Are Chris Huhne's bold claims about the outcome of Cancun justified, or will history, in the words of the Bolivian ambassador to the UN, judge it harshly.
Climate secretary Chris Huhne was very modest about the success of the Cancun climate change conference, although he bizarrely and, above all, mistakenly, claimed that there is now “an international commitment to hold the increase in global average temperature below two degrees Celsius”. This year’s global climate change gathering was by no means a headline-grabbing event comparable to that of the Copenhagen Summit just a year ago.
Simply put, public expectations were considerably lower due to the absence of media interest and speculation. Yet this ironically did not help to markedly improve the international commitment in preventing global temperatures to reach levels above the 2° C mark – typically considered as “safe” warming. Instead, independent analysis suggests the insufficient pledges made at Cancun will actually lead to a 3.2° C rise in temperatures.
Such an increase would have disastrous effects across the globe in the form of droughts, floods and food poverty, especially in states that are currently termed as third-world countries – a term found wanting in describing the future human suffering if nothing is done soon.
What is even more worrying is how the international community refused to incorporate agreed climate change measures into law. Since they are not legally required to fulfill their Cancun pledges, there is no inbuilt penal system. Without penalties, there is little motivation. Without motivation, a 3.2° C rise in temperatures seems at first glance very optimistic.
At second glance, however, there is hope, because what Cancun did succeed in doing was to partly bridge the gap between developed and developing states.
For example, by agreeing on rich countries paying poor countries in compensation for not chopping down huge swaths of forests, states such as Indonesia (3rd worst polluter in the world) are likely to reduce their carbon emissions by an unprecedented level. In addition, a newly appointed committee will seek to ensure that knowledge of green technology will undergo a transfer within a set-up network in order to assist disadvantaged countries.
Nonetheless, Huhne’s claim of him having achieved a “triumph for the spirit of international cooperation in tackling an international threat” is absurd.
Apart from rich countries repeating their non-binding arbitrary aspiration of raising $100 billion in climate aid by 2020, attendants showed great reluctance on agreeing upon any exact financial numbers, what contributions will be made by individual states, how emissions cuts will be inspected and verified, and what will replace the Kyoto Protocol, without which we will inevitably be heading for a climate catastrophe.
Yet most crucial of all, our governments in the west have once again shirked their climate responsibilities by refusing to make any of their Cancun cuts legally binding. In the words of Pablo Solon, the ambassador of Bolivia – a country that is suffering under severe drought and whose people are starving – to the UN:
“History will judge harshly.”
Perhaps so, but if the international community do not get their act together at next year’s climate conference in South Africa and agree on substantive and binding agreements, it will be our children’s children who will judge harshest of all.
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 124 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
8 Responses to “Can Cancun deliver?”
Steve Smith
RT @leftfootfwd: Can Cancun deliver? http://bit.ly/f4j4iw
Matthew
RT @leftfootfwd: Can Cancun deliver? http://bit.ly/fQf8u2
Farid
To ensure Rights for all
save a bit, reserve, preserve, conserve resources
Let’s achieve significant change in mindset, behavior and attitude combat Climate Crisis, Reduce Risk & Poverty, save Bio-diversity – Peace for Humanity
Way to Combat Climate Crisis, save Bio-diversity, Reduce Risk of Humanity
sasrai – work locally-serve globally, initiative local-outcome global
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=8450962401&ref=ts
http://sasrai.wordpress.com/sasrai-movement/
http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=86904&id=1095651282&l=abe1a204ea
http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=18927&id=100000452565165&saved
http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=42007&id=100000452565165&l=30fc880016
To ensure Rights for all
Let’s we all have significant change in mindset, behavior and attitude
save a bit, reserve, preserve, conserve resources
AIMED AT SUSTAINABLE LIVING, ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
Dear Friends
Scholars, Intelligentsia, outstanding professionals from government, business, finance, journalism, NGOs and other fields………………………………………………
Please
a. get together – Help the sasrai-Movement within Your limit
b. have initiative to serve the cause through your network
Please Keep a hand written sasrai-Movement Poster — in any discussion area
Let’s have zeal to self tune in sasrai-Movement policy and be committed to save resource and reduce solid waste in our daily living – no matter how small it is. Plz relentless to voice from each corner across the globe
Please, save a drop of water daily, during all water related activities
Please, plant at least a Native tree annually in own home or in the community
Please, keep off electric appliances one minute daily
Please, suspend travel by personal car once a day
Please, keep a day in a week luxury free
Please, do not throw away the waste wherever you like
Please, No more junk food
Please, save one minute to think on Climate Change and Environment
You Can Reduce CO2 Emissions, Plant Native Trees Worldwide
You could uphold the movement instantly using sasrai-Movement appeal at the bottom of your all printed material
Let’s be a desired friend to all living body, humanity, environment and earth
Let’s we try to save one Taka/dollar/pound/yen …………FROM daily LUXURY combat the CLIMATE CHANGE and the sequences
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=8450962401&ref=ts
http://sasrai.wordpress.com/sasrai-movement/
http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=86904&id=1095651282&l=abe1a204ea
http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=18927&id=100000452565165&saved
http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=42007&id=100000452565165&l=30fc880016
AIMED AT SUSTAINABLE LIVING, ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
save a bit, reserve, preserve, conserve resources
sasrai – work locally-serve globally, initiative local-outcome global
pontaprint
There is no unambiguous signal of human induced climate change. That is a FACT.
What you’ve seen over the last 10 years (little change), the last 100 (increasing temperatures), the last 1000 (down then up), 10,000 (down), 30,000 (up), 3 million (down), 30 million (down) is probably just natural cycles. Even Phil Jones admitted as much when he said the thing that made him think last century’s warming was human induced was that it couldn’t be explained by 2 things, volcanoes and the sun!! What about the rest of the influences????
Mr. Sensible
Pontaprint I’m afraid the argument has moved on.
Even the Daily Mail believes that humans are having an impact!