Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable

Statistics out today show the NHS and public sector pensions are entirely affordable, contrary to what George Osborne and the Conservatives are spinning.

Today there has been a blizzard of reports on the future of public finances, from the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), the Treasury (the Whole of Government Accounts, pdf), and the Institute of Economic Affairs (Sharper Axes, Lower Taxes, pdf). In the firing line are public pensions and the NHS.

The OBR’s July 2011 Fiscal Sustainability report (pdf) looks long into the future (2060) and guesses at the likely proportions of GDP that might arise as the population becomes more elderly. The assumptions are based on current policies, not government proposals. Confirming earlier findings in the Hutton Report (pdf), they clearly predict the cost of public pensions will fall from 2% of GDP to 1.8% in 2030 and 1.4% in 2060 – without any of the current Hutton proposals.

In contrast the state pension paid to public and private sector employees is set to rise from 5.7% to 6.1% in 2030 and 7.9% in 2060. Public pensions really are sustainable.


The other major factors increasing are health and long-term care, which taken together increase from about 9.5% to 10% in 2030 and 11.8% in 2060. The British Medical Journal puts this into context today in an article from John Appleby, chief economist of the King’s Fund.

Perhaps unwisely given the far more modest predictions from the OBR shown above, Appleby accepts at face value the verdict of health secretary Andrew Lansley that:

“If things carry on unchanged, this would mean real terms health spending more than doubling to £230 billion… This is something we simply cannot afford.”

And yet even in this worst case scenario this would bring us to only just exceed the OECD average and fall far shy of health and long term care spending in the US.

Health-spending-as-a-percentage-of-GDP
Or rather it would if the OECD and US didn’t have an aging population that is likely to push up their health costs too. So apparently we simply can afford to carry on with the current NHS arrangements… if we choose to.

Elsewhere, the BBC headlines the OBR report with ‘Public sector pension liabilities top £1 trillion’, noting this is £332 billion higher than the year before.  A bit further down they notice that the OBR states  this “has nothing to do with changes in the size of prospective pension payments” – remember they will fall from 2% to 1.8% in 2030 – but is because the government has just changed the assumptions.

And in perfectly circular reasoning the right is now trumpeting the OBR report as supporting their changes.

Hopefully Evan Davis or some other even moderately numerate journalists will notice this perfidy and hold the government to account.

45 Responses to “Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable”

  1. Christine Pampling

    RT @leftfootfwd: Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  2. Ahmad Noor

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  3. Michael

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable l Left Foot Forward – http://j.mp/ohc5fi

  4. Caer

    RT @TheRightArticle
    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable l Left Foot Forward – http://t.co/nRquTDV

  5. David Heathcote

    RT @leftfootfwd: Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable http://t.co/20sgy9Q

  6. Wendy Russell

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  7. Jim Henderson

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  8. StephenH

    RT @leftfootfwd: Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable http://t.co/CBA6KML

  9. Alan W

    These kind of statistics are so speculative as to be almost worthless.

    As Stephanie Flanders points out on the BBC website, even minor changes to key assumptions could produce radically different results, either plunging the country further into the red, or showing it to be in perfect inter-generational fiscal health.

    Frankly when it comes to any economic projections for the year 2060, I’ll take them with an entire dumper truck’s worth of salt.

  10. StephenHenderson

    Alan W: I pretty much agree with you…Incidentally I teach a statistical modelling course in which I tediously drum into my students the dangers of over- extrapolation

    Yet the present government, right-wing think tanks and their pet-media are doing their best to present such projections in a light that will scare the public into supporting precipitous and ideological cuts. ‘There Is No Alternative” writ large.

    Under such circumstances it is worthwhile to engage with such models if only to keep them honest.

  11. Pamela Heywood

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable http://dlvr.it/b3jnX

  12. Mr. Sensible

    The right never let the truth get in the way of their ideology…

    And nice to see that the IEA support getting rid of the NHS and overseas aid.

  13. InternationalUNCUT

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/xBRenC7l

  14. Paul McGlynn

    RT @leftfootfwd: Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable http://t.co/sbuRg6g

  15. False Economy

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  16. Staffordshire UNISON

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  17. James Haslam

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  18. simon trott

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  19. Clive Burgess

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  20. blazerunner

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – UK can afford pension liabilities and the NHS without savage Tory cuts http://bit.ly/pvG3E1

  21. karl thompson

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  22. Right To Work

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  23. Dave Plummer

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  24. pcs_euston

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  25. Camden United

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  26. Martin Stride

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  27. Simon Worthington

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  28. farfar

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  29. B.T

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  30. Cllr Darren Cooper

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  31. Paul Trembath

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  32. Bob Lloyd

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  33. Bruno Bear

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  34. Watching You

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  35. Jon Purdom/Paco Saez

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  36. Staffordshire UNISON

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  37. Simon Blanchard

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  38. Spir.Sotiropoulou

    RT @leftfootfwd Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable: http://bit.ly/pvG3E1 writes Stephen Henderson

  39. Shez

    Ignore the Tory spin – pension liabilities and the NHS are affordable | Left Foot Forward http://fb.me/12YHodubs

  40. Alex

    The reason it is unaffordabvle is that government tax receipts are currently less than 40% of GDP so that 12-14% out of the future 41% or today’s 41% is not being “afforded”, but simply passed on as a bill for future generations to pay. That doesn’t work indefinitely.

  41. How the UK could pay for its demographic “time-bomb” | Liberal Conspiracy

    […] the difference between the 2015 and 2060 OBR projections is less than the gap between UK and US spending on health care in […]

  42. Don't buy the right-wing spin: Public sector pension costs set to fall | Left Foot Forward

    […] and again and again that it is not true. As reported by Stephen Henderson on Left Foot Forward in July: “The Office of Budget Responsibility’s July 2011 Fiscal Sustainability report (pdf) looks […]

  43. Hutton repeats his big fat lie on public sector pensions | Left Foot Forward

    […] already sustainable. We know this, because it is in Hutton’s own report, as Stephen Henderson wrote for this site in July: The Office of Budget Responsibility’s July 2011 Fiscal Sustainability […]

  44. Four myths about today's strike: Busted. | Left Foot Forward

    […] Stephen Henderson wrote in July: The Office of Budget Responsibility’s July 2011 Fiscal Sustainability report (pdf) looks long […]

Leave a Reply