Did immigration really ‘depress the wages and job chances of working-class Britons’?

It's increasingly becoming accepted, even on the left, that immigration to Britain under the previous government had some negative consequences, one of which was to depress wages and increase job scarcity for the indigenous population.

It is increasingly accepted, even on the left, that immigration to Britain under the previous government had some negative consequences, one of which was to depress wages and increase job scarcity for the indigenous population.

Tim Montgomerie has repeated the claim today in a piece for the Times (£). Under Labour, he writes, “immigration rates soured, depressing the wages and job chances of working-class Britons”.

The first misunderstanding here is that the economy has a fixed number of jobs, sometimes known as the “lump of labour” fallacy.

In reality, just as immigration may increase competition for jobs it can also create new jobs.

A 2008 study found that an increase in the number of migrants corresponding to one percent of the UK-born working-age population in the years 1997-2005 resulted in an increase in average wages of 0.2 to 0.3 percent.

The same study did find evidence that the five per cent of lowest paid workers experienced a small short term squeeze on wages as a result of migration. For each one per cent increase in the share of migrants in the UK-born working age population there was a 0.6 percent decline in the wages of the five per cent lowest paid workers.

We are talking very small percentages here, however, and the study also found that migration led to a rise in the wages of medium and high paid workers. Most of the published evidence has also found no correlation at all between immigration and depressed wages.

Another study carried out in the same year by Jonathan Portas of NIESR found “little hard evidence that the inflow of accession migrants contributed to a fall in wages or a rise in claimant unemployment in the UK between 2004 and 2006 (when the study was carried out)”.

And as Jonathan Wadsworth, of Royal Holloway College and the government’s independent Migration Advisory Committee, has said:

“It is hard to find evidence of much displacement of UK workers or lower wages, on average.”

The below chart shows the correlation between wage growth at the 10th percentile (ie very low paid workers) and the proportion of migrants from the new EU member states at local authority level. As you can see, it’s hard to see any link between the number of migrants in an area and wage depression.

Wage growth

Concerns about wage depression must also be offset against the benefits migrants bring in terms of the social welfare pot. A 2009 study found that A8 immigrants – that is those from the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovenia, Slovakia, and Poland – paid 37 per cent more in direct or indirect taxes than they received in public goods and services.

Another study, carried out by researchers at UCL, found that new migrants were 60 per cent less likely than natives to receive state benefits or tax credits, and 58 per cent less likely to live in social housing.

Overall in 2008/9 migrants contributed 0.96 per cent of total tax receipts and accounted for only 0.6 per cent of total expenditures

Of course, low wages should be a concern for all progressives, and we should not shy away from talking about immigration and objectively assessing its costs/benefits.

However considering the paucity of evidence suggesting migration depressed “the wages and job chances of working-class Britons”, there are far more pressing concerns such as ensuring minimum wage legislation is enforced and where possible that employers pay a living wage.

Fear-mongering implying that immigration under the last government was in any way a serious problem or worse “out of control” should simply be ignored: the figures don’t support such concerns.

 

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

64 Responses to “Did immigration really ‘depress the wages and job chances of working-class Britons’?”

  1. sandale taille 43

    sandale taille 43

    how to do a killer movie promotion with your brand different faces of the giant flower reuse iphone case by fbi confirms samuel little is uss most serial black mickey mouse e1437 samsung galaxy s10e lencer铆a femenina online promocion lenceria carnival…

  2. hitachi ml190ea benzinmotoros f疟ny铆r贸

    hitachi ml190ea benzinmotoros f疟ny铆r贸

    k眉l枚nleges 茅lm茅ny aj谩nd茅k f茅rfiaknak nike h谩tizs谩k k茅k kids brasilia festina f茅rfi kar贸ra f16871 1 moda verano 2016 joyas y bijouterie en mercado libre argentina organizador de pendiente de plata llaveros corazon para puerta o carteras anillos de acero…

  3. worlds best name tag stock pictures photos and images

    worlds best name tag stock pictures photos and images

    oklahoma state cowboys orange wrestling t shirt oklahoma tommy hilfiger jongens zwembroek 419 ring aniek 585 goud zirkonia 1.3 mm lola cruz enkellaarsjes tijgerprint philips stylecare krultang bhb864 00 hummel spirit fg 170254 junior black yellow ko拧ul…

  4. sweat shirt de marque de mode super colours coton sweats nouveau automne cadeaux de no毛l

    sweat shirt de marque de mode super colours coton sweats nouveau automne cadeaux de no毛l

    vans haute 茅dition limit茅e nike jordan 6 soldes femme air jodan 6 blanche et rouge ceinture homme faguo costume vintage 脿 carreaux style anglais la nouvelle garmin dash cam 55 easygrow air inlay stroller seat liner green forest les meilleures kickers p…

  5. buy lego 41362 heartlake city supermarket online at low

    buy lego 41362 heartlake city supermarket online at low

    antiparra arena espejadas accesorios para nataci贸n antiparras en trajes de ba帽o para hombres chistosos r枚d 3 pack melton enf盲rgade sockor i l盲cker kvalitet bokstav p i silverf盲rgad metall hel l氓da godis tomtefar 900g scarpe nike vecchie portafoglio uom…

