Public sector pay – did the government massage the statistics to make its case?

Using a statistical sleight of hand, the government is trying to disguise the full horror of what's happening to public sector pay.

Using a statistical sleight of hand, the government is trying to disguise the full horror of what’s happening to public sector pay

The July 10 public sector strikes provoked a bitter war of words, with the government condemning the strikes as “unnecessary”. One assertion was that public sector pay growth had held up rather better than the private sector.

However the government is being disingenuous in relying on a figure that precedes their election to power. In fact, when we turn our attention to the coalition’s record it is the private sector that has seen faster earnings growth.

The TUC general secretary has written to Francis Maude to question the government’s statement, which pulled off the clever conjuring trick of being misleading without being untrue.

Bear in mind that all statisticians know that it is sometimes easy to radically revise the results by picking a different base year.

The government chose to base its claim for healthy public sector pay growth on measuring from the onset of the 2008 recession. Measuring from spring 2008, ONS reports that public sector earnings have grown by 12.3 per cent and private sector earnings by 9.3 per cent.

But this includes two years of Labour government. If we shift our focus just to the period when the current government was in power, the results are starkly reversed. Measuring from spring 2010, public sector pay has grown by just 4.2 per cent and private sector pay by half as much again – up by 6.7 per cent.

Frances O’Grady has told the Cabinet Office secretary that that there is much to be said for the government looking at the period for which it has had responsibility, otherwise there is a danger that, in a climate of failing trust, many will “believe that government simply picked the base year that best supports its case”.

But even the cute little comparisons that I have reported do not reveal the full horror of what has happened to pay, as they do not take inflation into account. The stark truth is that real pay has fallen substantially for both public sector and private sector workers.

Taking CPI inflation into account, the value of real pay has declined under the current government, with the purchasing power of private sector workers falling by 4.4 per cent since the general election and real public sector pay down by 6.7 per cent

There is only one cure for this malady, Britain needs a pay rise as a matter of urgency, and public sector workers must not be left behind.

Paul Sellers is a TUC policy officer

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

9 Responses to “Public sector pay – did the government massage the statistics to make its case?”

  1. stephenbooth

    Additionally a lot of us in Local Government lost money due to Single Status, whilst others gained, in that period. Wonder which set the government included in their figures?

  2. Leon Wolfeson

    Please use RPI, the proper measure of inflation. Using CPI is also playing the government’s narrative.

  3. billbradbury

    As a past student of statistics on “who says so,, how does he know,, what’s missing, does it make sense, median or mean, evidence of reliability”. Just ignore anything that comes out of this Tory Government. Once back in power we will find the recovery is an illusion. The rich are getting richer and the por poorer. It was ever so.

  4. Jayne Linney

    Once again we witness this Government spinning statistics to argue a false premis – it is time for a concerted effort to STOP this raft of Lies and the Policies they underpin.

    Please support the TRUTH Campaign

  5. Lazza75

    The public sector pay also now includes employees of The Royal Bank of Scotland (which raises the average earnings by quite a bit). Furthermore, a large amount of low paid jobs in the public sector have been cut, which also increases the average. The sell-off of Royal Mail, also increased average earnings in the public sector. Finally, the increase in zero-hours contracts, in the private sector, deflated the private sector average earnings.

  6. sarntcrip

    when do the selfservatives not massage figures unemployment,inflation,crime none represent reality

  7. flux5000

    Raft of lefties? What planet are you on? Obviously not the same as us.
    Dear Jayne, we have a far right Conservative party in power with middle right Libdems.
    The fact is what we have seen over the last 40 odd years is the effect of right wing policies.

    Perhaps you parents never taught you your left from your right?

  8. flux5000

    If you mean once Labour are in power, I have news for you, they are right wing too and have stated they will continue with austerity.

  9. billbradbury

    Absolutely the recovery is an allusion pre election. Whoever gets back in power the cuts will continue. Deficit and borrowing has increased. The last Labour Government just carried on Tory policies. I say one thing for the Tories they look after their own when in power. Labour just forgets its core voters and sucks up to the City. When I raised this with my Labour MP he said well we get 80% of our wealth from the City.

Leave a Reply