The idea £9k fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream

As Exeter University, the first outside the Russell Group, declares its intention to charge the £9,000 top fee for its degree courses the government’s plans to change the higher education funding landscape continue to unravel at an amazing pace.

Aaron Porter is the president of the National Union of Students (NUS)

As Exeter University, the first outside the Russell Group, declares its intention to charge the £9,000 top fee for its degree courses the government’s plans to change the higher education funding landscape continue to unravel at an amazing pace.

When the plans were announced they were widely and popularly dismissed as ill-thought through and unfair. The Government tried to appease doubters with an insistence that fees above £6,000 (still almost a doubling of the previous cap) would be the exception.

This was always a pipe-dream – when top up fees were introduced universities quickly raised fees up to the cap and this year every single one charged the full amount; so with no disincentives and plenty of incentives they were of course going to once again race to the cap.

Quickly it became obvious that the government expected £7,500 to be the norm rather than £6,000 and were told that the maximum fee would be the exception. If any university charges the minimum £6,000 for any course it will be the exception.

The Office for Fair Access has been given responsibility for negotiating the Access Agreements that will determine whether universities are able to charge more than £6,000. This body has made it clear that it has no way of enforcing the conditions it suggests when allowing higher fees. OFFA is also not a market regulator, it has no way to stop bunching of fees charges at the top level as it was asked to do by the Department of Business, Innovation and Skills.

So with 80 per cent of the teaching grant taken away and with no enforceable restrictions, most universities will of course charge the full amount.

The whole policy was rushed, trying to take advantage of good will both between the parties and from the public soon after the election. That, of course, backfired, sparking a resistance to the austerity ideology that continues to build and spread into other areas.

There is simply no excuse not to take a step back and reassess the entire scheme and find something that ensures a fair balance of funding between government, graduates and business and that no prospective student is discouraged by the threat of huge debt.

27 Responses to “The idea £9k fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream”

  1. Broken OfBritain

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  2. jbw

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  3. Mr. Mxyzptlk

    Well I’m jiggered never ever thought they would do an underhand thing like that

  4. Lawrence Rayner

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  5. Richard McKenzie

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  6. politicsinbrum

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  7. Aaron Porter

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  8. Elisabeth Gehrke

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  9. Samuel Rowlands

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  10. RCT UNISON

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  11. Lady STum

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  12. Jonny Brogdale

    Well quite. Tell them they can charge that, take away their funding, and then express surprise at the outcome. Speaking recently with an admissions tutor from LSE there seemed to be an assumption that their students would commonly graduate with £54k debt (£9k fees already factored plus £1k/month living costs etc.).I detected real concern about the viability of taught post-grad as an option for such heavily indebted grads.

  13. Jamie Ellison

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  14. Frances Grahl

    @WelshCommunist http://bit.ly/h0CacV How low will he go? And HOW soon will he be an MP?

  15. Grace Benton

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  16. Gemma Bennett

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  17. Stephen Budden

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  18. Mr. Sensible

    Couldn’t agree more Aaron.

    Given that as you say the Office for Fair Access will have no real teeth, why should we believe a single word this government says on this subject?

  19. chris star

    The idea £9k fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream…

    http://bit.ly/fL05zE
    #demo2011 #ukuncut

  20. Daniel Pitt

    £9k tuition fees 'exception' idea was always a pipe dream http://bit.ly/h0CacV #ConDemNation

  21. Tacitus

    The fact that Clegg and Cable actually believed only a couple of universities would adopt the higher fee demonstrates a frightening level of naivete. Perhaps Nick would have been better staying on the ski slopes and giving his job over to someone with a better analytic mind.

  22. Hugh Potter

    RT @leftfootfwd: The idea £9k tuition fees would be the exception was always a pipe-dream: http://bit.ly/h0CacV writes @AaronPorter

  23. John Ruddy

    Its a pity that Exeter University has done this, but then what is to be expected from a University which closed its Chemistry department 8 weeks into term? Simply because it only got 4 out of 5 stars?

  24. Non-shock poll reveals teenagers put off by £9,000-a-year tuition fees | Left Foot Forward

    […] Left Foot Forward have previously reported the idea that £9k fees would be the exception was a pipe-dream, not just because of the incompetency of the government’s approach to the reforms, but also […]

  25. Rich kids will pay less student debt than middle classes | Left Foot Forward

    […] on raising tuition fees, ministers were telling the nation fees above £6,000 a year would be the exception rather than the rule and insisting high earners would be hit hardest with the new fee repayment […]

Leave a Reply