Clegg’s plan for cleaning up the press: “Freedom, accountability, plurality”

Nick Clegg stepped up to the plate on the phone hacking scandal today with a call for widespread reform of the media, outlining the his three principles of reform.

Nick Clegg stepped up to the plate on the phone hacking scandal today with a call for widespread reform of the media, outlining the his three principles of reform: press freedom; accountability; and plurality.

Attacking the toothlessness of the Press Complaints Commission, he said the press can no longer “act as judge, jury and executioner” over themsleves, and said that “as expenses was for MPs, and the financial crisis for the banking system, so the phone hacking scandal must be for the press” in acting as a catalyst for reform.


The deputy prime minister called press freedom “the lifeblood of liberal democracy”, hailing the last week a “triumph for investigative journalism”, highlighting the very best of British journalism as well as the worst; on accountability, he said the PCC had “failed”, and was only a “limited complaints body”, later saying “it’s not that difficult to have independent scrutiny of the press”; and on plurality, he said a corporate monopoly “threatens democracy” as much as a state monopoly.

In the press conference after the speech, on the public reaction to the scandal, he said:

“In the public, there are millions of people out there who thought the press were on their side… They don’t work out how the information is arrived at in their newspapers… The lid has now been lifted on that process.”

On the Coulson scandal, he said:

“It’s qute clear given what I said and the party said, we had serious misgivings about it [the decision to bring Coulson into Downing Street]… For a long time we were the only party to express concerns about phone hacking…

“But at the end of the day, the prime minister does not seek to veto my appointments, so I cannot veto his – it was his decision and his alone.”

Later saying:

“Yes, it’s about vetting and scrutiny, but it’s also an issue of judgement; the prime minister has explained on many occasions the reasoning for his judgement.”

Asked whether Rupert Murdoch, if not deemed “fit and proper” to own the whole of Sky, could be deemed “fit and proper” to own its current 39 per cent stake, he said:

“It would be the worst thing to allow politicians to decide on who’s fit and proper, it should be up to Ofcom to decide, as [culture secretary] Jeremy Hunt has said… I’m no lawyer… it’s not particularly clearly understood in law, whether it’s applied to corporate bodies or individuals.”

On his claim that he alone among the party leaders was not “in the pocket” of media moguls, he said:

“This is really not the kind of time to be terribly holier than thou and pious and engage in one-upmanship… This is on the record, and goes back years, the fantastic work done by my predecessors, by Lib Dem peers; Evan Harris has been very vocal… [Yet] every time we were blocked [by the main parties]…

“It’s one of the roles of liberals and Liberal Democrats… I think this is now an opportunity… There’s been so much tragedy, anguish, heartache and distress; it’s time to act.”

Asked whether Parliament should have new powers to compel witnesses to appear before select committes, he answered:

“Let’s see what happens – it hasn’t yet crystallised, we don’t know whether they’ll refuse. Power has to come with responsibility and accountability. If people think they can get away with it, it will invariably go wrong… It is immensely important as a matter of principle.”

Later adding:

“My message [to Rebekkah Brooks, James Murdoch and Rupert Murdoch] it to do the decent thing. You can’t hide away from this level of anger and interest…. When you’re that powerful you’re also accountable; you have to make yourself available.

“If you feel the facts are wrong, you’ve been unfairly maligned, set the record straight and turn up.”

On the treatment of Gordon Brown by News International, and his claims in Parliament yesterday, he said:

“My heart goes out to them for the treatment of their son… [However] I sense a whiff of rewriting of history… He was prime minister, and a very powerful chancellor, at the apex of poilitics for 13 years…

“Are we really to believe he was hampered? There were other areas in which he bulldozed his way through.”

And when asked if Vince Cable was owed an apology, for having been right all along about Murdoch, he replied:

“Vince was never on the naughty step. Do I think that Vince’s misgivings about some of the implications of the proposed deal have been vindicated? Vince was acting, as Jeremy Hunt has beem, in a ‘quasi judicial’ role…

“Was it a deal that was signinficant enough to elicit very serious scrutiny? Yes, of course.

