Look Left – Mubarak finally resigns; next stop: democracy

After 18 days of demonstrations and three decades of dictatorship, Egypt finally rid itself of Hosni Mubarak tonight, sparking wild celebrations as Tahrir Square erupted with delight.

To receive Look Left in your inbox before it appears on the website, sign up to the Left Foot Forward email service

• After 18 days of demonstrations and three decades of dictatorship, Egypt finally rid itself of Hosni Mubarak tonight, sparking wild celebrations as Tahrir Square erupted with delight.

History made before our eyes, a nation reborn, a region shaken to its core; fireworks skimming the night sky, joy unconfined… but once the sand settles, and the future closes in, where does Egypt go from here, as it embarks upon the long and winding road to democracy? Writing on Left Foot Forward this evening, Omar Salem, a very proud Egyptian, outlined the steps that need to be taken:

  1. The emergency laws that limit freedom of association and speech must be lifted;
  2. The constitution should be changed to make it easier for political parties to organise and for individuals to run for President;
  3. Time needs to be given before elections for the relatively weak and disorganised opposition political parties to organise properly for elections;
  4. Political prisoners need to be released and allowed to participate in political activity unhindered;
  5. Finally, the organisational infrastructure needs to be put in place for the holding of free and fair elections.

For now, though, Egyptians will enjoy the moment, pinch themselves, remember the fallen, dream of the future and sing themselves to sleep… 30 years of hurt, never stopped them dreaming.

• Domestically, banks, bankers and the economy dominted the headlines, with the chancellor unveiling his banking levy plans and the Project Merlin lending and bonuses deal.

On Project Merlin, Duncan Weldon wrote on Left Foot Forward that the banks had been “let off the hook” on lending:

“Questions are already being asked about the failure of government to get tough on bonuses and the low level of transparency on pay, but perhaps most worrying is the failure to deal with the central question of bank lending to support the recovery…

“The agreement is for gross lending rather than net lending – i.e. it only refers, it takes no account of repayments on existing loans. It would be perfectly possible for banks to issue gross loans of £190 billion but fund this by calling in old loans. What matters for the UK is not gross lending but net lending..

“Furthermore, the agreement includes a let out clause for the banks:

‘Each bank’s lending expectations, capacity and willingness, as set out above, will be subject to its normal commercial objectives, credit standards and processes and regulatory obligations, as well as the availability of the required funding.’

“This potentially provides the banks with a ready made excuse when they fail to meet the targets.”

On the banking levy, Ben Fox described it on Left Foot Forward as “the desperate action of a desperate chancellor”, while this week also saw the first Commons duel between Mr Osborne and his new shadow Ed Balls – watch the video on Left Foot Forward here.

• Higher education remained at the forefront of the political agenda, with Cambridge University announcing it would charge the maximum £9,000 tuition fees and Nick Clegg embroiled in an access row.

Writing on Left Foot Forward today, Sally Hunt, general secretary of the University and College Union (UCU), said:

“Looking first at the scholarships, and leaving to one side the fact they are a tacit admission higher fees will put poorer students off, students from the poorest backgrounds will actually be considerably worse off under the new system…

“Moving on to the access agreements… The government’s claim that institutions would only charge fees higher than £6,000 a year in exceptional circumstances is entirely bogus. Every single English institution with undergraduates will have to charge more than £6,000 just to plug the funding gap the government has created by slashing the teaching budget. The average fee will need to be £6,863.”

Meanwhile Aaron Porter, president of the National Union of Students (NUS), wrote on Left Foot Forward on Tuesday:

“Companies in a market like the one the government have tried to introduce into higher education work on the principle that a higher price equates to better quality; if you are Cambridge, or Oxford, or any of the other UK universities hoping for a place in the exclusive pantheon of the best universities in the world, your reputation is built on exclusivity, an exclusivity that disappears if you could charge more than you do…

“Without proper oversight and careful implementation, however, the most exclusive universities will become even more exclusive and the lecture halls of Cambridge will even more closely resemble classrooms at Eton.

