Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen?

Should the Northern Ireland Football team should sing “God Save the Queen” before their matches? Ed Jacobs investigates.

 

The Belfast Telegraph has today published a series of articles focusing on one of the more contentious issues in Northern Ireland sport, namely whether or not the Northern Ireland Football team should sing “God Save the Queen” before their matches.


The debate comes just weeks after the former Northern Ireland player Paul McVeigh called for the anthem to be dropped as it served, he argued, only to alienate Catholic players who as a result preferred the lure of playing for the Republic of Ireland.

In calling on the Irish Football Association (IFA) to do more to retain the best players in the north, McVeigh last month declared:

“The IFA has to make decisions if it wants to stop players from the north opting to play for the Republic and the answers are staring them in the face.

Who are the people who make decisions at IFA level and can they really say that it is a good thing for football in Northern Ireland to have the English anthem played before games?

“Northern Ireland, as long as it continues with that anthem, will not have an identity of its own and players will continue to turn to the Republic.

“I don’t care if the next manager of Northern Ireland is Fabio Capello; whoever gets the job starts it with his hands tied behind his back because he will not have many of the best players from the country to choose from.”

Following first minister Peter Robinson’s calls at his party’s annual conference a few weeks ago for an end to the sectarian divides that have long dogged Northern Irish society, the Belfast Telegraph’s reports expose not just how contagious the issue is but the impact playing then anthem has on wider society.

For Ed Curran, a columnist at the Belfast Telegraph, the continued playing of “God Save the Queen” sits badly with Robinson’s call’s for unity.

Outlining his calls for a new anthem he concludes:

“There is no more emotional moment in sport on this island than when God Save The Queen is played at Windsor Park and A Soldier’s Song at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin. And yet, in the context of 2011, I now feel they are both wrong.

“If Scotland and Wales can do it with Flower of Scotland and Land of My Fathers, so can Northern Ireland. Given our divisions, we have even more reason to find words to unite and inspire all – and not just some – of our talented international sportsmen and women.

“The singing of an anthem should come from the heart. It is about passion, spirit, commitment, loyalty and pride in one’s country. It should never invoke unease among some spectators, or – more importantly – among the players on the pitch.

“Yet that is precisely what happens in Dublin and in Belfast. The tight lips of international players standing uncomfortably to attention before games in both cities is a telling reminder of our divisions, if one were needed.”

For former Northern Ireland World Cup striker and IFA ambassador Gerry Armstrong, however, changing the song that is sung before football matches is simply tinkering about with the much larger sectarian problem.

Armstong, arguing the public support his case, writes:

“So should Northern Ireland drop the national anthem? After I researched the views of the up-and-coming generation of footballers, I found the results were hardly surprising.

“Predictably, there’s one view that thinks the move could bring a few more Catholics back to international matches at Windsor Park. But on the other hand it has become clear there would be a significant number of dissenters among the fans who have supported us through thick and thin.

“The research I’ve done points to a conclusion I had foreseen all along – there is no point, no benefit, when it comes to bridging the yawning gap in society here.”

The debate takes place as Sinn Fein culture minister, Caral Ni Chuilin, enraged unionists by declaring during yesterday’s Question Time that her department had had no discussions with Buckingham Palace about ways in which Northern Ireland could celebrate the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee next year.

In a strongly worded attack, Jim Allister, leader of the hard-line unionist party the TUV responded:

“Cullen’s response was an insult to the majority of people in Northern Ireland who hold the monarchy in very high regard. Her bigoted answer today again demonstrates her unfitness for office and exposes all of Sinn Fein/IRA’s fine words about wanting to see a shared future for what they are.”

See also:

New study of Orange Order exposes bigotry at the coreKevin Meagher, November 23rd 2011

Labour: Anti-sectarian legislation is right in spirit, but flawed in executionJames Kelly MSP, November 7th 2011

Sectarian Law will address “ugly element” within Scottish societyJohn Finnie MSP, November 3rd 2011

Northern Ireland: Are the sectarian divides beginning to crumble?Ed Jacobs, March 15th 2011

UUP seek to keep Sinn Fein away from the top jobEd Jacobs, September 7th 2010

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

20 Responses to “Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen?”

  1. Political Planet

    Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen?: Should the Northern Ireland Football team should sin… http://t.co/HvPYrLrZ

  2. Newsaccess

    Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Left Foot Forward http://t.co/hQjPNcHe

  3. Ireland Travel News

    Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Left Foot Forward http://t.co/b4KjSOXw

  4. Jamie

    Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? http://t.co/Cpi0YAhd

  5. Geoff, England

    Er, ‘God Save The Queen (or King)’ is not an English anthem. It isn’t even a British anthem. It’s used as a royal anthem by several members of the Commonwealth. it’s for the people of Northern Ireland to decide its use or otherwise in their six counties (which rightfully belong with the other 26, rather than in the Divided Kingdom), but I wish we could hear ‘Jerusalem’ used by England teams. The words are positive and progressive, unlike the sycophantic words to GSTQ, and the tune itself is stirring, unlike the depressing dirge of GSTQ.

    They should bring in a law that GSTQ may only be played in the presence of the monarch (like ‘Hail to the Chief’ is only played in the presence of the US President), and then declare a republic. Heaven for those who appreciate music with a melody, and who don’t scrape and bow.

  6. William DeZouza

    Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen?: For former Northern Ireland World Cup striker and IF… http://t.co/uaBhvvRM

  7. Ed Jacobs

    RT @leftfootfwd: Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? http://t.co/9UHd4g6n

  8. Northern Ireland

    Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Left Foot Forward http://t.co/H3BCj5lH #gawa #owc

  9. Mark Stevo

    Of course they should, just don’t replace it with that dirge Danny Boy or Ireland’s Call.

  10. Selohesra

    The Scots & the Welsh are a disgrace for not using National Anthem. Happy to be British and under our Queen when her parliament is shoving oodles of English taxes their way but its another story when asked to show a bit of respect

  11. Phaedo Tawkes

    I think the rugby fraternity show the way once more here. A united Ireland team would go a huge way to transcending sectional religions ethnic identities. Despite the sectarian nature of soccer in Ulster, something in common to cheer would gradually help bind the communities pace South Africa. But then again, probably not.

  12. SNP’s anti-sectarianism bill unites the opposition | Left Foot Forward

    […] also: • Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Ed Jacobs, December 13th […]

  13. Elena Santos

    http://t.co/uNGKdWOn Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Left Foot Forward

  14. Look Left – Labour hold Feltham but deeper problems remain | Left Foot Forward

    […] God Save The Queen should be scrapped as the anthem of the national football team – see my article for […]

  15. Elena Santos

    Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Left Foot Forward http://t.co/uNGKdWOn

  16. Elena Santos

    http://t.co/uNGKdWOn Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Left Foot Forward

  17. Preview 2012 – Northern Ireland | Left Foot Forward

    […] also: • Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Ed Jacobs, December 13th […]

  18. How does Northern Ireland achieve reconciliation in 2012? | Left Foot Forward

    […] Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Ed Jacobs, December 13th […]

  19. The changing face of healthcare in Northern Ireland | Left Foot Forward

    […] Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? – Ed Jacobs, December 13th […]

  20. ULSTER (still) SAYS NO | Left Foot Forward

    […] Should Northern Ireland football scrap God Save the Queen? 13 December […]

Leave a Reply