Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny

Lib Dem deputy leader Simon Hughes has called for England to have its own Parliament, while Scottish first minister Alex Salmond has come under fresh scrutiny.

 

Sign up to our weekly “Week Outside Westminster” email service summarising the week’s news from Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland

Lib Dem deputy leader Simon Hughes has ratcheted up the constitutional stakes over the future of the union by calling for England to be given its own Parliament.

Following a week which saw former Welsh and Northern Ireland secretary, Paul Murphy, calling for consideration to be given again to the idea of devolution within England and the establishment by the UK government of a commission to look at the West Lothian question, Hughes used a speech to Lib Dem members in Derby on Saturday evening to dub the on-going debate about the future of Scotland “an opportunity to make an important constitutional decision about the way we make laws in England in the future too”.

He continued:

“The present system has become unjust to England and should not continue. At last we have an opportunity to correct this in this parliament.

“We now have a chance to make a decision which will be good for lawmaking, good for parliament, good for the public and good for all four corners of the United Kingdom.”

His remarks come ahead of a week that will see further steps being taken towards a referendum on Scottish independence.

Having been challenged by Nick Clegg on the Andrew Marr programme to provide greater clarity and answers about what an independent Scotland would look like, Alex Salmond will use Burns Day this Wednesday to publish the Scottish government’s consultation on a referendum which, according to the Sunday Mail, will include a wish list comprised of allowing 16 and 17 year olds to vote in the poll and holding the vote on a Saturday in Autumn 2014.

It is thought, however, that the SNP will cede to calls to allow the Electoral Commission to oversee the operation of the vote.

Looking ahead to the consultation’s publication, Salmond used an interview on Sky News’s Murnaghan programme to argue an independent Scotland would be fairer for England as well as Scotland.

He said:

“We will share a monarch, we will share a currency and, under our proposals, we will share a social union, but we won’t have diktats from Westminster for Scotland and we won’t have Scottish MPs poking their nose into English business in the House of Commons.

“There have been a lot of rather injudicious things said by Westminster politicians about Scotland. I will be a lot more positive about the future of England than people like David Cameron have been hitherto about the future of Scotland.”

Meanwhile, as the first minister continues to steamroll ahead with his plans for a referendum, the substance of his proposals have come in for attack from a group of senior, former ex-military chiefs.

Following Salmond outlining his vision on BBC Scotland last week of a Scottish Defence Force that would combine the army, navy and air force, the Sunday Telegraph has carried a series of criticisms from a group of former army commanders of the plans.

Declaring that the SNP Leader had “absolutely no grasp of how the British Armed Forces work”,  Lt Col Sir Andrew Ogilvy-Wedderburn spoke for those cited by concluding:

“This would lead to the downfall and demise of famous regiments, such as the Scots Guards and The Black Watch, as the soldiers would vote with their feet and leave because their pride would not allow them to serve with what is little more than a third world militia.”

See also:

The Week Outside Westminster – Answering the West Lothian questionEd Jacobs, January 21st 2012

Win or lose, Scottish independence referendum heralds a revolution in UK politicsEd Jacobs, January 16th 2012

What is patriotism in Britain today?Carl Packman, November 27th 2011

Clegg’s Scottish discomfortEd Jacobs, January 17th 2011

The left-wing case for an English parliamentDave Dyke, March 18th 2010

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

17 Responses to “Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny”

  1. Ed Jacobs

    RT @leftfootfwd: Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond comes under fresh scrutiny http://t.co/ARn7ZTiJ

  2. keith ferguson

    Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond comes under fresh scrutiny | Left Foot Forward – http://t.co/kBA4mKPV

  3. BevR

    RT @leftfootfwd: Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny http://t.co/GHNIEaK8

  4. Political Planet

    Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny: Lib Dem deputy leader Simon Hug… http://t.co/zYSxo7H8

  5. Anonymous

    Just what the UK needs. More politicians.

    EU,
    Westminster
    Regional assemblies
    District councils
    Parish councils.
    Quangos – hundreds of them

  6. BevR

    Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny: http://t.co/v7JyexmG reports @EdJacobs1985

  7. Selohesra

    Not a big fan of Simon Hughes – but on this he is right. We are either United Kingdom and all decide on everything or we let regions decide things for themselves in which case that should include the English

  8. Patron Press - #P2

    #UK : Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny http://t.co/teP7TpZr

  9. Selohesra

    Get rid of Westminster – and have English Parliament choosing where English taxes are spent in England – lose 650 mps and replace with 150 say for English parliament – bigger constituencuies fine in the modern era with e-communication & better travel systems

  10. Pulp Ark

    Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as… http://t.co/0doBIp25 #A_Britain_We_All_Call_Home #Alex_Salmond #muslim #tcot #sioa

  11. leftlinks

    Left Foot Forward – Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny http://t.co/8FSdwyvu

  12. WestMonster

    RT @leftfootfwd: Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny: http://t.co/Yn3vqxUw reports @EdJacobs1985

  13. Charles Addison

    The Scottish armed forces would collapse for want of “pride”?! Is that seriously his argument! So far this week, I’ve read that the proposed units would be too few then that they were to grand for such a small country. Even I know they can’t both be right. And during all this, Labour politicians of dubious CND credentials, have explained to us why we must keep the Bomb on the Clyde: for the jobs, for the good of the nation, to avoid picking up the bill for relocation. So much for their leftwing commitment!

  14. Toque

    RT @leftfootfwd: Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny http://t.co/15DnvsLZ

  15. Hotspur

    RT @leftfootfwd: Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny http://t.co/15DnvsLZ

  16. Anonymous

    Lord Blagger we’ll get rid of Westminster and the House of Lords and replace it with an English Parliament. Massive saving there!

  17. Miliband to outline vision of a fairer Union | Left Foot Forward

    […] Hughes makes the case for an English Parliament as Salmond faces fresh scrutiny – Ed Jacobs Share | Permalink | Leave a comment /* © Left Foot […]

Leave a Reply