Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom

Alex Hern argues that much of the chancellor George Osborne’s plans for economic growth will put the UK in a race to the bottom which it cannot possibly win.

George Osborne today has signalled the dangerous new route he plans to go down, apparently in an effort to stimulate growth: Starting a race to the bottom. The problem Osborne has is that there is always going to be someone able to undercut the UK internationally, and there will always be someone prepared to act as badly as the law allows them domestically. If he starts that race, he will lose; and even if he wins, the bottom is not somewhere the UK should be.

He proudly announced:

“We’re cutting business taxes to one of the lowest rates in the developed world.”

Yet arguing, as he does, that we as a nation need to compete with states like Liechtenstein and Monaco – or, let us not forget, with British territories like the Cayman Islands, a hotbed of tax evasion – by lowering business taxes, he is entering in a race that we can never win.

These countries are tiny city-states, who fund what rudimentary welfare states they have with minimal tax revenue from companies whose presence in the country is often little more than a PO box.

Businesses do not headquarter there because of the quality of the staff, the access to markets, or the international prestige, but because and only because they can spend less on taxes. If we do manage to cut our rates to a level low enough to win these headquarters back – doing untold damage to our revenues in the process – then it is far easier for those countries to cut back again than it is for us.

The end result of this race is bad for all concerned, except the businesses who can make a quick buck.

The same is true for other Tory targets. When he euphemistically stated that:

“We also respect the right of the unemployed to get a job and not be priced out of the labour market”

Just like when Louise Mensch claimed this weekend:

“The left think they’re helping working people by providing more rights, but all that actually happens is you create poverty and despair, because jobs go to your competitors who have fewer rights for workers.”

What they both mean is that because nations overseas treat their workers badly, we must too. This is, plainly, madness. It is a mentality that will, without hyperbole, lead to deaths.

The four miners who died in Gleision brought back to the forefront of British minds how dangerous collieries can be; and yet, in China, there is an average of one death from coal mining each week. It is a nation that produces 35 per cent of the world’s coal, and has 80 per cent of the world’s deaths from coal mining.

If we do try and compete by lowering regulations, it is indeed China we’d be competing with. As Richard Exell has showed, we already have less employment protection than every other OECD state other than the USA; there’s no-one else to compete with other than the developing world.

Again, we should not try and see who can treat their workers worse or try and capture the market in low skilled, low paid and badly treated labour, but we should instead sell ourselves to companies on the quality of our workforce; on their education, on their ability and on the welfare state that ensures that the baseline is high. Winning business in this way is not a pipedream.

This race to the bottom is not just an international problem, either. Osborne calls for it domestically too, when he condemns unions as irresponsible:

to go on strike in economic times like this, when you’re being offered pensions far more generous than most other people could ever afford.

The claim that public sector pensions should be low because private sector pensions are low is often heard. But why should it be true? Why not instead make the opposite argument: that the only reason why private sector pensions are as high as they are is because they face competition from the public sector.

Some business may offer a fair pension out of the goodness of their heart, but many more offer the lowest that they can get away with – and if workers aren’t offered a better alternative in the public sector, then that low will be much, much lower.

None of this will stimulate growth. As Angela Eagle MP, Labour’s shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury, said:

“This hotch-potch of small measures and re-announcements shows how out of touch Ministers still have no idea of the scale of the problem families and businesses are facing right now.

“By refusing to even consider a change of course George Osborne has decided to put saving political face and protecting a plan that isn’t working above the needs of the country.”

Osborne seems to think that the UK’s only hope is to become the Lidl of the world, competing on price an nothing else. But there is another way. We can sell ourselves on the quality of our labour force, on the added value we can provide businesses who headquarter here, and we can use the public sector to provide much-needed competition that will raise standards all around.

Osborne should know the appeal of quality, and if not he can ask his old Bullingdon friend James Gissing, the founder of Ocado. What he shouldn’t do is join in a race to the bottom, because we can’t win – and even if we could, the bottom is not a nice place to be.

See also:

FTSE suffers worst quarterly fall since 2002 as fears rise of “Great Stagnation”Shamik Das, September 30th 2011

UNICEF calls for Living Wage to enable better work/life balanceDeborah Segalini, September 14th 2011

Tory MP: Disabled should work for less than minimum wageShamik Das, June 17th 2011

Right’s dodgy youth unemployment attack on minimum wageDominic Browne, April 13th 2011

Osborne, Mitchell and Hammond accused of tax avoidanceShamik Das, October 18th 2010

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

41 Responses to “Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom”

  1. Alex Hern

    I like this one @leftfootfwd: Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom: http://t.co/Qrppni9m writes @AlexHern #ToryCon #CPC11

  2. Joe Gammie

    Good point from @alexhern maybe private sectors pensions are only so high because public ones are too: http://ow.ly/6LGGq

  3. Joe Gammie

    RT @leftfootfwd: Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom: http://t.co/06uZRQVs writes @alexhern #ToryCon #CPC11

  4. Michael

    Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom l Left Foot Forward – http://j.mp/qahrgh

  5. Patrick McGuire

    Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom l Left Foot Forward – http://j.mp/qahrgh

  6. Political Planet

    Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom: Alex Hern argues that much of the chancellor George Osborne’s plans fo… http://t.co/dGIluYSA

  7. E Azicate

    Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom: http://t.co/OyFEiiC8 writes @AlexHern #ToryCon #CPC11

  8. paulstpancras

    Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom – http://t.co/SNmkAcJz

  9. Spir.Sotiropoulou

    RT @leftfootfwd: Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom http://t.co/3a4tY1rs How deep can he go??

