Why Iain Duncan Smith should resign

His welfare schemes keep imploding, severely ill people keep being declared fit for work and so many people are falling through cracks in the benefits system that food bank use surpassed a million this year. Yet Iain Duncan Smith soldiers on. The media seem obsessed with discussing Ed Miliband’s appearance, but the man who has overseen the chaos and misery of the Department of Work and Pensions is still in his job – a serious media would call for this ridiculous man to resign.

Today the Major Projects Authority (MPA), a watchdog for government programmes, declared that the Universal credit scheme the DWP has been working on for the last three years has had to be so reorganised due to technological mishaps and problems that it is now effectively a new scheme. This means that the scheme is now recognised as reset – after three years of doomed attempts to get it started.

Last month the DWP blatantly ignored its own evidence in order to enact a punitive scheme that doesn’t help anyone. The Department of Work and Pensions decided to launch its “Help to Work” programme, despite the fact that its own test pilot showed it to have basically no positive effect. It revealed that only 19% of people on the scheme ended up in employment – compared to 18% in the control group. Millions of pounds are being wasted simply to garner a few more gleeful benefit-claimant bashing headlines in the Daily Mail.

The list of failures goes on and on. ATOS, the private company that the DWP hired to decide whether sick and disabled people are fit for work, has declared a shocking number of very ill people fit for work. Since the work capability assessment began there have been more than 600, 000 appeals lodged against Atos decisions and in four out of 10 cases the original decisions have been overturned. As a report by the Work and Pensions Select Committee noted, “in far too many cases the Department is getting these decisions wrong at considerable cost to both the taxpayer and the claimant.”

On top of all this is the rise and rise of food banks. The number of people using foodbanks has risen from 128,697 in 2011-12 to 346,992 in 2012-13 and to 913,000 in 2013-14, according to The Trussell Trust. The Trussell Trust has said that around 44% of people using food banks are there because of benefit changes or delays. This means that they are there because of problems or policies which are ultimately the responsibility of the Department for Work and Pensions.

Iain Duncan Smith seems to believe that the fact he once toured impoverished council estates in Glasgow gives him an understanding and level of compassion that none of his critics can possibly possess. But, the misery that his reforms have unleashed demonstrate that he is delusional. He has overseen a chaotic department that worsens the lives of the most vulnerable. Ministers have resigned for far less.


Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

9 Responses to “Why Iain Duncan Smith should resign”

  1. Kryten2k35

    I think you meant “launched into the sun”

  2. jray

    I have always been employed,at 47 I lost my business,I refused to sign on as I have always been able find something to tide me over. Signing on was a humbling experience,I had become “One of them” Who are they? For the majority,hard working,tax paying citizens! Once you enter the world of the unemployed? you are looked upon as a sub human,you are trying to get something for nothing,Scrounger,Skiver and undesirable..This is the reception that awaits you,but their is hope,the £5 Billion Work Programme,no training,no tailored support,just jumping through hoops as long as the Provider can claim Tax Payer money.and after 2 Years of that? Back to the JCP,the main mission? Avoiding getting Sanctioned,if you meet every silly thing asked of you the reward is? MWA,30 Hours a Week unpaid labour.but is it really unpaid? You receive £72 per Week,must still be actively searching for full time employment,conduct XXX of job searches…Meanwhile the same Company on the failed Work Programme collects £600 start fee the Minute you start MWA,so at least these Pimps cash in at the Taxpayers expense…..Some where in this mess it seems actually helping people find employment is lost!

  3. Paul Trembath

    Anyone would suppose that the people in charge – whoever they are, surely not the spiv Cameron and his comedy Chancellor – need a deniable scapegoat in case their vicious policies result, unexpectedly, in some very small part of their richly deserved retribution.

  4. Leon Wolfeson

    Watch him slip more nastiness in there (especially for workers) in there under the cover of the elections, I’d bet.

  5. Mini

    They’ve now introduced a mandatory reconsideration phase now because so many people were winning their appeal, basically while they look over your appeal, they don’t have to pay you anything for 6 weeks. The Tories took nasty to a whole new level, because when Atos find you fit for work, and they do for pretty much everyone regardless of your illness, this mandatory reconsideration thing is a game changer.

  6. Maggie

    The push to get claimants into “Part time, Zero hours, jobs” and take two or three has resulted in a horrendous situation for a lady I know. She has a number of part-time posts. She has not had a day off since 1st May, and will get the next one 21st July – the rota’s of different posts do not co-inside with each other, and while it may only be a few hours a day, a working day is a working day ! But her case is counted as a success by IDS & his henchmen as she is no longer claiming JSA.

  7. Keith M

    IDS was a disastrous leader of the Tory Party; he is a wrecker in his present incarnation. His policies have caused misery for thousands of people – shame on him.

  8. Keith M

    You are right Mini – i would say not just nasty but wicked.

  9. So long, IDS. And good riddance. | Left Foot Forward

    […] Comment: Iain Duncan Smith is undoing years of struggle for disabled rights […]

Leave a Reply