Medicine menus: How the NHS is being chipped away by stealth

"Rationing must be called out for what it is – privatisation driven by rationing," says John Puntis of Keep Our NHS Public.

The government will never admit to privatising the NHS, and certainly not to charging patients for what many would consider essential treatment, but shockingly, through a combination of rationing and outsourcing, this is happening right now in front of our eyes.

For the past year individual Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs) have been rationing a whole range of much needed treatments, grouping 17 restricted procedures under the heading of ‘Procedures of Low Clinical Effectiveness’ but the fact that this is happening has slipped by under the radar for many who are currently unaffected. 

At the same time, the Department of Health and Social Care and NHS England (NHSE) contradict themselves by insisting that the NHS will continue to offer a comprehensive service to patients, free at the point of use. The issue of “self-funding” patients now blows this claim wide open.

Warrington and Halton Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust hit the headlines recently with its long list of “affordable self-pay” procedures and price lists including cataract operations and hip and knee replacement surgery.

The menu of paid procedures at Warrington was called: ‘My Choice’ and promoted under the strap line – ‘My Choice is by the NHS, for the NHS’. CCGs are seeking to restrict treatments in order to adjust to a chronic shortage of resources. 

Sustained government underfunding over the last 9 years, coupled with a clinical vacancy rate of over 50,000 means that the NHS is significantly short of both money and staff, and this is clear to most people. 

Waiting times for elective surgery are now the longest they have ever been – with nearly 5 million people on the list, and Trusts are suffering record deficits.

It’s no surprise therefore that one response to this funding crisis is rationing of care, although this term is never used. The reality has not only been revealed by ‘My Choice’ but also by the numbers of exceptional funding requests, originally used to limit cosmetic and fertility treatment, but recently showing a massive increase for other interventions including hip and knee surgery, as CCGs try to limit patient access.

A cost of at least £7,000 for a new hip is beyond the reach of many of us, let alone elderly people on state pensions who have paid into the system all their lives. 

This was never how the NHS was supposed to work. Dressing up procedures as ‘of low clinical effectiveness’ is an affront to the founding values of the NHS, and nothing short of a disgrace in the sixth richest world economy.

It’s revealing that NHSE appears unconcerned about the variation currently seen in how CCGs commission for surgical procedures such as highly cost-effective cataract surgery, where most CCGs are now flouting existing NICE guidance and restricting access for patients.

This system, introduced gradually, is intended to normalise the idea of paying for some treatment that is ‘no longer available on the NHS’. It is clear that Trusts are seeing this as a commercial opportunity, being encouraged as they are to become more business-like and increase their income from private work.

Warrington NHS trust may now have withdrawn their charging processes after a barrage of negative publicity but in the current climate it won’t be the only trust to try something like this. In asking patients to ‘self-fund’ (pay) it was sending out a clear message that the government has moved to a system whereby patients will increasingly be expected to foot the bill for essential treatment previously available on the NHS. 

The list of limited treatments will grow over time and is already hugely undermining of the health service’s founding principles. It must be called out for what it is – privatisation driven by rationing. 

This move is a very slippery slope, and it’s clear that patients will suffer. Fully renationalising the NHS is the only real way to save a comprehensive and essential service for us all.

Dr John Puntis is co-chair of Keep Our NHS Public and a retired Consultant Paediatrician.

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

3 Responses to “Medicine menus: How the NHS is being chipped away by stealth”

  1. Tom Sacold

    The NHS should be fully funded so that all British citizens get free health care. Foreigners should have to pay for the service through their travel insurance.

    British workers should not have to pay for foreigner’s health care.

  2. steve

    During the New Labour, Blairite era much was done to privatise the NHS. Indeed, Gordon Brown believed only the private sector could effectively run the NHS (see Prof. Allylson Pollock’s book book NHS Plc (2005) – Pollock was senior adviser to the Blairite government.

    Will the Blairite majority within the PLP back “Fully renationalising the NHS”? It is doubtful.

    If they were keen to back renationalisation they would abandon their relentless campaign to undermine Corbyn and the Labour Party.

  3. Blissex

    «A cost of at least £7,000 for a new hip is beyond the reach of many of us, let alone elderly people on state pensions who have paid into the system all their lives.»

    That’s just verbiage: most of its users never “paid into the system” enough to cover their costs, and some unfortunate ones never “paid into the system” at all, but they can still use it. The NHS is not a self-insurance system, it is welfare (group insurance, taxpayer funded), just like state pensions.

    And that’s why the Conservatives want to privatize it: they see no reason why high income taxpayers should pay for expensive operations for people who never contributed enough to fund them for themselves. There are very good reasons for them to do, but “have paid into the system all their lives” is at not one, it is best a tenuous excuse.

Comments are closed.