  10. TheCreativeCrip

    Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom – http://t.co/SNmkAcJz

  11. Anon E Mouse

    “It is a mentality that will, without hyperbole, lead to deaths”

    hahahaha – please…

  12. No growth? ‘Keep calm and carry on’ says Osborne | Left Foot Forward

    […] Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom – Alex Hern, October 3rd […]

  13. Awake!

    ‘but we should instead sell ourselves to companies on the quality of our workforce; on their education, on their ability and on the welfare state that ensures that the baseline is high. ‘
    mankind is not ready for this higher state of evolutionary awareness. So lovely thoughts, but on planet earth, in which the UK has one of the finest and most advanced and well funded (AND RIGHTLY SO) welfare states, the real problem is a left that has no concept or understanding of what is going on in the rest of the world. ! mine worker in china a week? 20 years ago 40 to 60 thousand miners died there a year, yet you were happily buying their cheap crap. So, perhaps a touch less hyopocrisy and a little more realism into how we step away from the abyss, rather than a knee jerk anti tory rant. No longer interested in the hatred, i want to know about heating, jobs and the future, because i REALLY don’t vare about your high fellutin ideals, i want to know that my ’employers’ aren’t leaving the country. seriously peeved at an article that depicts the country as some sort of third world hell hole, it’s poor and talks the country down- Shame on u!!

  14. Awake!

    Perhaps the developed world might consider that it regularly DEFECATES into a grade of water that would prevent 30,000 (yes thirty thousand mothers) watching their BABIES die EVERY day cos they didn’t get access to that grade of water. So MAYBE the left might get of its high horse and consider how those 30,000 mothers feel watching their child die from cholera/typhoid/malaria, rather than crying about British workers and their soon to be terrible conditions and the shocking pensions boo hoo… And yes I come partly from a much poorer country, a poverty this writer cannot imagine i don’t think, so am affordeda better perspective, buthis emotional appeal is so dismissive of other workers on the planet it becomes offensive- Idiot!!

  15. Awake!

    so then, knowing this, the developed world (that we are supposed to benchmark to according to this writer, and is incidentally collapsing under a debt bubble that financed an unrealistic lifestyle) might want to refocus on what is realy impt, rather than fretting about nonsensical political decoding of osbornes speech in which he basically says that less tax will attract investment… Pathetic

  16. Jonathan

    George Osborne appears to want to make it easier for Employers to treat their Workers as they were treated in this shameful episode http://tiny.cc/k7aep

  17. London IWW

    #Capitalism: Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom http://t.co/AbINJ95y | #Corporatocracy #ClassWar

  18. Alex Hern

    "Some people say we need to be more like India or China". Like Osborne and Mensch? http://t.co/rETOJAjo

  19. Rachel

    Cam says we don't need toB like other countries so why are we competing in a race to the bottom on taxes: http://t.co/wiFUegXq #cpc11 #con11

  20. Robert McRuer

    Cam says we don't need toB like other countries so why are we competing in a race to the bottom on taxes: http://t.co/wiFUegXq #cpc11 #con11

  21. Ashraf Choudhury

    Cam says we don't need toB like other countries so why are we competing in a race to the bottom on taxes: http://t.co/wiFUegXq #cpc11 #con11

  22. Alex Hern

    Again: A race to the bottom hurts everyone.
    http://t.co/rETOJAjo

  23. If Osborne gives up the lead on climate change, he can kiss goodbye to a recovery | Left Foot Forward

    […] Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom – Alex Hern, October 3rd […]

  24. Hutton repeats his big fat lie on public sector pensions | Left Foot Forward

    […] So Hutton’s cry of unsustainability has nothing to do with the public purse, and everything to do with joining in Osborne’s race to the bottom. […]

  25. Cameron and Osborne want the unemployed to work for £1.78 an hour | Left Foot Forward

    […] stated that: “We also respect the right of the unemployed to get a job and not be priced out of the […]

  26. Janet Graham

    If Europe is pricing itself out of the market, the solution isn't a race to the bottom http://t.co/lKYqsTNC #as11

  27. Andrew Johnston

    If Europe is pricing itself out of the market, the solution isn't a race to the bottom http://t.co/lKYqsTNC #as11

  28. Four myths about today's strike: Busted. | Left Foot Forward

    […] as we said in October: The claim that public sector pensions should be low because private sector pensions are […]

  29. Orson Best

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  30. DrKMJ

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  31. Cherry McCormack

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  32. Liza Harding

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  33. Little lurcher

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  34. Mel

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  35. guin

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  36. Michael Smith

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  37. Nicola Thomson

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  38. Daniel Weichman

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

  39. pinners

    Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom | Left Foot Forward http://t.co/pPvlRMBz #N30

  40. Jonathan Sadler

    Osborne dreaming of a race to the bottom | Left Foot Forward http://t.co/pPvlRMBz #N30

  41. Clare Singleton

    One last #n30 #mythbusting: A race to the bottom will not help the public or private sector: http://t.co/DzcSUQAt and http://t.co/OyFEiiC8

Leave a Reply