John Major is right – but the problem isn’t only private schools

John Major is right to talk about the dominance of ex-private school pupils in public life. The problem is bigger than that, though.

John Major

Former Prime Minister John Major has described the dominance of privately educated children in the “upper echelons” of public life as “truly shocking”.

Major’s comments come on the back of a recent intervention over energy prices, in which he called for a windfall tax on the profits of the Big Six.

Despite first impressions, Major hasn’t had a late life conversion to socialism, however; rather he is simply stating the obvious: the dominance of private school alumni in public life is plain for all to see.

Fee-paying schools educate seven per cent of the pupil population but now produce 54 per cent of Tory MPs, 40 per cent of Lib Dem and 15 per cent of Labour, according to the Mail. In total, 37 per cent of MPs from the three main parties elected in 2010 were privately-schooled – up from 34 per cent in 2005 and 30 per cent in 1997, the paper says.

It isn’t just in politics that ex-private school pupils dominate, either. Today it’s almost impossible to break into journalism without significant financial backing due to the sheer amount of free work expected from a budding hack. After all, the only people who have time to fool around for no money are the people who already have plenty of it.

It would be a mistake, however, to view this strictly as an issue of private vs public education: comprehensives are just as likely to fail poorer pupils as private schools are to boost the chances of the elite.

This has a great deal to do with the assumption that selection in mainstream education was somehow abolished with the dissolution of the grammar school system. It wasn’t. It’s just that today it happens arbitrarily by house price rather than arbitrarily by a test taken at 11 years old.

Schools campaigner Fiona Miller summed up the blind spot many have about comprehensive education when she wrote last year that “Selective education was largely abolished (emphasis my own) because middle-class parents were incensed at their children being labelled failures at 11 and forced into secondary moderns starved of the balanced intakes all schools need”.

Taking her comments in reverse order, undoubtedly many affluent parents were indeed incensed when mummy’s little soldiers failed to pass their 11 plus; however in no sense was selection “abolished”, largely or otherwise, with the dissolution of grammars. It was instead replaced with selection by the most ruthless commodity of all: cold hard cash.

Access to a good comprehensive today is often decided by the ability of a child’s parents to pay the price of a house in a desirable catchment area. In 2012 premiums on houses in areas with good schools commanded an average price of £309,732 – 42 per cent higher than the average price of £218,114.

I’m not sure I wish to make the argument that grammar schools should be brought back in their old form – it’s incredibly unfair to allow the future of a child to be determined at 11 years old by a single test, the result of which was often prejudiced by the class background of the child.

However some honesty about school selection would be welcome: it’s just as prevalent today as it was under the old system, it’s just that today it’s the price of the parents’ house that determines what sort of school a child ends up at, and so often where they end up in life.

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

23 Responses to “John Major is right – but the problem isn’t only private schools”

  1. dcfghkhlkjojobvgfgvd

    Major is correct the Tories are out of touch and elitist but Labour have also damaged the British working class through mass immigration that has caused millions to be unemployed, housing unaffordable, long NHS times and wages going low

    Please sign and share, blog, tweet, facebook the Daily
    Express petition to stop EU immigration. Over 83,000 have signed in 10 days.

    Sign here-

  2. Johnny

    What a load of rubbish socialists; Even in the land of equal opportunity America, Barack Obama from a humble background has been accused of elitism. In animal kingdoms there must always be a few who controls so many. The truth is everyone must compete their way up and defend their positions for their children and grand children. 99% of the richest men in the world are self-made not inheritence.

  3. Essexandy

    Its interesting that the area of the UK (Northern Ireland) with highest social mobility according to comparison tablesi is also the only area which has retained the Grammer school system.

  4. Alien Pirate

    Actually its about DNA of the individual which dictates their future – I have no interest in Money – fact – psycological assessment – not assumption – but I’ve worked for Technical Directors all my working life because of my Technical (craft ‘hands on’ ) ability and my man management skills – friends with less technical ability and no management skills have got further up the ladder simply because they have a different outlook on life and consider money important. I failed my 11plus – I didn’t know what it was – I did four years Apprenticeship (a Proper one) some Lads with exactly the same training and opportunites have reached dizzing heights of Head of Establishment and others never did anything but lowly Craft work – the only difference is our DNA!

Comments are closed.