Will Grayling and IDS stand up to Osborne over £10bn DWP cuts?

George Osborne may face a fight over the planned £10 billion welfare cuts, with DWP ministers Chris Grayling and Iain Duncan Smith at odds with the chancellor.

E-mail-sign-up Donate



George Osborne may face a fight over the planned £10 billion cuts to the Department for Work and Pensions, with DWP ministers Chris Grayling and Iain Duncan reportedly at odds with the chancellor.

Today’s Financial Times reports (£):

Plans by the chancellor to take £10bn a year, or almost £1 in £20, out of the welfare budget are being openly resisted by the department for work and pensions in the first sign of government infighting over the coming spending round.

Employment minister Chris Grayling told the FT:

“What the chancellor did in his budget was set out a framework for government as a whole and that £10bn is a figure that applies across government. He expressed the desire that we make further savings in welfare as part of that, but… we haven’t begun that kind of discussion yet.”

With an aide to Work and Pensions secretary Iain Duncan Smith adding:

“From our perspective, we wouldn’t see this as simply £10bn off the DWP budget, and I’m pretty sure we’ll be making that point as and when we sit down with the Treasury.”

As IPPR’s Richard Darlington explained on Left Foot Forward last week, a cut of “£1 in £20” will hit hard:

[As Chart 1 shows], two-fifths (42%) of welfare spending goes on pensioners: a whooping £77bn in total. And more than 15% – £31bn – goes on children, via child benefit and the child tax credit. That’s almost £6 out of every £10 of welfare spending accounted for and, so far, not a “scrounger” in sight.

Then we’ve got another 10% going on support for disabled people – and this should not be confused with incapacity benefit, now called employment and support allowance, or ESA. A further 5% goes to carers and boosting the incomes of the working poor.

Only a shade over a 10th of the benefits bill – and a far smaller share of total public spending – is actually spent on directly replacing the incomes of those not in work, through jobseeker’s allowance, income support and ESA (£21bn in total). The remaining large items of spending are council tax benefit (£5bn) and housing benefit (£20bn).

Chart 1:



See also:

Budget 2012: Breaking down the benefits bill 21 Mar 2012

The DWP’s ‘scrounger’ rhetoric is causing real harm 26 Feb 2012

Exposed: The six myths of IDS’s benefits cap 23 Jan 2012

The human cost of the government’s inhumane welfare reforms 20 Jan 2012

Yes, but are you REALLY disabled? 20 Jan 2012


Still, the row aside, it appears Grayling has finally grasped the simple concept that getting people into work and off benefits is the best way to bring down the deficit – not slashing spending, rising unemployment and a looming double-dip:

“If we are successful in getting people off benefits and into work, that will generate a saving for the nation and that’s not accounted for at this moment in time.”


Sign-up to our weekly email • Donate to Left Foot Forward

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by becoming a Left Foot Forward Supporter today.