Amazon factory conditions? Shut up or robots get your job, says Times writer

The retail giant's treatment of workers is a disgrace. But Ross Clark warns unions to keep quiet about it


Scribbler Ross Clark has a message for the GMT union after it slammed working conditions at Amazon’s UK warehouses.

After reports in the New York Times about the retail giant’s appalling treatment of staff in the US, distribution centres in the UK came under the spotlight.

Elly Baker at the GMT said: “You can’t be a normal person. You have to be an above-average Amazon robot all the time.”

This was music to Ross Clark’s ears. 

Writing in the Times today, he said:

“If I were the company’s chief executive Jeff Bezos I would be asking myself: has the time come for us to employ real robots?

It cannot be beyond the wit of technologists to design an Amazon warehouse which employs about three people — all skilled technicians whose role is to make sure the automated arms and levers keep rifling through the shelves to select the right books to dispatch.”

He concludes:

Bleat too much about pay and conditions and Amazon’s warehouses will catch up with the futuristic images on 1960s comics, where uncomplaining robots take the strain.”

In other words, if a trade union does its job and raises concerns about working conditions, its members risk being sacked and replaced with robots.

How nice for Amazon to have Mr Clark volunteer to keep Amazon staff in line, and for the Murdoch-owned Times to publish his friendly advice!

The Telegraph recently made a similar threat about striking train staff, pointing out the same advantage – robots don’t complain.

Ironically, Clark draws attention to the original problem – the boss class thinking of working people as replaceable machines.

Which is why we have unions in the first place.

Adam Barnett is a staff writer at Left Foot Forward. Follow MediaWatch on Twitter

DONATE to support MediaWatch here.

Read more: 

Anti-union press wants train staff to act like robots. But who is the real bully here?

Who’s really ‘gerrymandering’? Express attack on Labour backfires

Sign up for our weekly email by clicking here.

Like this article? Left Foot Forward relies on support from readers to sustain our progressive journalism. Can you become a supporter for £5 a month?

6 Responses to “Amazon factory conditions? Shut up or robots get your job, says Times writer”

  1. Foullaini

    Do robots respect picket lines?

  2. blarg1987

    I wonder will he volunteer a robot to take this role, after all do we need CEO’s or just have a programmed computer with all the information plugged in that will compute what results people are after.

  3. GhostofJimMorisson

    Unions have done nothing to stop the rise of zero-hour contracts; they have made virtually no protest about mass immigration, particularly from the EU, which big businesses like Amazon simply love as it provides an inexhaustible supply of cheap labour. What could they possibly do to stop Amazon replacing staff with robots ?

  4. Jon Jones.

    Artificial Intelligence has come a long way. Perhaps we could replace Ross Clark with a computer? A Commodore 64 should be up to the task.

  5. JarrowPete

    Jon, I think a Vic 20 is more appropriate 😉

  6. RobShorrock

    You can’t have mass immigration from the EU by the fact that the UK is part of the EU and there is a right of European citizens to work anywhere in the EU.

Leave a Reply