tout noir afax

    fitflop femme shoes f sporty baskets tout noir afax

    sport lorrain basket ball le club affaire hommes nous notre nouvelle collection de basket classic cortez nylon pull col v sofia galeries lafayette en rose clair pour femme 1M plana de sincronizaci贸n del cargador Micro USB Cable de datos para tel茅fonos…

  17. 蟺伪蟽蠂伪位喂谓苇蟼 位伪渭蟺维未蔚蟼 2020 6 12 渭畏谓蠋谓

    蟺伪蟽蠂伪位喂谓苇蟼 位伪渭蟺维未蔚蟼 2020 6 12 渭畏谓蠋谓

    general aviation jacket jakke black sort para damas skechers t茫 aanis mascu ino bota adventure coturno mascu ino promo茫 茫 a3o. carregando 灏忓鐢?js 銇嬨倧銇勩亜鏈嶃伄銉栥儵銉炽儔6閬?zimowe ocieplane buty mruga a polski producent zimowe ocieplane buty mruga a polski prod…

  18. customized 19 20 ajax home kids kit

    customized 19 20 ajax home kids kit

    cipele s kockastim vrhom se vra膰aju u modu svatebn铆 拧aty art. 708 zimn铆 obuv demar hunter pro teva 啪eny original universal sand谩ly zp谩tky do 拧koly real madrid hoodie. size youth xl for sale in el paso tx offerup nike womens air max 95 premium pink oxfo…

  19. d臎tsk茅 boti膷ky pro nejmen拧铆 sebi

    d臎tsk茅 boti膷ky pro nejmen拧铆 sebi

    808 lounge sessel thonet einrichten von der affenjacke zum tropentarnanzug dopl艌ky na mobiln铆 telefony sportovn臎 elegantn铆 拧aty ewaco kovan茅 snubn铆 prsteny z nerezov茅 dama拧kov茅 oceli haut make up halloween schminke grau pockets kapuze mocha mouss rosa…

  20. winter no solid long v collar mini shift mini v neck fuzzy sweater dress

    winter no solid long v collar mini shift mini v neck fuzzy sweater dress

    folding multiple guitar stand red oversize hoodie ladies ropa para ni帽as oto帽o invierno nike fondos de pantalla chidos para celular hiken in duitsland haar vet na wassen trek uitverkoop fjallraven kanken 20l secador de pelo gama diamond ceramic bloedpr…

  21. maxi vestido lentejuelas plisadas fuera del hombro brillante manga larga fiesta negro

    maxi vestido lentejuelas plisadas fuera del hombro brillante manga larga fiesta negro

    da per 22 con super jubilee cinturino seiko acciaio inox a vestido palo rosa paris district dise帽o casual a un tono con una mujer en bikini negro y expresi贸n seria de pie ciklus bicikli zagreb bicikli cube nature lonac za umake gourmet star pakiranje 1…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.