Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles

Ed Miliband will lay out his plans for a new era of responsibility at the top and outline his vision of “one nation banking” in a speech to Reuters today.

 

Ed Miliband will lay out his plans for a new era of responsibility at the top of society and outline his vision of “one nation banking” in a keynote speech to Reuters in Canary Wharf this morning.

The Leader of the Opposition will reflect on the scandals of the past week, which have included the row over RBS chief Stephen Hester’s million pound bonus; the de-knighting of former RBS boss Mr Fred Goodwin; and Network Rail’s moves to reward fat cats with bonus schemes that could double their salary over the next five years.


Looking ahead to how a better banking system should run, he will say:

“There are three principles to restore the link between banks and society.

Transparency – so that banks publish the details of all their large bonuses. We have called on the government to implement rules we legislated for to make banks reveal how many employees are earning over one million pounds, so that consumers can take this into account when choosing where to bank.

Accountability to employees so that companies put some of their ordinary employees – maybe a teller normally at high street bank window – on the committee which sets executives’ top pay. If you can’t look one of your own employees in the eye when you receive a huge bonus, you should not get it.

“And accountability to shareholders. When banks that are majority-owned by the taxpayer, David Cameron must exercise some shareholder oversight on top pay. He says he believes that shareholders should exert their influence over pay at the top. All I ask is that he should practice what he preaches.

“After transparency and accountability – is responsibility. That means ending the culture of excessive bonuses. It is corrosive. It enriches individual bankers, but weakens the banking sector as a whole.

“Nobody begrudges rewards for genuine risk-takers. Nobody begrudges exceptional rewards for exceptional performance. That is how capitalism should work. But exceptional rewards for exceptional performance means the kind of huge bonuses which have caused such controversy recently should not be handed out for just doing your job.

“They should not be a one-way bet.”

Reflecting further on the problems of the present, he will add:

“These are symbols – and symptoms – of public discontent with a system that is not working any more. Not for our economy. And not for our society. But these moments in our national life should not be the end of the debate. They should be the start.

“This is not about one man, one bonus, or one knighthood. Nor is this about the politics of envy. It is about a culture of responsibility.

“Labour has set out the case for new rules to tackle irresponsibility from the benefits office to the boardroom. Values of fairness matter more than ever when times are tough.

“The consequences of the financial crisis are felt every time a library closes, every time a school can’t afford a new book, and every time a policeman or policewoman is taken off the beat.

“The banking sector needs to understand this. People who did not cause the financial crisis are paying the price. Too many of those who did cause the financial crisis are not.

“Banking has a history of performing invaluable service to the economy which we do not celebrate enough: from Midland Bank’s role restructuring the cotton industry in the 1930s, to Barclays’ role in financing high tech startups in Cambridge in the seventies and eighties, or more recently, the way HSBC, Barclays, Lloyds, RBS and Standard Chartered put up £2.5 billion for a business growth fund focused on British firms.

“But this is a call for banking to recognise it has reached a crossroads. To recognise that continuing on its current path will lead to further isolation from society, greater public anger – and an economy which does not pay its way in the world.

“This is a call on banking to recognise that it should take the path of change. To recognise that it is not isolated from the economy or society. To recognise that we succeed or fail together.

“One nation banking recognises that banks must not be isolated from the rest of the economy. Because banks and small businesses must succeed or fail together, banks must lend to small businesses so we can get the growth and jobs we need for the future.”

And on the forthcoming Parliamentary vote on banking and bonuses, Miliband will say:

“This is about taking the first step away from bonus culture and towards one nation banking. It is about leadership to take the first step towards responsible capitalism. That is why we will have Commons vote on Tuesday.

“We will say that that too many are getting bonuses which are too big, too often. All companies must show responsibility but banks have a particular responsibility because they are either directly or indirectly supported by the taxpayer.

“We will give MPs the chance to vote on having another bank bonus tax to get 100,000 of our young people back to work. but we will also ask MPs to vote on ending a bonus culture based on one-way bets rather than genuine reward for exceptional performance.

“It will not be legislation and it will not be binding. But it will allow the voices of millions of people across our country to be heard. People who do a fair day’s work for a fair day’s pay, who wake up early to go to work and get home late just like you, who work hard just like you.

“Their voices which will be heard through our vote in Parliament on Tuesday. Because at the core of one nation Banking is the idea that as a country, we succeed or fail together.”

The challenge has been made – it’s now up to David Cameron and George Osborne to show they get it with their actions not merely their words.

Miliband has laid out a progressive path to deal with the problems the banking, bankers and bonuses have created, to instill fairness in the system and force responsibility at the top; it’s now time for the government to either back him or come up with something better. The ball’s in their court.

