Unemployment is no better for the Scottish government than for the British one

Matthew Pitt explains why the SNP can't be smug about their unemployment figures, no matter what they may claim.

The short-lasting honeymoon period for youth unemployment figures in Scotland is over and there is now a real danger of a generation being abandoned by an overzealous government in Westminster and a single-minded SNP government in Holyrood that is following the wrong priorities.

Scottish unemployment rate now stands at eight per cent, an increase of 0.3 percent from last month. Although the rate remains below that of the UK, it is important not to be lured into a false sense of security concerning the robustness of the Scottish economy and its ability to withstand the austerity cuts that are still to come.

There are four main areas that are being neglected or misrepresented by the SNP that Labour is demanding urgent action on in order to build an economy fit for purpose and avoid forcing a whole generation out of the labour market.

Firstly, the boast that headline unemployment figures are better than those in the UK overall mask the fact that the number of 16-24 year olds claiming Jobseeker’s Allowance increased by 0.3 per cent compared to last year and youth unemployment by 14,000 since last month.

The urgent need to get young people into work cannot be understated. With 84,000 youth now unemployed in Scotland, it is time for the SNP to stop blaming Westminster and turning a blind eye to the austerity cuts whose real effects will hit Scotland in 2013.

Addressing an already disadvantaged group in the jobs market, it is vital to ensure young people get the access and support they need to find a job.

As part of its five point plan, Labour has therefore proposed a two billion pound tax on bank bonuses to fund 100,000 jobs for young people and build 2,500 more affordable homes. Without the necessary skills and experience early on in life, there is a real danger of creating a lost generation and the SNP need to urgently face the truth that it has no plan to fix the problem.

The second argument by the SNP is the claim that Scotland is faring better compared to the UK, which is simply not true. Employment is now more than three per cent under its pre-recession peak despite the total UK employment experiencing greater recovery and now stands at over 1.5 per cent

To help the Scottish economy, Labour has called upon the government to help small business throughout the country by introducing a one year national insurance tax break for every small firm that takes on extra workers.

Thirdly, blaming the dire state of the economy on the troubles in the eurozone is not supported by figures.

The eurozone itself grew three times faster than the UK did over the last year whilst growth in Scotland has been almost flat in the first two quarters this year and business surveys indicate no tangible improvement in the third quarter.

According to the latest data available by the Scottish government, Scotland remains under its pre-recession GDP by a staggering four per cent and yet the SNP has cut capital investments more than double compared to the UK in the last two years.

In order to boost job growth and avoid any further weakening of the Scottish economy, Labour is urgently demanding the SNP to bring forward long-term investment projects, such as schools, transport and road.

Fourthly, the SNP overlook the fact that Scotland has a much stronger bias towards part-time work than the UK. The drop in full time workers in Scotland continues and the most recent data record a 1 per cent change since last year. This has been overshadowed by a burgeoning part-time uptake. Having fallen by a mere 7,000 during the recession, it has now grown by more than 43,000 higher than the pre-recession peak.

With a lack of full-time employment jobs, it is important to help squeezed households and businesses at a time of increased hardship. For this reason, Labour is demanding that the government reverse its damaging VAT rise for a temporary period and cut VAT on home improvements, repairs and maintenance to five per cent for one year in order to help struggling families, businesses and pensioners and .

Instead of avoiding the problems plaguing the Scottish economy, both governments need to tackle the issues undermining the prospects for growth and focus on implementing Labour’s five-point plan in order to get the economy moving and full-time jobs growing.

See also:

Million young unemployed figure highlights enormity of the situation hitting our youthRory Weal, November 16th 2011

Devolved nations call on Whitehall to create jobsEd Jacobs, October 12th 2011

Memo to Mr Cameron – look to Scotland, where unemployment is fallingEd Jacobs, September 14th 2011

Jobs and growth figures from Wales and Scotland deepen the gloomEd Jacobs, July 21st 2011

Vote 2011: Scottish Labour “will keep standing up for Scottish jobs”John Park, April 21st 2011

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

9 Responses to “Unemployment is no better for the Scottish government than for the British one”

  1. CAROLE JONES

    Unemployment is no better for the Scottish government than for the British one, writes @mpittparliament : http://t.co/Z0xg9EIf

  2. matthew pitt

    Read my piece: Unemployment is no better for the Scottish government than for the British one | Left Foot Forward http://t.co/ubfhkOOv

  3. High inflation + high unemployment = misery, misery, misery... | Left Foot Forward

    […] also: • Unemployment is no better for the Scottish government than for the British one – Matthew Pitt, November 16th […]

  4. Wayne Strnad

    Unemployment is no better for the Scottish government than for the British one http://t.co/4dtfNejq

  5. Alasdair

    The second paragraph of this article undermines its entire premise, by admitting that the unemployment situation in Scotland *is* better than the rest of the UK.

    I don’t really understand the need to attack the SNP government when they’re providing a clear demonstration of how to run an economy in a more progressive way than that of the socially destructive coalition.

  6. Glynbeddau

    At least Scotland under the SNP seem to have some Plan. In Wales where Unemployment is 9.3% we have A Labour Government that hs been in power since the Assembly first sat. The current administration seem to think the best thing to do is nothing and then blame it on the Tories.

    The SNP what ever you say looks like a vibrant government and therefore more likely to attract business. The only part of the UK with a Labour government look like they have no answers.

    Of course thy do don’t have overall control in the Welsh Assembly and will use this as excuse for their lethargy where their flagship legislation (now they have some) has been about introducing bike lanes

    But the last Scottish Parliament saw the SNP looking like a government on top of things (Hence their landslide).

    By the way isn’t that photo beneath you?

  7. Shug the Profound

    Alasdair, this guy kids himself on he’s some kind of socialist internationalist. In reality he’s just another Brit-imperliast Labout hack. THAT’s why he needs to attack the SNP). An SNP government that has done more to protect Scottish workers in the last few years than Labour ever did in the preceding century.
    The don’t like it up ’em and they don’t like getting shown up either.

    edited -spelling

  8. Look Left – Tories past and present battle to out-nasty each other | Left Foot Forward

    […] Wednesday on Left Foot Forward, Matthew Pitt reported how the unemployment figures in Scotland are no better than those for Britain as a whole: “The […]

  9. Swinney calls on Osborne to “change course” on Scottish investment | Left Foot Forward

    […] also: • Unemployment is no better for the Scottish government than for the British one – Matthew Pitt, November 16th […]

Leave a Reply