Fifty-five thousand HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) staff are on strike today over plans to axe 10,000 jobs from the department.
.
Fifty-five thousand HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) staff are on strike today over plans to axe 10,000 jobs from the department.
Following widespread media coverage last week of comedian Jimmy Carr’s tax affairs and Cameron’s subsequent denouncement of tax avoidance as “morally wrong”, the government are failing to tackle the problem by cutting staff that could mobilise a crackdown on tax avoidance.
These jobs cuts will be particularly damaging, considering Treasury secretary Danny Alexander said on Sunday that the ordinary person’s tax bill could be reduced by 2p in every pound if tax avoidance was reduced by a quarter.
Cutting tax avoidance however, will be impossible with a shortage of staff at HMRC.
Robert Monks, general secretary of the United Road Transport Union, said:
“For the current government to seek to justify job cuts among PCS members employed by HMRC at this time is nothing short of scandalous. When you have the current prime minister making such an issue of tax avoidance, the last thing that this country needs at this present moment in time is further job cuts at HMRC.”
Interestingly however, a YouGov poll showed the prime minister’s approval rating at minus 18 (38% say he is doing well, 56% say badly), the highest since the Budget three months ago.
• So, Mr Cameron, are Tory boys Philip Green and Gary Barlow “morally wrong” as well? 21 Jun 2012
• French leaders attack Cameron’s “red carpet” invite to tax exiles as Carr gets owned 19 Jun 2012
• Osborne allows tax avoiders to get away with murder – while you pick up the tab 15 May 2012
• Osborne, Barclays, the Cayman Islands and tax avoidance 17 Apr 2012
President of YouGov Peter Kellner said:
The prime minister’s condemnation of Jimmy Carr may well have done him some good.
However, data taken in reference to tax avoidance shows the government must take responsibility for evaders. Kellner continued:
Although a majority, 60%, think the rich have a moral duty to pay their fair share of tax and not use artificial tax avoidance schemes, a substantial minority, 36% think the tax avoiders have acted reasonably, on the grounds that ‘it’s the government’s job to pass stricter laws if they want the rich to pay more tax’
So with the majority of the public expecting the government to crack down on tax avoidance, why aren’t they? Is there a connection here between wealthy tax avoiders (some of which are Tory donors) and the government’s refusal to make tackling it a priority?
54 Responses to “As tax avoidance fills the headlines, 10,000 jobs to be cut at HMRC”
Liza Harding
RT @leftfootfwd: As tax avoidance fills the headlines, 10,000 jobs to be cut at HMRC http://t.co/ggkxbCDT
JC
If we’re lucky, it’s a start to a much simpler tax system. A flat rate with no tax deductible allowances apart from a fixed personal allowance of whatever 45hrs/week at the minimum wage is (must allow for overtime) would reduce the number of HMRC staff required. If all income were included (capital gains, inheritance etc) and everyone paid as if it were PAYE (no dividends from your own limited companies) we could manage without tax accountants and lawyers as well as tax collectors. Those left could focus on VAT and company tax fraud.
Selohesra
It wouldn’t make much difference if they employed 10,000 extra people at the processing end – what is needed is for politicians to enact more watertight rules and the government to hire one or two of the top tax lawyers to challenge some of the more dubious schemes legality/efficacy
Anonymous
No, of course not. Going to get away with your own schemes now are you? Sigh.
Anonymous
Ah yes, gotta give the rich a MASSIVE tax cut. And a massive slash in the allowance (and 45 hours a week now, as a standard? Yup, gotta have the poor work more).