First Minister's fate is a test of NI's political maturity
If Belfast played by Westminster rules, Arlene Foster would already be out the door.
Northern Ireland’s First Minister is embroiled in one of the worst – and clearest cut – examples of ministerial bungling seen anywhere on these isles in at least 50 years.
The Renewable Heat Incentive, launched in 2012 while Foster served as enterprise minister, was a cut-down version of British scheme to subsidise non-domestic customers – farms and businesses – in switching from oil to wooden pellet-burning biomass boilers instead.
So far, so anodyne. However the elementary flaw in Northern Ireland’s version was a lack of cost controls. As the Auditor General succinctly put it, there was
“no upper limit on the amount of energy that would be paid for. The more heat that is generated, the more is paid.”
‘Burn to earn,’ or ‘cash for ash,’ meant recipients could claw back £160 for every £100 of fuel used and has led to a potential £400m overspend. That’s a conservative estimate.
It’s perhaps worth pointing out that Northern Ireland only has 1.8 million inhabitants – a population around the size of Hampshire. It’s the equivalent of a UK Business Secretary messing-up a scheme that saddled UK taxpayers with liabilities running into the tens of billions.
So a classic case of the minister in charge needing to quit? You would think, given our longstanding British traditions of ministerial accountability.
Yet Foster clings to office because of the frailty of Northern Ireland’s political institutions – which don’t have a clear cut mechanism for forcing her out – and the usual hubris of the Democratic Unionists who are content, a la Millwall Football Club, to say ‘everybody hates us, we don’t care.’
But they should. Foster is not a bad politician in the main, and certainly a welcome successor to Peter Robinson and before him Ian Paisley. She has done a decent, if not spectacular job since she took over 12 months ago.
The trouble is Foster is bang to rights over RHI. The sheer scale of the mistake means there is no wiggle room: She should resign.
Sinn Fein, keen to avoid the disruption of Foster being forced out, has not pressed its advantage. Instead, the Shinners have been urging her to step aside while an inquiry establishes the facts.
Foster’s response has been one of dunder-headed defiance. She has broken the arch lesson of dealing with a political crisis: She has turned her handling of the problem into its very own crisis.
Before the Christmas break, she was forced to explain herself to the Northern Ireland Assembly.
In rambling, indulgent and largely incoherent speech (after all the other parties had walked out in protest) Foster conceded there needs to be some sort of investigation – a point she was hitherto loath to admit when this scandal was gathering pace.
Now, at the eleventh hour, she claims to have a rescue plan to curtail the scheme and limit costs.
But as Jim Allister, the leader of the hardline Traditional Unionist Voice party reasonably points out, cancelling the scheme and clawing back payments is potentially a litigation minefield, with recipients of the grant suing the executive for breach of contract.
Her inept handling of this crisis means Arlene Foster is inching towards the exit door.
For her own dignity, it would be better if the DUP’s men (or indeed women) in grey suits were to visit her and get her to fall on her sword and avert fresh elections and the attendant disruption.
Ultimately, this mess is a test of the maturity of Northern Ireland’s political structure and whether the system can lose Foster without broader fallout. It can. And it should.
Kevin Meagher is a former special adviser to Labour Northern Ireland Secretary Shaun Woodward, and author of A United Ireland: Why Unification is Inevitable and How It Will Come About
As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.
We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.