In a cynical attempt to secure votes in the rest of Spain, the socialists have a long history of disrupting Catalan attempts at greater autonomy.
The Spanish Socialist Workers Party (PSOE) played a decisive role in preventing a legal referendum on Catalan independence. Now it’s complicit in an outright assault on the region’s autonomy, writes Kate Shea Baird in Barcelona.
As Catalonia heads into another week of political uncertainty, with direct rule from Madrid and the possibility of a unilateral declaration of independence on the cards, it’s worth examining the role of the Spanish socialist party, the PSOE, and its Catalan branch, the PSC, in getting us to where we are today.
Amid the ping-pong of mutual recriminations between Catalan President, Carles Puigdemont, and Spanish Prime Minister, Mariano Rajoy, it’s easy to overlook the socialist party’s share of the blame for the current crisis.
The PSOE is the only nominally progressive political party in Spain that doesn’t recognise Catalonia’s right to self-determination.
In the Catalan Parliament, the PSC voted against a declaration of the “right to decide” of Catalonia in 2013 and against requesting the power to hold a legal referendum from the Spanish Congress in 2014.
It was the PSOE’s refusal to accept a referendum in Catalonia that prevented it from gaining the support of Podemos to form an alternative government after the Spanish general election of December of 2015.
When repeat elections were held six months later, the socialists refused to budge on the issue and Rajoy resumed office.
In other words, the PSOE has been wilfully frustrating a legal, democratic solution to the Catalan question for years. Even so, its response to the referendum of October 1 and the events that followed verges on the grotesque.
Officially the PSOE is calling for dialogue and constitutional reform to give Catalonia more autonomy. Yet, at the same time, the party is backing the most authoritarian and repressive policies of the Spanish government, policies that are violating basic rights and freedoms and serving to escalate the conflict.
First, the PSOE’s reaction to the police brutality during the referendum, where over a thousand people were injured, was to blame the Catalan government “for taking politics from the institutions to the streets”.
Second, its Secretary General, Pedro Sanchez, has refused to condemn the detention without bail of Jordi Cuixart and and Jordi Sanchez, two Catalan civil society leaders charged with sedition for organizing peaceful demonstrations in late September.
Third, the socialist party is supporting Rajoy’s move to activate article 155 of the Spanish Constitution and implement direct rule over Catalonia.
This implies the removal of the Catalan government from office, a takeover of the Catalan police and public broadcasting services, and the neutering of the Catalan Parliament.
Unsurprisingly, the PSOE’s position is difficult for some of its members in Catalonia to swallow. The PSC has always struggled to maintain unity among its MPs in its opposition to Catalan self-determination, but the party’s support for repressive measures by the central government is putting it under increasing strain.
The PSC’s fiercely anti-independence leader, Miquel Iceta, was one of a number of socialist officials to criticise the detention of the two “Jordis” on sedition charges.
Most significantly, the decision to trigger article 155 has provoked a wave of condemnation from Catalan socialist leaders, including from four mayors who released a statement expressing their “most radical disagreement and rejection” of the move, and calling on the PSC not to support it.
One of them, the Mayor of Santa Coloma, Núria Parlón, has resigned from the executive committee of the PSOE in protest.
The PSOE has opposed a legal referendum, renounced the chance to remove Rajoy from office and supported the crushing of democratic governance in Catalonia.
This strategy may be a vote winner in Spain, where support for Catalan sovereignty remains below 50%, but it’s difficult to see how it contributes to the party’s stated goal of negotiating a new constitutional settlement that will be accepted by Catalan society.
Ironically, in its pursuit of law, order and unity, it may be the socialist party that does more than anyone else to convince Catalans of the impossibility of reforming Spain from within.
Kate Shea Baird has lived in Barcelona since 2008. She writes on Catalan and Spanish politics and is an activist in the Municipalist movement. She tweets here.
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 124 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
8 Responses to “The Spanish socialists must be held to account for blocking Catalan self-determination”
Mark H Burton
The situation is not that simple.
1) Independence is probably not supported by a majority of people living in Catalonia although it is difficult to tell.
2) However, there should be a referendum to test this and the action of the PP (and the PSOE at their coat-tails) in blocking it can only increase the support for independence, as do the fascist era style violent actions of the two national police forces under PP direction.
3) A motley collection of parties support independence – the right have consistently used it as a distraction from austerity policies while the maximalist left mostly seem to think it will mean Keynesianism in one “country”. Some of the calls for independence have the ugly tone of economic privilege, rather like the Rt Wing Northern League in Italy. Like our London and the South East, Catalonia should subsidise the poorer regions. It’s basic socialist redistribution.
4) It seems that only Podemos and its allies (e.g. Barcelona en Comun) have any kind of a sensible position on this in their call for a referendum with guarantees for those who oppose independence and dialogue with mediation. They largely oppose independence but respect the right of self determination (unlike the independistas who want to take the populace out of Spain whether they like it or not).
5) Both the nationalist sides (Catalan and Spanish) are playing with fire. Catalonia is a multi-cultural polity like former Yugoslavia. Nationalism, as opposed to regional government (based on the principle of subsidiarity), should be opposed by leftists and republicans.
D J Mac Innes
“…..they want independence. It does not make sense and PSOE is not wrong!” It’s for the Catalans themselves to decide on indepdndence, Patrick Newman, not you. As the article indicates it is to the shame of the left in Spain thst they support a government that makes a decision on self determinstion impossible.
D J Mac Innes
Independence may or may not be good for Catalunya. It is for the Catalans themselves to decide, and it is to the shame of the left in Spain that they support a govrnment ell bent on denying the right of self determinstion to people.