18 Responses to “Clegg’s plan for cleaning up the press: “Freedom, accountability, plurality””

  1. Liz K

    Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plural: //bit.ly/qXoJPw – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate

  2. Jill Rutter

    Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plural: //bit.ly/qXoJPw – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate

  3. Prateek Buch

    RT @leftfootfwd: Clegg's plan for cleaning up press: "Freedom, accountability, plural: //bit.ly/qXoJPw – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate

  4. Liz K

    Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plurality": //t.co/FzN6agp – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate #NewsCorpse

  5. Tom Rouse

    Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plurality": //t.co/FzN6agp – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate #NewsCorpse

  6. Martyn Griffin

    Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plurality": //t.co/FzN6agp – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate #NewsCorpse

  7. A C McGregor

    RT @leftfootfwd: Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plurality" //t.co/7syxJq0

  8. Joe Jordan

    Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plurality": //t.co/FzN6agp – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate #NewsCorpse

  9. Robert

    Also note Brown was telling porkies yesterday again, the bole cannot help it.

    I was told not to have a review, but it now clearly states it’s up to the Prime Minister, it was up to you Gordon not your advisors mate and you decided it was to close to an election, blame who you like you were prime Minister and it was clearly left in your hands. Blame lies with you not your advisors mate

  10. Ash

    “This is really not the kind of time to be terribly holier than thou and pious…”

    Says the most unwaveringly, obnoxiously sanctiomonious man in politics, immediately before going on to note:

    “the fantastic work done by my predecessors, by Lib Dem peers; Evan Harris has been very vocal… [Yet] every time we were blocked”

    You just can’t help yourself, can you Nick?

    Hands up anyone who is remotely interested in a lecture on ‘decency’ from a man who signed a contract with students up and down the country to vote against any increase in tuition fees, and then – in his capacity as an elected representative of those very students – voted for the tripling of those fees?

    Anyone?

  11. Ed's Talking Balls

    ‘This is really not the kind of time to be terribly holier than thou and pious and engage in one-upmanship’

    Quite right. The only problem is that he goes on to do just that in his next sentence. He needs to put party politics to one side and stop with the petty point scoring. Ditto Ed Miliband.

    Politicians across the spectrum need to show more guts than the hypocrite Gordon Brown and actually do something rather than talk about it. Thank goodness that man is no longer in a position of power, although it would be nice if he turned up to Westminster, represented his constituents and earned his salary.

  12. FBI called in to investigate News Corp as Murdoch succumbs to Parliament | Left Foot Forward

    […] Nick Clegg laid out his plan for reforming the media, the three pillars being press freedom, accountability and […]

  13. jaqi

    Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plurality": //t.co/FzN6agp – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate #NewsCorpse

  14. jaqi

    Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plurality": //t.co/QLfJIoD – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate

  15. David Bingham

    RT @Jaqi: Clegg's plan for cleaning up the press: "Freedom, accountability, plurality": //t.co/QLfJIoD – @ShamikDas reports #hackgate

  16. Clive

    So Clegg being the man of principle he is did not threaten to pull out of the coalition to stop (for example) the employing of Coulson? Nah, Clegg just went along with things so he could keep his position and little bit of power. He is now trying to get brownie points after screwing the country over

  17. ST editor: Papers take PCC “very seriously... it’s treated by the press seriously” – Really??? | Left Foot Forward

    […] many other instances of the PCC failing to deliver and it’s clear for all to see – even Nick Clegg – that the PCC needs backbone, bite and the will to wield […]

  18. “Nothing wrong” with the PCC code, thinks the head of the PCC | Left Foot Forward

    […] Clegg’s plan for cleaning up the press: “Freedom, accountability, plurality” – Shamik Das, July 14th […]

Leave a Reply