Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable

Better regulation of the media - holding them to account like public servants are - was one of the ideas discussed at the Dragons Den session at the Fabian conference.

A £7 billion windfall tax on banks to fund social housing was voted the most radical idea for the future by delegates at yesterday’s Fabian Society Next Left conference. Emma Burnell’s idea beat proposals for greater accountability for the media – submitted by Left Foot Forward contributor Claire French; a plan to “stop all the cuts now” by offering the Lib Dems “whatever they wanted”; Maurice Glasman’s baffling plans for reforming the City of London; and Sunder Katwala’s proposal of levying a 20 per cent tax on private school fees to fund a new, genuinely aspirational pupil premium.

The judges on the ‘Dragons Den’ style panel were Mehdi Hasan, Senior Editor (Politics) at the New Statesman; Sadiq Khan MP, Chair of the Fabian Society; pollster Deborah Mattinson; and Telegraph columnist Mary Riddell. Though it failed to win, French’s proposal, centring on better regulation of the media, holding them to account the same way public servants are – for example by publishing journalists’ expenses – was widely thought of as the best presented and easiest to understand.


At present, the Register of Lobby Journalists’ Interests, for example, only publishes journalists’ “other relevant gainful occupation” (with no figures) – falling well short of the extensive Register of Members’ Financial Interests or the Ministerial and SPAD travel, gifts and hospitality lists. Though inextensive, the lobby register does reveal just how many pies the BBC’s Daily Politics and This Week anchor Andrew Neil has his finger in:

Chairman, Press Holdings Media Group, publisher of The Spectator, Spectator Business, Apollo. In 2009 I received payment for speeches to the Steel Institute, Institute of Electrical Engineers, Federation of Small Business, Kent Business Link, SAB Miller (brewers), Vodafone, Astra (satellite company), Local Government Association Conference, Association of Property Executives, Advantage Travel, a group of local investors in Yorkshire, Barclays Wealth (three speeches), the Oil Industries Club and the Healthcare Financial Management Association.

(Entry added on 13 January 2010 under the procedure set out on page 2 of the Register).

The media would be made more accountable, the conference was told, were journalists and executives of a certain rank made to register all gifts received from and meetings held with the likes of David Cameron’s communications chief Andy Coulson, pictured above having lunch with the BBC’s Political Editor Nick Robinson.

Journalists couldn’t have it both ways, said Riddell:

“It can’t be one of convenience. They can’t claim both that they are acting in the public interest, that they are serving the public but are not public servants.”

There was broad consensus amongst the judges and delegates that there needed to be much more effective regulation of the media, putting them in line with doctors, lawyers and accountants. Although “Robinson and Coulson deserve each other”, Mehdi argued that:

“We need an OFCOM system for newspapers so we don’t have the Daily Express publishing horrible racist Islamophobic lies on their front page almost every day.”

Riddell, however, said:

“I’m not in favour of it but I do have sympathy for the idea; as scummy and terrible as they are, there is huge argument for a free and fair press. We already have very strong libel laws – we tamper with our free press at our peril.”

While Mattinson said:

“It’s difficult – no one would talk to journos if you bind a journalist’s hands. The Lib Dems are right to complain to the PCC about the Daily Telegraph sting – it was a complete fishing expedition.

“At the moment journalists are more unpopular than politicians and they’re both less popular than estate agents. And should bloggers be regulated? That said, I don’t believe this proposal is in conflict with a free press so I back it.”

With Mehdi Hasan concluding:

“We don’t have a free press at the moment, look at Richard Desmond, and look at Rupert Murdoch – too much of the media in the hands of a small self-serving elite so I back better regulation and I back the proposal.”

23 Responses to “Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable”

  1. Broken OfBritain

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11

  2. Martin Johnston

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11

  3. DemocracyFail

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11

  4. William J. C. Brown

    Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/e6Thdf

  5. Sarah Mingay

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11

  6. Shamik Das

    #Fab11 Dragons Den: RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH

  7. Claire French

    Left Foot Forward explores the idea of greater regulation of journalists, as I pitched yesterday at #fab11 dragons den http://bit.ly/dSrMtc

  8. Claire French

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/e6Thdf

  9. Νέα Νέμεσις Εργασίας

    Sunder @leftfootfwd finally comes up with the idea of taxing aspiration itself http://bit.ly/gGW3lH #Labour #Fabians #Fab11

  10. Shelly Asquith

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11

  11. Helen Godwin Teige

    RT @leftfootfwd: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11” #pressreform

  12. Mr. Sensible

    Shamik, with press freedom must come press responsibility. Accordingly, I think there’s something to be said for this idea.

    What we need is to replace the current system of self-regulation with an independent regulator.

    On Cablegate, as questionable as I think the Telegraph’s actions may have been, even if those 2 women had been Mr Cable’s constituants, the principle of collective ministerial responsibility should have applied; your constituents are still your public.

  13. Money Hackers

    Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable: In 2009 I rece… http://bit.ly/eGQtmL http://www.moneyhackers.org

  14. Nick H.

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11

  15. chris star

    Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable
    http://j.mp/gcO0QC
    #ukuncut

  16. Trakgalvis

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11

  17. Gareth Jones

    http://tinyurl.com/6zj6rg4 Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable

  18. Emma Burnell

    I’m sorry that you didn’t think my winning idea was either well presented or easy to understand.

    I though Claire’s idea was interesting, as was Sunder’s and that all three deserve further investigation.

  19. Matthew Barrett

    RT @mjhsinclair: The big @leftfootfwd idea for the left to win a majority, attack journalists or censor the press: http://bit.ly/gVFJ8C

  20. Pedro

    So the most radical idea at a Fabian Society Conference was to tax the banks. Sweet Jesus that's creative thinking! http://bit.ly/gVFJ8C

  21. Shamik Das

    Emma – that’s not what I was saying, some ideas will be easier to understand and better presented, but that doesn’t imply the other ideas are neither well presented nor easy to understand. I agree, though, that they are all worthy of further investigation (and articles in the Fab Review…?!)

  22. Daniel Pitt

    RT @leftfootfwd: Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more accountable http://bit.ly/gGW3lH by @ShamikDas #Fab11

  23. Manage Your tweet

    Radical ideas for a progressive majority: Making the media more … http://bit.ly/fgDFrt

Leave a Reply