The majority of disabled people, particularly those with mental health conditions, are victims of day-to-day hostility which has a massive impact.
Stephen Brookes MBE is a disability and equality consultant, a coordinator for the Disability Hate Crime Network, and an ambassador for Disability Rights UK
The majority of disabled people, particularly those with mental health conditions, are victims of day-to-day hostility which has a massive impact on their lives.
Being disabled means that we have to carry additional baggage: we are viewed as ‘different’ and, in these politically motivated times, are also often portrayed as a burden: as cheats; scroungers and the great work-shy – leading to verbal abuse.
These issues become even more difficult when any form of mental health condition is involved.
It is perhaps no wonder, then, that with those issues to fight, the reporting of minor crimes and anti-social behaviour against us does not register high on the table of important actions in our lives? It is all too easy to say that ‘they won’t do anything about it’ if we report these things.
In many presentations and workshops recently, I have put forward the idea that the local statutory and voluntary community – including disabled people themselves – can help by not allowing this to happen.
But in answer to that comment, I often ask: who are the ‘they’? The answer comes back, ‘well the police’; but the police cannot do anything if nobody reports an incident. By spreading the word, hopefully more people will report hate crime in future and help other victims and themselves before it’s too late; and here is the key point, because communication is not just up to the police, it is up to the neighbours and social services to report it and the police to listen and take action.
Cases of disability hate crime are easier to identify than they used to be, not least because of the Crown Prosecution Service definition, which defines disability hate crime as:
“Any criminal offence which is perceived by the victim or any other person to be motivated by hostility or prejudice based on a person’s disability or perceived disability.”
So the excuse of lack of knowledge is no longer acceptable. Here we see that the key words are ‘hostility or prejudice’ – the word ‘hate’ has been removed, as it is harder to prove than hostility or prejudice, particularly in the difficult area of mental health or learning disability.
But the process of reporting and maybe going to court is not one most people relish, and this is why the CPS and the police work to support victims through Witness care, witness support, and where applicable, though special measures, all of which are intended to make justice available to disabled people.
So while we do see that there has been movement toward recognising and responding to hate crime incidents, I accept there are a lot of real problems, and very patchy actions in areas of social care, housing associations, local authority and the criminal justice system as a whole. If one body or group acts in a negative way, the whole confidence is destroyed.
If a specific police officer or social service staff member doesn’t seem to take notice, then go further and demand actions is taken and report beyond their level.
That is why the message has to be that disabled people, their organisations, carers, families, friends, and neighbours need to be part of the culture of change, and if that means us being forceful to stop stupidity, laziness or institutional ignorance and therefore stop disability hate crime, then so be it.
Earlier today Left Foot Forward looked at today’s Sun, and the paper’s misleading and execrable headline on crime and people with mental health problems
As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.
We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.
6 Responses to “Hate crime against disabled people comes in many forms”
The police are worse then the public on two occasions I have been involved with so called hate crimes against the disabled it was the police that had caused it.
Sorry I think most disabled people are well aware of how the police act to disability..
And the worse accusation of abuse comes from the Labour party, the Tories may want us to die but the Labour party would tell accuse us of being scrounging cheat first.
I deem that the police are not interested in disability hate crime. Having tried to report it they informed me if I didnt like move elsewhere. And in reporting it yet again last week, they have failed to get back to me, which is no surprise. I think they would rather I just expired. It seems to me they see hate crime as an activity to be condoned.
I know the San Francisco Police are not interested in hate crime against the mentally ill. They calmly watched while my son died in a suicide baiting in Hallidie Plaza, San Francisco, on 2-16-10. See “Suicide baiting is a hate crime” at http://ipinionsyndicate.com/suicide-baiting-is-a-hate-crime/
And “when police do not protect: a 2010 suicide baiting in San Francisco” at http://ipinionsyndicate.com/paradigm-shift-in-police protection-a-2010-suicide-baiting-in-san-francisco/
you are a kind person, Stephen, and this kindness and understanding is the only thing that can stop Hate. Your words:
>The majority of disabled people, particularly those with mental health conditions,
>are victims of day-to-day hostility which has a massive impact on their lives.
made me feel that *someone* recognises this. This struggle that has at times been so severe that I will admit I have lapsed into Hate back, hate for the mainstream world, hate for all the prejudiced individuals who have done this to me. The only trouble with hating back is that you spiral… Ouch.
But now I have googled and started to read words of support a better solution appears.
Police have done report over my complaint of one of their officers,no face to face contact just phone asking for photographs. Sent to her thinking police naturally wanted them 26th may 2014 then 31st May2014, she emailed too say, giving to housing provider. Me a tenant
So she took them photographs false pretences , The Photographs relate to damage fence at
My property Disabled Wheelchair bungalow.So had to appeal there Police investigation