More EU woe for slippery Salmond as Barroso shuns Sturgeon

Alex Salmond and the SNP suffered another EU slapdown this week as EC President Jose Manuel Barroso shunned Nicola Sturgeon.

Just a matter of hours after Alex Salmond argued this week it is David Cameron that now poses the biggest threat to Scotland’s position in the European Union, EC President José Manuel Barroso has rebuffed attempts for by Scottish ministers to discuss with him EU membership status of an independent Scotland.

Last month, deputy first minister Nicola Sturgeon contacted the Commission seeking a meeting following the President’s declaration an independent Scotland would need to re-apply for EU membership.

Responding to the request, however, Commission Vice President Maros Sefcovic concluded discussions at this stage would not prove useful.

In rebuffing Sturgeon’s request, he explained:

The European Commission has consistently refrained from expressing a position on questions of internal organisation related to the constitutional arrangements in the member states.

“The European Commission has expressed its views in general terms in responses to several parliamentary questions from members of the European Parliament to which the European Commission is democratically accountable.

“However, the European Commission has not commented on any specific situation in relation to any member state and will continue to refrain from doing so. The European Commission would only be able to express its opinion on the legal consequences under EU law of a specific situation upon request from a member state detailing a precise scenario.”

He continued:

“At the present stage in the absence of a precise scenario, President Barroso has, therefore, asked me to signal that he would not be in a position to usefully discuss this further with you.

Responding to the letter on a blogpost, the deputy first minister has drawn attention to the phrase in the letter saying Barroso would refrain from commenting on “any specific situation in relation to any member state”. This, she argued, showed last month’s comments by Barroso “were not actually meant to be specifically about Scotland at all”.

She continued:

“Fine. That is helpful and effectively reasserts the Commission’s previous position of neutrality on this issue. The Commission have moved back into neutral gear.

“The letter goes on to argue that since they don’t have a position on a particular case then there is nothing usefully to be gained from a meeting at this stage. That’s a pity since the world has moved on even since December.”

The developments come as the MEP who began the process of the Salmond ‘Omnishambles’ – that revealed the Scottish government was launching legal action to prevent the publication of non-exist ant legal advice on EU membership if Scotland went independent – has argued the Scottish government still has serious questions to answer.

Speaking to, the Scottish Labour MEP Catherine Stihler (who made the Freedom of Information request for the information), was critical of the time taken to reveal the truth.

She told the website:

I had a baby in the time it took to get this answer, but I’m so glad I persisted. In politics you have to keep asking questions and keep chasing the answer. In this case it was to get an answer to a question that impacts on Scotland’s future.

“Now, if you’re in government you have a responsibility to the people, and if you want to make these huge complex changes, you should have legal advice to back it up – you agree, right? I’m not out of order here, am I? But I spent 17 months chasing this answer that basically told me the SNP’s legal advice was non-existent.

“Why not just admit that in the first place? Why say it’s not in the public interest? What confidence does this give you in them?”

Raising the questions the SNP still had to answer, she continued:

“Alex Salmond may have been cleared of breaching the ministerial code, but this is still an issue because the the SNP hasn’t yet answered what legal basis their 2007, 2009 and 2012 documents – which all refer to an independent Scotland and EU membership, by the way – are based on if they are only now seeking legal advice.

“More MEPs are showing an interest in how the Scottish independence issue progresses – it’s so complex and could have strong knock-on effects for the rest of Europe. Catalonia, for example. So when some people claim ‘oh, you can’t talk about this unless you’re Scottish’, that’s quite disappointing.

“We need to fully embrace that we’re a part of Europe. I have a German name, an American husband and I’m Scottish. That’s the world we live in!

Meanwhile, in Wales, first minister Carwyn Jones has attacked David Cameron’s Europe speech for playing into the hands of those looking to break up the UK.

Speaking of it having a “destabilising effect”, Jones explained:

“Let me be clear – the UK and Wales’ continued membership of the EU is vital for our economic success. As we strive for economic growth following the deep global recession, anything that puts a question mark over our membership of the EU is a mistake.

“Undoubtedly, the prime minister’s speech has constitutional repercussions for the UK itself. It plays into the hands of those who want to break up the United Kingdom. Having a crude and unnecessary in/out referendum, sends out confusing signals to the Scottish people about the UK’s continued membership of the EU.

“As a consequence, this speech will have a destabilising effect on the future of the United Kingdom at a time when we can ill-afford it.”

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

3 Responses to “More EU woe for slippery Salmond as Barroso shuns Sturgeon”

  1. Brian

    Translation – we can’t think of any reasons why Scotland will benefit from being part of the UK in the future, so here’s some recycled Labour Party anti-SNP propaganda instead.

  2. Brian

    Translation: We at Left Foot Forward can’t think of any positive reasons why Scotland will benefit from being part of the UK, so here’s some recycled New Labour Party anti-SNP propaganda instead.

  3. Garve Scott-Lodge

    The EU won’t talk to the Scottish Govt, only to ‘Govts of member states’ like the UK.
    The UK unionist parties say the SNP must provide details of an independent Scotland’s membership of the EU.
    But, the UK Govt won’t discuss this with the EU, saying it’s the SNP’s problem.
    That vicious circle may seem a delightful political wheeze for the unionist parties, but does it help voters to make the correct decision in 2014?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.