MigrationWatch is scaremongering, as usual

MigrationWatch is more interested in scaremongering than getting the facts right.

Thomas Southern is a writer and blogger

MigrationWatch has published a paper by its leader Sir Andrew Green which says that Britain should remove the ‘pull‘ for new immigrants.

When he speaks of the ‘pull’, he is referring to the UK’s minimum wage and the benefits available here which are worth up to five times more than those in Romania and Bulgaria.

MigrationWatch has a long and illustrious history of skewed data about immigrants.

For the most part, their anti-immigration sentiment flows from two categories: economic concerns, where it is claimed immigrants have a detrimental impact on employment, and social issues, or in other words, losing our ‘Britishness’.

I will focus on the former.

The National Institute of Economic and Social Research has recently shown through statistical evidence that, specifically during a recession or low growth period, net immigration has little or no impact on unemployment in the host country.

This may be because most migrants move to a country for a specific reason, rather than just for the sake of it. They may already have a job, are willing to take up lower paid work, or indeed they may be students who tend to be self-supporting.

For the most part, people do not make huge life changing decisions, such as moving to a new country, on a whim.

As MigrantWatch has pointed out, 26 million Bulgarians and Romanians will be able to move to the UK from January 1st 2014. Forgetting the other 26 EU states they could go to, and assuming that the entire population of Bulgaria and Romania decide to up sticks and come here, they are technically correct.

What MigrationWatch forgets, however, is that the citizens of both countries have been free to come to the UK to live for the past six years. The only restrictions have been on the labour markets.

Additionally, MigrantWatch and its affiliates are concerned that the EU will allow Romanians to come over to the UK and claim benefits rather than work.

The stats, however, don’t back this up.

In the 2010/11 fiscal year, 5.5 million out of the 38 million UK working age population claimed work related benefits, including Jobseekers Allowance, Income Support and the like.

Of these, 371,000 were non-UK nationals, a quarter of whom were from other EU countries.

Therefore, out of the 2.2 million EU nationals in the UK in 2010, 4.21% claimed working benefits. By contrast, 14.32% of British nationals within the age range were doing the same.

The difference is staggering, and coupled with the above NIESR report, shows that migrants don’t come for the benefits, nor do they ‘steal jobs’, as some believe.

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

15 Responses to “MigrationWatch is scaremongering, as usual”

  1. LB

    immigrants have a detrimental impact on employment,

    Really? Most complaints are that some of the migrants cause problems.

    The main complaint boils down to some migrants getting something for nothing.

    So since migration is optional, why should we accept the detrimental migrants? We should accept the beneficial migrants in my opinion.

    The problem is that you spend 11K per person per year.

    How many migrants pay more tax than 11K a year? Per migrant. eg. Family of 4, needs 44K a year in tax.

    That’s the problem. Migrants not paying that level of tax are being subsidized. They are spending other people’s pensions and adding to the debt.

  2. LB

    As MigrantWatch has pointed out, 26 million Bulgarians and Romanians will be able to move to the UK from January 1st 2014


    How? We’ve eaten their transport. [2 jokes for the price of one]

  3. Old Albion

    So! let’s see. We have around 2.5M unemployed in the (dis)UK. Let’s also say .5M come here from Bulgaria and Romania and they ALL find work. WE still have 2.5M unemployed.
    Let’s say none of our new found Romania and Bulgarian chums find work. Now we have 3M unemployed.
    O/K those are the extreme outcomes of the impending immigration. But surely even the far-left can see unfettered immigration is damaging the (dis)UK. ?

  4. Mr Reasonable

    I bet you can’t wait to welcome back the 750,000 Britons who live in the EU…

  5. Old Albion

    And how many of those 750,000 Britons, would you say have gone to other EU countries comfortable in the knowledge that should they not wish to work. Or even were unable to find work. Their new country would hand them out benefits that eclipse the earnings available to them back home?

Comments are closed.