Iain Duncan Smith has called for social tenants to be more prepared to move to find work where none exists where they live. However, nowhere has concern over the plan provoked such negative reaction to the Government's position than across Scotland and Wales.
“Get on your bike” was the advice handed out by Norman Tebbit to the unemployed in the 1980s. Now, in 2010, in a Telegraph interview his successor as MP for Chingford and Wood Green, the new work and pensions secretary Iain Duncan Smith, has called for social tenants to be more prepared to move to find work where none exists where they live.
However, nowhere has concern over the plan provoked such negative reaction to the Government’s position than across Scotland and Wales.
Scotland
In 2002, following his now famous visit to the Easterhouse council estate in Glasgow, Mr Duncan Smith, as leader of the Conservatives at the time, told his party that it needed to address the social deprivation that he witnessed on his visit. He had said:
“It’s about being a party that doesn’t just drive past Easterhouse on the motorway. If politicians cannot help the millions of people on estates like Easterhouse then politics has failed.”
At the time, the Herald reported it as his attempt to dump his party’s Thatcherite past. However, following his latest proposals, the Tories’ main political opposition in Scotland, Labour and the Scottish National Party, concluded that Mr Duncan-Smith is taking the Tories back to the past.
For Labour’s Iain Gray, the Secretary of State’s remarks suggest a lack of understanding about Scotland. He said:
“Iain Duncan Smith’s comments show how little the Tories understand the reality of life for those seeking work or living on low incomes. His choice of language simply echoes Norman Tebbit’s ‘get on your bike’ insult, showing that the Tories have not changed since the time of Margaret Thatcher.
“Families cannot move around the country every time a parent is out of work. We have to create jobs here in Scotland. That is why cancelling the Future Jobs Fund was an outrageous decision, made worse by the budget decisions which will cost another 100,000 jobs.”
Meanwhile, the SNP’s spokesperson on work and pensions, Eilidh Whiteford, sought to tie in the announcement with a wider attack on the Government’s broader economic policies, saying:
“Instead of endangering economic recovery with short-sighted cuts and reverting to policies which proved disastrous in the 1980s, the new coalition Government should be investing in growth and job creation across the UK.”
Wales
In Wales, which earlier this month saw the number out of work fall, the Assembly Government has expressed its concerns that the Department for Work and Pensions does not fully understand Devolution, particularly its responsibilities for housing policy, with a frank admittance that education minister Leighton Andrews had requested a meeting with Mr Duncan Smith.
A spokesman for the Government said:
“The [minister] responsible for relations with the Department of Work and Pensions, Leighton Andrews, last week asked for a meeting with Mr Iain Duncan Smith out of concern that DWP Ministers may not fully understand the different processes operating in Wales, post-devolution.”
Responding to the criticism, Conservative shadow housing minister in Cardiff Bay, Mark Isherwood, said:
“Iain Duncan Smith highlights one possible practical solution to a real problem facing people at a time of housing crisis and massive waiting lists across England and Wales.
“The new UK Government has committed itself to a respect agenda which acknowledges devolution and pledges to work in co-operation with the devolved administrations.”
18 Responses to “IDS told to get on his bike”
Mr. Sensible
This isn’t helping places like Easterhouse; it is writing places like Easterhouse off.
We’re not just getting a generation lost to work; we’re getting areas lost to prosperity.
It is good to see the SNP coming off the ‘independence’ agenda and talking sense.
blogs of the world
Iain Duncan Smith has called for social tenants to be more prepared to move to find work w… http://reduce.li/sd3a5k #his
winston k moss aka 9xzulug
north/side divide widens further and further apart.no wonder scotland,wales,northern ireland want their own independence.sadly we all ignoring the fact that we all awaiting on voting reform which will help in realigning logical politics
Robert
Wales does not want Independence, for god sake we’d lose 15 billion, what we want is law making powers and tax raising power which is basically the same.
The Tories knowing this have stated we can have a vote on it this year labour wants it next year. The problem for Labour if we get law making and tax raising powers, they the English election will mean nothing to those in Wales, which could mean labour losing the votes from Wales, which the Tories would love.
Evidence based? Really?
Seriously though, why is this such a problem policy? Millions of polish people come over here every year to find work (don’t tell ed balls) and they don’t seem to have a problem; is there seriously something that prevents the Scottish and welsh from doing the same?
The simple fact is, even after 13 years of ‘progressive’ government, there are people who live in places where there are entrenched cycles of poverty. Why is not acceptable to say that, having claimed off the state (thus ensuring tax payers have made provision for you) that you make a compromise to ensure the long term viability of the welfare system and provide value for money. I’m all for welfare for those who need it- its good to improve peoples life chances- but leaving people on sink estates with not enough work is not a sustainable way to acheive this.