Labour continues to send a signal to the public that it doesn't know what it believes in
The Conservative faithful continues its annual conference in Manchester today. Events so far have served only to highlight the hole in which the Labour Party now finds itself.
Let’s start with the issue of tax credits. According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies the government’s proposed living wage would offset just ’27 per cent of the drop in household incomes from the impact of net tax and benefit reforms.’
This should be natural Labour territory and we should be seeing the party leading the campaign against the tax credit reforms announced in the Budget. Yet it is opposition from within the Conservative Party which is proving more effective and which is most likely to lead to some sort of comprise arrangement.
Yes, it’s just one issue, but it shows a failure of the new Labour leadership to speak to the issues which voters that decide elections care about most.
Why has the party been so silent as George Osborne slowly but surely pinches so much of the Labour manifesto – a living wage, full devolution of business rates and the establishment of a National Infrastructure Commission?
The audacity of Osborne, who yesterday described the Conservative Party as the party of labour and stole Aneurin Bevan’s words – ‘we are the builders’ – has been possible only because Labour has seen its flag lowered over the cherished centre ground.
This is not to say that principles do not matter; but the reality that those around Jeremy Corbyn must grapple with is how to turn his left-wing rhetoric into an enticing ‘one nation’ programme for government – one that brings middle and lower earners together.
It is a programme that needs to speak to people’s aspirations and hopes, and properly address their fears that Labour can no longer be trusted to look after their taxes and provide proper national security.
Last night was a reminder of the problem Labour now faces. As the prime minister was in the conference bubble celebrating an election victory, Jeremy Corbyn was reduced, somewhat sadly, to addressing protests that will do nothing to change government policy.
To make matters worse, he did so alongside Terry Pullinger, deputy general secretary of Communication Workers’ Union, who argued that Corbynmania ‘almost makes you want to celebrate the fact Labour lost the election’.
Such words are profoundly depressing, and speak volumes about those for whom the comfort of opposition is somehow preferably to being able to do things in government.
We have rightly seen many Labour MPs tweeting about how depressing such words are, but it is time for Jeremy Corbyn to take a lead, to disassociate himself from such sentiments and make clear that for Labour to succeed the party must be in power. He needs to show a desire and eagerness to win which has so far been lacking.
To cite just one example: Labour now finds itself in the position where it either backs the renewal of the nuclear deterrent, putting Corbyn in a very difficult spot, or it decides to reject it, leading to mass resignations from the shadow cabinet. Tothe public thismust look farcical.
The reality is that Labour is currently a mess. It is failing to properly stand up for its legacy in government and it is failing to take the Tories to task on crucial policy issues.
We know that many in the PLP remain deeply unconvinced by the Corbyn leadership. The question now is how long will they wait until they move against it.
EdJacobs is a contributing editor at Left Foot Forward. Follow him on Twitter
Want to read more posts like this? Then *sign-up to Look Left* and make sure you have the facts to rebut right-wing spin
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 124 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
46 Responses to “Comment: The Tories are walking all over Labour – Corbyn must act”
Chris Kitcher
Jeremy Corbyn addressed a larger audience last night than the whole shower of Tories in Manchester.
I cannot see the reasoning in your assertion that the Tories are seeking to capture the centre ground. Their policies, that I have seen emerge from Manchester, are so far to the right they could be confused with Fascism. I suspect that Corbyn is allowing them sufficient rope by which to hang themselves and then will put them in their place after their rabid ideas have been torn to shreds.
Barry Hearth
for many years the Blairites ruled Labour with an iron rod, dissent was severely dealt with, now that the left are in the ascendency they promise to wreck or leave the party.
Austerity doesn’t and wont work, most people will just end up worse off, the banks destroyed economies around the world, and as in Greece they are still trying to rule the world.
Time for change, ir you can’t accept that then maybe you’re in the wrong party.
leslie48
The Corbynite honey moon is now over and the fully paid up members of our party awaken to a cold morning reality. A party whose votes are in very serious decline, who have deserted the centre ground to clever Osborne, and whose image is categorised as ‘hard left’ by all the media and moreover which has deserted so many of its traditional working class voters.
The solution is bleak as we have become under JC and his clan a party of two irreconcilables as the hard Left and the most Leftist Unions have taken over more or less the leadership contest structures. The social democratic and moderates are in despair at the inactivity and passivity of the rest of the Labour Party.
leslie48
Indeed at this rate ‘a divided party’ to escape the hard leftist unelectable Corbynites looks appealing at times as the nation condemns our party for deserting the centre ground and keeping Boris, George and David in power for the next ten years of our lives. That’s the reality and we will fight to save this party from those who are dropping our vote dramatically.
Lovejoy
Corbyn is not the greatest of orators. Opposition to the tax credit cuts seem to come from Boris Johnson and the Sun on Sunday! Nevertheless with New Labour the ‘centre ground’ was further and further to the right, whereas now it will be somewhere centre-right. Labour needs to unite behind their leader or ditch him (which given the size of his mandate, would be an affront to democracy). We must do everything we can to pressurise our MPs to speak out against tax credits being slashed. My own MP is on the front bench, so will act in accordance with the chief whip’s instructions, but backbenchers can speak their minds!