MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms

MSPs today expressed “grave concerns” over the likely impact on Scotland’s most vulnerable people as a result of Westminster’s £2.5 billion cut in benefits.

E-mail-sign-up Donate

 

.

MSPs have today expressed their “grave concerns” over the likely impact on Scotland’s most vulnerable people as a result of Westminster’s £2.5 billion cut in benefits.

Kenny-DalglishIn publishing a report recommending support for the scottish government’s Welfare Provision (Further Provision) (Scotland) Bill which seeks to limit the likely widespread impact of the UK Welfare Reform Act on the poor and vulnerable in Scotland, Labour MSP, Michael McMahon, Convenor of Holyrood’s Welfare Reform Committee argued:

“We heard from witnesses about the bleak picture for those on welfare and the scale of personal impact that is likely to follow the UK reforms. We have grave concerns for the future of Scotland’s most vulnerable people.

“This comes at a time when the Scottish welfare budget is being cut by £2.5 billion. Seeking to limit even some of the negative impacts of reforms is therefore no mean feat.

“Our Committee has provided a forum for the concerns of individuals, service providers and campaign groups, to help to ensure their voice can be heard. It is important in the coming months and years that we are able to use this evidence to address those concerns by influencing forthcoming legislation and its implementation in Scotland.”

Alex Johnstone, the sole Conservative member of the committee however objected to the use of the term “grave concerns”.

 


See also:

Lib Dems have “ceased to function as a viable party in Scotland” 9 May 2012

The Tories in Scotland: right message, wrong messengers 26 Mar 2012

IDS gets it wrong on disability allowance 14 May 2012


 

Outlining emerging themes that come from consideration of Westminster’s welfare reforms, the committee notes that:

Changes to the benefits system will “remove lifeline benefits from large numbers of vulnerable people.”

• The means of applying for new benefits is “complex”, requiring greater use of online applications and “stressful capacity assessments” for finding those with long term disabilities as able to work.

330,000 people are caught within an appeals system that “overturns two thirds of these assessment results and time taken by medical professionals on the appeals process is impacting on frontline NHS services.”

• There will be a “major impact on the independence of disabled people, and on child poverty and homelessness levels.”

• “The likelihood of individuals and families getting into serious debt, including rent arrears, due to the new arrangements for allocating income support and benefit is increased.”

• As the instigator of the reforms, the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) “has done limited work to assess the impacts on different groups in society and therefore working out where to target support is not possible.”

Turning its attention to the Scottish government’s legislation to mitigate some of the impact of the reforms, the committee’s report argues:

The DWP has a responsibility to provide “full and proper advice services to help claimants make the adjustments to the new benefits systems.” The committee notes however that “it would also be appropriate for the Scottish Government to examine whether it requires to support bodies whom claimants are likely to turn to for independent advice and assistance.”

• Significant problems can be anticipated for local authorities and housing associations both in transition and through reduced income and increased costs of borrowing as a result of the decision to consume housing benefit into the new universal credit.

• The DWP should have primary responsibility for undertaking “extensive modelling to understand the impacts of welfare reform in Scotland and the policy responses to it, e.g. in establishing criteria for passported benefits.”

• “The main aim of the Scottish government in implementing the new welfare system should be in so far as is possible to maintain eligibility to passported benefits as they are at present.”

This is yet another blow to Iain Duncan Smith, whose war on genuine claimants knows no bounds.

 


Sign-up to our weekly email • Donate to Left Foot Forward

27 Responses to “MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms”

  1. Ebony Dawn Marsh

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/kOMJeH6l

  2. Janet Graham

    MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms, reports @EdJacobs1985: http://t.co/2vCcMhbR

  3. Wordocalypse

    MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms, reports @EdJacobs1985: http://t.co/2vCcMhbR

  4. K Carington Smith

    MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms, reports @EdJacobs1985: http://t.co/2vCcMhbR

  5. Political Planet

    MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms: MSPs today expressed “grave concerns” over the likely im… http://t.co/K93TntLP

  6. Ed Jacobs

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/oC9b73Qw

  7. BevR

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/3cLuoluw

  8. johnny_wheelz

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/3cLuoluw

  9. Foxy52

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/3cLuoluw

  10. hay

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/3cLuoluw

  11. Mr. Sensible

    The government need to seriously think about this.

  12. Anonymous

    You seem to think that they’re NOT thinking…I believe they know *exactly* what they’re doing and where they’re going. All the government’s real embarrassments are at having to back down from minor portions of their plans.

  13. Alan Cowan

    UK welfare reforms concerns http://t.co/t5XQkla4

  14. Coryn Barclay

    UK welfare reforms concerns http://t.co/t5XQkla4

  15. allbigideastartsmall

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/2QSxQs34

  16. BevR

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/3cLuoluw

  17. paul and lynn hewitt

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/3cLuoluw

  18. Stella Harding

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/3cLuoluw

  19. BendyGirl

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/mqwe4vPH

  20. Vivienne Ward

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/mqwe4vPH

  21. Stella Harding

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/mqwe4vPH

  22. Martin Steel

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/mqwe4vPH

  23. Gerard

    Yes the committee have slammed the decisions by the UK Government but that is not what the committee was set up to look at. The media have missed the real story on this one:

    The Welfare Reform Bill cannot be changed by Holyrood, but the Scottish Government response can be looked at and that is what the committee was set up to do. Its a technical story, and therefore not very sexy as a story, but the SNP members of that committee have let down the charities et al who are affected by these reforms. They asked for greater scrutiny of each part of the Scottish Government response and the SNP MSPs have shut that down. This means the Scottish Government will not be held to account for their response to the Welfare Reform Bill.

    This is another example of the SNP abusing the lack of checks and balances on display due to their majority.

    A bad day for democracy in Scotland. A bad day for the people of Scotland who will be affected by the Bill and have no opportunity to make sure the SNP government stand up for them adequately.

  24. Chris Salter

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/68R17MSr #ppnews #wrb #spartacusreport

  25. WorkfareProtest

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/68R17MSr #ppnews #wrb #spartacusreport

  26. liane gomersall

    RT @leftfootfwd: MSPs outline “grave concerns” about UK welfare reforms http://t.co/J0s2YQUV

  27. Look Left – The Tory Olympic legacy, Osbornomics under siege and IDS | Left Foot Forward

    […] on Wednesday, MSPs expressed “grave concerns” over the likely impact on Scotland’s most vulnerable people as a result of the coalition’s […]

Leave a Reply