See also:

The government has the power to stop Hester’s bonus, they just don’t want toBen Fox, January 27th 2012

All in it together? RBS fat cat “in line for £7m payout”. Seven. MillionShamik Das, January 27th 2012

Implementing Vickers won’t stop the next crisisJosh Ryan Collins, December 20th 2011

How bankers’ bonuses are contributing to the new credit crunchCormac Hollingsworth, December 6th 2011

The rotten borough of the City of London needs to be dragged into the 21st centuryJenny Jones AM, November 4th 2011

As energy company buckles, Miliband needs to pick more battlesAlex Hern, October 12th 2011

The fragmented society: How irresponsibility and inequality feed off each otherDuncan Exley, August 12th 2011

20 Responses to “Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles”

  1. John Turner

    Transparency, accountability, responsibility: @Ed_Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles: http://t.co/p4obYAgZ by @ShamikDas

  2. Claire Spencer

    .@Ed_Miliband's speech on banking reform seems shrewd: http://t.co/V3QjeBJ1 Transparency, responsibility, accountability. (via @ShamikDas)

  3. Patron Press - #P2

    #UK : Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles http://t.co/EzYVaY8F

  4. Political Planet

    Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles: Ed Miliband will lay o… http://t.co/mJzv0RWV

  5. John Turner

    .@Ed_Miliband's speech on banking reform seems shrewd: http://t.co/V3QjeBJ1 Transparency, responsibility, accountability. (via @ShamikDas)

  6. leftlinks

    Left Foot Forward – Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation… http://t.co/yNe9yBhP

  7. BevR

    Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles http://t.co/SvwDi2xx #WRB#SPARTACUSREPORT#ATOS#UNUM

  8. Pulp Ark

    Transparency, accountability, responsibility:… http://t.co/MyJcEEtN #Sustainable_Economy #accountability #banking #muslim #tcot #sioa

  9. Hein Albeda

    Het VK over de banken RT @leftfootfwd: Transparency, accountability, responsibility: “one nation banking” principles: http://t.co/V3Y2UuA6

  10. Anonymous

    13 years in Power banks making billions but had massive debt, bonus payments into the billions and labour now tell the Tories how to act, you had a well know dark angel telling people you hate people getting rich. I’m sorry it like trying to close the door of the stable after the stable has fallen down around your ears.

    I suspect a bit of welfare bashing and money going to the right people private sector being told they can have a lot of the public sector, a few concentration camp building for the poorest in society run by a banking charity. in other words it’s bull shit for Miliband who was Blair bag carrier then Browns minister then leader of the Labour party and his brother who is out making money in the private sector
    give a shit about Labour or what labour stands for

  11. Michele Paule

    Transparency, accountability, responsibility: @Ed_Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles: http://t.co/1v4TWEjr by @ShamikDas

  12. JC

    I know this sounds a little negative, but when the government took a stake in Lloyds-HBOS and RBS, I believe that it was done through non-voting shares. On that basis, even though the government is a major shareholder, they cannot vote on issues. If that is the case, it is disingenuous of Ed to suggest that the government is in a position to influence bank decisions. If it is not the case then there should be government appointed board directors (a horrible thought – John Prescott?).

    We need to have a debate on remuneration and how people should be rewarded. This should not be confined to the upper echelons of organisations, but must be comprehensive. How should we reward a teacher, a cleaner, a doctor? We should consider artists – was it right that Freud became so wealthy? Or Damian Hirst? What about Paul McCartney? Also consider Richard Branson, Tim Dyson and Brian Souter. We cannot imply that everyone is a special case, we must have a set of principles that can be applied generally. What do we do about the salesperson who brings in a £10M project and the project manager who delivers it for £8M as well as the staff on the project. We waste time picking on individual cases without some framework to suggest what should be done instead of what shouldn’t

  13. Bev Craig

    Good stuff from Ed:RT @leftfootfwdTransparency,accountability,responsibility:Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles http://t.co/jJvB62Y2

  14. Patrick

    So let’s get this straight. Labour were in power for 13 years adopting a policy of light-touch financial regulation. Now they’re in opposition, they lecture the current government about stringent regulation. Laughable.

  15. Miliband: British Investment Bank could provide government banking for entrepreneurs when market fails | Left Foot Forward

    […] Ed Miliband’s speech this morning will be overshadowed by the events surrounding Chris Huhne and any coverage that he does get will focus on his banker bashing. But the more interesting section of his statement at the Thomson Reuters building is on potential reforms to the banking sector. […]

  16. Anonymous

    It’s a funny old world is it not

  17. ECB bailing out British banks exposes coalition’s finance failure | Left Foot Forward

    […] Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles – Shamik Das, February 3rd […]

  18. Umunna’s arguments expose the ideological divisions in the coalition | Left Foot Forward

    […] Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation banking” principles 3 Feb […]

  19. After the Barclays Libor scandal, how long must we wait for a public inquiry? | Left Foot Forward

    […] Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s “one nation banking” prin… 3 February […]

  20. David Cameron: once enraged over rioters, now complacent over bankers | Left Foot Forward

    […] Transparency, accountability, responsibility: Miliband’s ‘one nation’ banking prin… 3 February […]

Leave a Reply