Calamity Grayling misuses the stats (again)

Gaffe-prone employment minister Chris Grayling added to his opus of incompetence today; Shamik Das chronicles all his balls ups down the years.

E-mail-sign-up Donate



Gaffe-prone employment minister Chris Grayling added to his opus of incompetence today by claiming large numbers of previously ‘stay at home’ mothers were deciding to look for work, leading to a big reduction in ‘economic inactivity’ among women – a claim which, as usual with Grayling or his DWP master IDS, doesn’t stand up.

Calamity-GraylingIPPR’s Nick Pearce has more:

To back up this claim, Grayling highlighted figures showing a 71,000 drop in female economic inactivity over the last year. These also confirm that there has been an 85,000 rise in the number of women unemployed, so even if they are looking for work many are not finding it.

However, looking beneath the headline figures the story is not quite as the minister claims. The Office for National Statistics (pdf) breaks down inactivity by age groups. This does show that inactivity among women aged 16–64 has fallen by 71,000. However, that’s not the whole story.

Inactivity among women aged 16-17 had dropped by 10,000 in the last year, but most won’t be parents. Looking at those aged between 18 and 49 – when most women have young children – economic inactivity has actually increased by 3,000 in the last year. By contrast, among older women, aged 50-64, inactivity has reduced by 63,000.

Another way of putting this is that almost 90 per cent of the drop in female inactivity in the last year had been among women aged over 50. Not quite the story Chris Grayling was trying to tell.

With C4 Fact Check adding:

The IPPR actually thinks the figures show the reverse of what Mr Grayling wants them to show.

Mr Pearce said:

“It is much more likely that women with young children are being put off a return to work – through a combination of cuts to tax credits and childcare support and the tough job market – with major negative long-term consequences for them and the economy as a whole.

“By contrast many older women are realising that they don’t have the pension provision they hoped for and so need to stay in employment – or at least look for work – for longer.”

Of course that’s just a theory, but so is Mr Grayling’s notion about mothers trying (and apparently failing) to return to work.

And a more in-depth look at the government’s own figures suggests it’s a theory that doesn’t hold much much water.

Slam dunk.

Not that we should be surprised; as the links below highlight, Left Foot Forward has long chronicled the calamities of one of the Tory party’s most incompetent frontbenchers, in opposition as in government:


How DWP’s incompetence cost taxpayers and disabled people 16 Apr 2012

Chris Grayling should respond to criticism of workfare, not smear the critics 21 Feb 2012

Employment minister Chris Grayling does not appear to understand his own disability reforms 13 Jan 2012

“Demonising the government”: Sue Marsh v Chris Grayling (and Emily Maitlis) 13 Jan 2012

Forget Grayling’s excuses: Record joblessness is solely the fault of this government 12 Oct 2011

Grayling dragged into Fox/Werritty scandal – are Osborne, Gove and Hague next? 10 Oct 2011

Grayling’s tabloid pandering gone mad 29 Aug 2011

Grayling’s “ticking time bomb” – more misdirection from IDS’s DWP? 24 Jan 2011

UK Statistics Authority: “Serious deficiencies” in DWP use of statistics 26 Nov 2010

IDS’ stats rebuke is tip of the iceberg 19 Nov 2010

Investigation ordered into DWP’s use of statistics 11 Nov 2010

New Grayling porkie on welfare reform statistics 27 Oct 2010

Another balls-up by Calamity Chris! 12 Aug 2010

Grayling’s use of crime stats attacked by fact checkers 27 Apr 2010

Grayling fails to welcome fall in violent crime 23 Apr 2010

Cameron slams Grayling on B&B remarks 20 Apr 2010

Out of hiding, Calamity Grayling is wrong on drugs & reoffending 9 Apr 2010

Calamity Grayling opposes Cameron’s unilateral bank tax 20 Mar 2010

Grayling fails to release full details of “study” showing rise in violent crime 9 Mar 2010

Weak link Grayling: Wrong on the facts, wrong on the stats 3 Feb 2010

Grayling’s household defence plans slammed as “state-sponsored revenge” 25 Jan 2010

Grayling seeks to emulate Irish Government’s “licence to kill” home defence bill 21 Dec 2009

Grayling’s immigration cap is “completely Stalinist” 10 Dec 2009

Gray days for Grayling 9 Oct 2009

Grayling’s revisionism on Wire comparisons 6 Oct 2009

Grayling’s fears over new vetting scheme misplaced 11 Sep 2009

Grayling depicts Wire fiction as fact 25 Aug 2009


To screw up once may be considered unlucky, twice unfortunate; to have done so repeatedly? Still, I suppose he makes the rest of them look like they know what they’re doing… Wait a minute!


Sign-up to our weekly email • Donate to Left Foot Forward

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

30 Responses to “Calamity Grayling misuses the stats (again)”

  1. Sue Rees

    RT @leftfootfwd: Calamity Grayling misuses the stats (again)

  2. Foxy52

    RT @leftfootfwd: Calamity Grayling misuses the stats (again)

  3. Kevin Richards

    Foot in mouth comes to mind – RT @leftfootfwd: Calamity #Grayling misuses the stats (again)

  4. WorkfareProtest

    Calamity Grayling misuses the stats (again): reports @ShamikDas #CalamityChris

  5. IRejectFPTP

    Calamity Grayling misuses the stats (again): reports @ShamikDas #CalamityChris

Comments are closed.