Clarke and Thornberry accuse government of ‘long-grassing’ torture inquiry

The UK has been accused of complicity in torture.

Ken Clarke and Emily Thornberry have accused the government of repeatedly delaying a judge-led inquiry into the UK’s complicity in torture.

Speaking in parliament, former Tory justice minister Ken Clarke criticised the government for delaying a judge-led inquiry which Cameron’s coalition government first promised in 2010.

Further promises of a judge-led inquiry were made in 2012 and in July 2018, a decision on whether to launch such an inquiry was promised within 60 days.

“For years and years, this has been put into the long grass in the hope that it would eventually go away,” Clarke said.

Labour’s Shadow Foreign Secretary echoed Clarke’s comments, referring to delays as “unfortunate long grassing”.

Deputy Prime Minister David Lidington promised a decision by the end of the week although he refused to say whether the decision would be announced to parliament verbally or in a written statement.

The inquiry would look into allegations that, after 9/11, the Labour government had been involved in the rendition and torture of detainees.

Rendition is when someone is passed over from one country’s authorities to another.

Parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee found that the UK had planned, agreed or financed 31 rendition operations.

It also found there were 15 occasions when UK intelligence officers consented to or witnessed torture, and 232 occasions on which UK intelligence agencies supplied questions to be put to detainees who they knew or suspected were being mistreated.

One example is that of a Libyan couple called Abdel Hakim Belhaj and Fatima Boudchar.

They were kidnapped in Bangkok and handed over to Colonel Gadaffi’s regime in Libya where they were tortured. Theresa May has apologised for the MI6’s role in the couple’s ordeal.

According to Clarke and Thornberry though, the Intelligence and Security Committee was not able to get to the full truth because it was not allowed to interview certain intelligence officers. A judge-led inquiry would have more powers to interview witnesses.

Thornberry said that, as well as investigating abuses under the Labour government, an inquiry should look at the role of the secret courts which were introduced by the Tory-Lib Dem coalition in 2013. Clarke was the justice minister who introduced them.

These secret courts are not open to the public and only special lawyers called ‘special advocates’ are allowed to witness the evidence presented there.

Clarke and Thornberry were supported in the debate by the SNP’s Joanna Cherry, Liberal Democrat Tom Brake, the DUP’s Jim Shannon and Labour and Conservative backbenchers.

Like Jeremy Corbyn, John McDonnell and Diane Abbott, Emily Thornberry was a backbench MP during the last Labour government.

Like this article? Left Foot Forward relies on support from readers to sustain our progressive journalism. Can you become a supporter for £5 a month?

3 Responses to “Clarke and Thornberry accuse government of ‘long-grassing’ torture inquiry”

  1. Tom Sacold

    I always thought the following quote was probably the best about 9/11 terrorist attack.

    “Through science man flew to the Moon. Through religion men flew into buildings.”

  2. Dave Roberts

    Tom.
    Well said sir but that won’t affect the PC brigade who run this blog. First of all Thornberry is a hater of white working class people as is the current Labour Party. I clearly remember when a fascist dictatorship in Argentina invaded the Falklands in 1982 the entire British left came out in support of a Junta which had murdered or disappeared at least 30,000 of its own people on the grounds that Argentine military fascists were ” anti Imperialist” The left are scum.

  3. wg

    The Labour Party sent our forces into Iraq – resulting in the deaths of thousands and setting the whole region alight.
    We also became aware of a new phrase – ‘extraordinary rendition’.

    I carry no torch for the Tories, but pointing the finger at them and forgetting the thousands of skeletons in Labour’s own cupboard is hypocrisy writ large.

Leave a Reply