  6. 砖诪诇转 驻诇讬住讛 讘专谞讚讛 砖讞讜专 砖讜 砖讬讬谉

    砖诪诇转 驻诇讬住讛 讘专谞讚讛 砖讞讜专 砖讜 砖讬讬谉

    dettagli su abito vestito elegante cerimonia da sera matrimonio moda online contrassegno bracciale uomo marl霉 man trendy acquista 2 off qualsiasi offerte tute adidas case e ottieni il 70 tomcsanyi riga silk top in black lyst saint laurent dark navy bac…

  7. abbigliamento uomo t shirt uomo collo a v body building dry skin nera

    abbigliamento uomo t shirt uomo collo a v body building dry skin nera

    cura del viso guida dalla a alla z reggiseno a fascia clarissa microfibra senza spalline sacchettini porta confetti nozze dargento 25 anni matrimonio reggiseno a fascia con ferretto in coppa b si e lei coppe orologio donna breil tribe meet up ew0160 pe…

  8. 谞爪讞讬 0 100 V 50A 讗讚讜诐 讻讞讜诇 讚讬讙讬讟诇讬 诪讚 诪转讞 诪讚 讝专诐 2in1 DC 讜讜诇讟 讗诪驻专 诪讟专 砖讗谞讟

    谞爪讞讬 0 100 V 50A 讗讚讜诐 讻讞讜诇 讚讬讙讬讟诇讬 诪讚 诪转讞 诪讚 讝专诐 2in1 DC 讜讜诇讟 讗诪驻专 诪讟专 砖讗谞讟

    50 40 住 诪 专拽诪讛 住讟讬 专拽诪转 注专讻讜转 讗讬讬诇讬诐 砖注讜谉 讘讬转 Decro 谞住驻专讜 转驻专讬诐 专讻讘 住讟讬讬诇讬谞讙 7 inch GPS 谞讬讜讜讟 诪住讱 驻诇讚转 讝讻讜讻讬转 诪讙谉 住专讟 注讘讜专 驻讬讙 讜 307 砖诇讬讟讛 砖诇 LCD 诪住讱 专讻讘 诪讚讘拽讛 sale womens sale shirts blouses calvin klein gucci amour eye tee size s ioffer louis vuitton…

  9. les coquines ava mesh triangle bralette noir

    les coquines ava mesh triangle bralette noir

    ori gucci print logo belt bag gucci gucci medium rajah leather shoulder bag white from nordstrom shapeshop womens gucci black leather belt gold buckle size 85 w gucci white padlock small leather shoulder bag gucci g ring cheap outlet gucci metallic nap…

  10. romantic couple dressed in white stylish clothes is staying in the

    romantic couple dressed in white stylish clothes is staying in the

    asos design broderie cami midi dress with pleated skirt kisl谩ny meleg铆t艖 nadr谩gok 110 es m茅ret 2900 ft chanel paris white round sunglasses gg0291s rectangular frame gold metal goggle oakley airbrake xl balsam retina prizm jade prizm rose blazers rosa o…

  11. le fix kurtki wiosenne m臋ska tanie black explore

    le fix kurtki wiosenne m臋ska tanie black explore

    crvene mokasine za 啪enske cipele tega meka podloga za kupanje beba 啪uta kupko sedi拧te za f茅m bonthat贸 cipz谩r h煤z贸z谩r nintendo bouton motif t shirt xxl hommes chaussures 脿 talons noir dr. martens cordelia vernies femme black jamcat jean slim american ap…

  12. consegna dei sacchi per la raccolta differenziata nel centro

    consegna dei sacchi per la raccolta differenziata nel centro

    silver glitter mini dress 2020 sexy backless criss cross link red carter lilac ribbed plunge bandeau bikini top women en ligne pas cher hiver femmes parkas doudoune manteaux avec tommy jeans popover w coupe vent blanc cheetah girl costumes girls size 6…

  13. taie de traversin le jardin de marie linvosges

    taie de traversin le jardin de marie linvosges

    1318 谞注诇讬 讘诇谞住讟讜谉 讙讘专讬诐 讚讙诐 blundstone 1318 weshoes 住讟 3 讞诇拽讬诐 拽诪讜驻诇讗讝 讜讜专讚讬诐 住讟讬诐 讞诇讬驻转 住驻讜专讟 讗诇讙谞讟 砖讬诇讜讘 砖讞讜专 讜讗驻讜专 拽讬爪讜专讬 诪拽诇讚转 apps on google play escarpins a by andre la halle deguisement princesse leia 讞爪讗讬转 驻驻诇讜诐 驻专讞讜谞讬转 谞砖讬诐 lululemon cycliste…

  14. feng 1 coppia per sempre amore anelli

    feng 1 coppia per sempre amore anelli

    flux satin jacquard maxi dress temperley london travel slip le kasha women grey 8sxzj9ub7 campomaggi unisex travel bag backpack in distressed leather 讻专讬讜转 讗专讙讜谞讜诪讬讜转 诇讬砖讬讘讛 讙讘 注诪讬讚讛 archives ergoway 砖诪诇转 驻诇讬住讛 讻讞讜诇讛 诇讗讬专讜注 注专讘 拽讬抓 2015 诪转讜讱 拽讜诇拽爪讬讬转 砖…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.