Will Tory MEPs make a mockery of the coalition agreement?

Tory MEPs look set to vote against the 30 per cent emissions reduction target in the European Parliament today - breaking a pledge in the coalition agreement.

At Prime Minister’s Questions today, shadow climate change minister Luciana Berger asked David Cameron if he would “guarantee that all of his MEPs will honour the coalition agreement and vote for the 30 per cent” emissions reduction target – his response was far from convincing; Martyn Williams, Senior Parliamentary Campaigner at Friends of the Earth, looks at whether those Tory MEPs will deliver

It’s just over a year since the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats announced their Programme for the Coalition Government (pdf). Right at the top of the section on energy and climate change was a promise to:

“…push for the EU to demonstrate leadership in tackling international climate change, including by supporting an increase in the EU emission reduction target to 30% by 2020.”

Furthermore, the Conservative Party European Election manifesto 2009 (pdf) states:

“Conservatives have consistently supported and strengthened the EU climate change package and resisted the argument that efforts to tackle climate change should be watered down in the light of the global economic downturn.

“Conservative MEPs played a central role in securing agreement on the climate and energy programme in the European Parliament. We are determined to see it implemented without delay so that the EU can meet its targets on emissions and energy generation.”

You have to wonder how Liberal Democrats are feeling today when they read in today’s Guardian that while Chris Huhne pushes the 30% target for all he’s worth, David Cameron is letting his Conservative MEPs vote against the target. It is quite possible, given the arithmetic of the European Parliament, that the target will be defeated as a direct result.

Martin Callanan, leader of the Conservative MEPs, claims this is to support business; “European companies will be unable to compete,” he tells the Guardian – but this conveniently ignores the views of 72 major companies who have come together to call for a 30% target.

So what is going on? Was this always a clever ploy to be seen to be on the right side of the argument in Westminster while scuppering it in Europe? Or are the MEPs just a remnant of the unreconstructed Conservative Party that doesn’t get climate change?

Whichever it is, Cameron needs to act. He spent a lot of yesterday arguing that his decision to make Ken Clarke do a U-turn on prison terms was a show of strength. He has until midday tomorrow to show that strength again – and persuade his own party members to support the programme he signed up to a year ago.

However, there is at least one honourable exception to this MEP bashing – one of the Conservative MEPs for London, Marina Yannakoudakis, will be supporting the 30% target as she has before. Good for her.

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

7 Responses to “Will Tory MEPs make a mockery of the coalition agreement?”

  1. Friends of the Earth

    RT @leftfootfwd – will Tory MEPs make a mockery of the coalition agreement asks our campaigner Martyn Williams http://tiny.cc/p2io7 #PMQs

  2. Tory MEPs run riot in Brussels and put us all at risk « Hynd's Blog

    […] is facing embarrassment tonight then when a number of his MEPs are vowing to vote against any move to increase the EU emissions reduction […]

  3. David Cameron poised to step into MEP climate target row – The Guardian | Manchester News and Weather

    […] threaten progress of climate change', say MEPsBucks Free PressEkklesia -Left Foot Forward -Full Factall 15 news […]

  4. Northern Worker

    I hope they do vote against it and the measure is defeated. All this climate change stuff is putting people out of work in Europe – especially the UK. And even if there is a slim element of truth in it, which I doubt, nothing we do will make any difference with China and India ploughing on regardless. I’d rather have a job any day.

  5. Alex Macfie

    To be clear, our MEPs are NOT bound by the Coalition Agreement: this agreement applies ONLY to the UK government at Westminster. The Conservative and Lib Dem MEPs belong to different transnational blocs (ECR and ALDE, respectively) between which there is no special relationship.
    By voting against a Coalition policy, Tory MEPs are simply voting with their party’s principles (i.e. thare are indeed “a remnant of the unreconstructed Conservative Party that doesn’t get climate change”). It doesn’t surprise me that Tory MEPs don’t feel bound by the Coalition agreement, as Lib Dem MEPs certainly don’t (Chris Davies has stated that the European Parliament is a “Coalition-free zone”: http://chrisdaviesmep.blogspot.com/2010/05/coalition-free-zone.html). And this is a good thing, as it underlines that whatever the two parties are doing together at Wesminster, they remain independent parties; also it underlines the independence of the European Parliament from national governments. Whatever you may think of Tory MEPs’ stance on climate change, they have every right to assert their independence from the Coalition.

  6. Martyn Williams


    You are right about the extent of the coalition agreement – but the fact remains that we are seeing Conservatives saying one thing in their manifesto and at Westminster, and voting for the opposite in Europe.

  7. Climate sceptic Tory MEPs will send us sleepwalking towards disaster | Left Foot Forward

    […] were asked to vote on a proposal to strengthen EU climate action by agreeing to unilaterally cut the bloc’s […]

Leave a Reply