“Higher education should be about talented and ambitious young people studying the course that matches their potential at the institution that suits their ambitions. Instead we will see the emergence of a two-tier system where students are studying at the institution that matches their wallets.”

In other education news today, Michael Gove was given a slap on the wrist for his brutal axing of the Building Schools for the Future programme – described by a High Court judge as “so unfair as to amount to an abuse of power” – while a new poll, reported by Left Foot Forward, revealed nearly half the public oppose the abolition of EMA.

Progressive of the week:

Lord Oakeshott, who stood up to the coalition for their pitiful failure to take action on bankers’ bonuses – and was forced out for his troubles. As shadow chancellor Ed Balls said:

“It is symbolic of the shambolic and panicked way that the chancellor has gone about agreeing this weak and toothless deal with the banks that the Liberal Democrat Treasury spokesman in the House of Lords has been sacked… It is a sad commentary on this Tory-led government that Lord Oakeshott has been forced to pay the price for daring to tell the truth.”

Regressives of the week:

The Top Gear triumvirate, rightly savaged by Steve Coogan this week for their unfunny, borderline-xenophibic remarks about Mexicans. Coogan branded Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond and James May “uber-conservatives” whose attempts at humour are more tragic than comic. He wrote:

“The BBC’s initial mealy-mouthed apology was pitiful. It cited the more benign rivalry that exists between European nations (ah, those arrogant French, over-organised Germans), and in doing so neatly sidestepped one hugely important fact – ethnicity. All the examples it uses to legitimise this hateful rubbish are relatively prosperous countries full of white people. How about if the Lads had described Africans as lazy, feckless etc? Or Pakistanis?

“What’s more, this was all spouted by the presenters on one of the BBC’s most successful programmes, with ratings that could only fail to impress Simon Cowell (very fast lap time). Forget the World Service; overseas, Top Gear is more frequently the public face of the BBC.

“The Beeb’s hand-wringing suggested tolerance of casual racism, arguably the most sinister kind. It’s easy to spot the ones with the burning crosses. Besides, there is not a shred of truth in Top Gear’s ‘comic’ stereotype. I can tell you from my own experience, living in the US, Mexicans work themselves to the bone doing all the dirty thankless jobs that the white middle-class natives won’t do.”

Evidence of the week:

Declan Gaffney’s article on Incapacity Benefit today, which set straight the misleading figures seemingly briefed by the DWP and swallowed hook, line and sinker by the right-wing press.

Express, Mail, Sun and Telegraph headlines this morning screamed: “70% of Britons on ‘incapacity benefits’ found to be fit to work”; “Nearly 2 million on sickness benefits for years are fit to work”; “Fit as a fiddler; and “Two in three benefit claimants are fit to work”. In reality, however, official figures show that 71 per cent of claimants are not fit for work; as Declan wrote:

“How did the Telegraph, Mail, Sun and Express get it so wrong – and get it wrong in exactly the same way?”

Ed Jacobs’s Week outside Westminster:

Scotland: The Daily Record opened their report on the budget with the headline: ‘Desperate Nats forced into Con-Dem deals to save budget blushes’, following the news that MSPs voted to approve the SNP’s final budget before May’s elections – only after John Swinney was forced to make concessions to the Lib Dems and Conservatives to gain their support. Shadow finance secretary Andy Kerr said:

“The Cabinet Secretary has chosen his priorities. The country will soon have the chance to choose their priorities. A budget is a test of your values, a test of who you are and what you stand for. The SNP has shown us it stands with the Tories and the Lib Dems. They have no credible plan for growth or jobs and we cannot support them.”

The UK’s most senior civil servant Sir Gus O’Donnell, meanwhile, published papers concerning the release of the Lockerbie Bomber Abdelbaset Mohmed Ali al-Megrahi, with suggestions the SNP were looking to do a deal with the UK government in return for his release. Labour’s justice spokesman in Holyrood, Richard Baker, said:

“Kenny MacAskill and Alex Salmond now have very serious questions to answer about Megrahi’s release.”

Wales: Left Foot Forward reported the Institute for Fiscal Studies report which showed Wales was losing out under the Barnett Formula. Responding to the report’s conclusions, Plaid Cymru’s treasury spokesman Jonathan Edwards said:

“To my knowledge, this is the first time the IFS Green Budget has made any reference to the funding formula. In the so-called age of austerity, it is a clear indication how the inequity of the Barnett Formula is becoming a significant issue across the British state.”

Meanwhile, with just four months until elections to the Assembly, the governing coalition entered election mode, with Labour sources attacking Plaid’s leader. The Western Mail quoted one ‘senior’ Labour figure as saying:

“Ieuan Wyn Jones is the One Wales weak link. This is not a party political attack – his handling of the economic brief during tough times has been absolutely shambolic. He has lost the confidence and respect of Wales’ business community. Every businessperson I meet wants [former Labour economy minister] Andrew Davies brought back. Andrew understood the business community. Ieuan is out of his depth.

“We hope his incompetence doesn’t reflect badly on Labour in May. There’s no reason why it should but we are very aware of the problem. Labour will have a strong offer for Welsh businesses at the time of the election.”

Northern Ireland: It was a grim week in Northern Ireland as police arrested three men thought to have been attempting to lure police to their deaths in a bomb attack last month. It followed bomb alerts on the Antrim Road. Reports also suggested this week that one bomb was attached to a child’s bicycle.

Meanwhile, debate continued over a visit by the Queen to Ireland, with Gerry Adams explaining that he felt such a visit would be “premature and too soon”. Fine Gael Leader, and Ireland’s probable next Taoiseach, Enda Kenny, concluded that such a visit was “long overdue”, adding she would be “very warmly received”.


Come along to the Fabian Society Europe conference on Saturday, February 19th and debate Britain’s role in Europe. Speakers include Douglas Alexander MP, Nigel Farage MEP, Ute Michel (Green Party), Mark Reckless MP, and Baroness Shirley Williams. Tickets are available at www.fabians.org.uk; alternatively, call Phil Mutero on 020 7227 4903.

5 Responses to “Look Left – Mubarak finally resigns; next stop: democracy”

  1. jaqi

    RT @leftfootfwd: Look Left – Mubarak finally resigns; next stop: democracy: http://bit.ly/h0sVQB reports @ShamikDas #Egypt #Jan25

  2. Mr. Sensible

    Not exactly been a great week for Nick Clegg, has it.

    First Lord Oakeshott is quite clear what he thinks about the deal with the banks, and then Lib Dem councils reveal their displeasure at local government cuts.

    And now the SNP is being propped up by Tories and Lib Dems to get its budget passed.

  3. Boffy

    It seems to me the most important next step for Egypt is to call for the Military Junta to be removed. All that appears to have happened is that the Military-Bureaucratic elite that supported Mubarak have now stepped out into the daylight themselves! They clearly hope to demobilise the mass protests as they have been trying to do for the last two weeks. The protests should be stepped up, the strikes and occupations should be intensified until the Military Junta step aside in favour of a Civilian Provisional Government.

    In the meantime the workers need to organise and regularise the Militias they have developed in their neighbourhoods and factories in order to defend themselves against any attacks that come from the State once the mass protests are demobilised.

    The generals are not the saviours of the revolution. They are its hangmen.

  4. Egypt at the crossroads as Presidential candidate warns of “anarchy” | Left Foot Forward

    […] the message that Egypt must make more progress toward democracy – eight months on from the toppling of Hosni […]

  5. Watch Cameron’s pathetic ‘condemnation’ of Clarkson’s sick comments | Left Foot Forward

    […] Scumbag Clarkson’s racist attack on Mexicans – Shamik Das, February 11th […]

Comments are closed.