New campaign to up the ante on bank reform

If banks operated in public interest, there would be no need for a ‘Big Society Bank', argues Ruth Potts of the new economics foundation.

If banks operated in public interest, there would be no need for a ‘Big Society Bank’, argues Ruth Potts, manager of the Great Transition Campaign at the new economics foundation (nef)

As the UK government back-tracks over bank reform, there are signs that the Government has misjudged the public mood. Student protests have targeted bank branches as well as parliament, and while its impact remains to be seen, the Cantona-inspired BankRun2010 has attracted supporters in 15 countries around the world, the most significant in the UK and France.

A new campaign animation, inspired by Rolling Stone Journalist Matt Taibbi’s description of Goldman Sachs as a vampire squid “wrapped around the face of humanity”, released this week and supported by groups from 38 Degrees to Compass, ResPublica, PLATFORM, Positive Money and the World Development Movement is designed to up the ante on bank reform.

Evidence that emerged in the Financial Times yesterday would seem to indicate that two years after the financial crisis that sent shockwaves through the global financial system, Chancellor George Osborne is preparing to:

“… normalize relations between Government and the city”

– leaving banking regulation exactly as it was when the crisis hit. This is the same George Osborne, who, when presenting the Government’s emergency budget just six months ago, stated:

“In putting in order the nation’s finances, we must remember that this was a crisis that started in the banking sector. The failures of the banks imposed a huge cost on the rest of society.”

It is said that a week is a long time in politics. With regard to Government resolve to reform the banking sector, a few weeks is enough time for a total volte-face.

The rumour, reported in the FT, is that a deal is being struck in which bankers exercise a ‘degree’ of restraint over bonuses, promise funding to UK businesses (a promise they’ve previously broken time and time again according to small business groups) and provide funding for the ‘Big Society Bank’ any further talk of reform will be kicked into the long grass.

This “normalisation” of relations with the city strikes a particularly odd note when establishment figures such as Governor of the Bank of England, Mervyn King are becoming increasingly vocal about the need for fundamental reform of the financial system. He is emphatic that some of the much lauded attempts to reform banks are inadequate:

“If [Basel III, the latest international agreement on banking rules] is a giant leap for the regulators of the world, it is only a small step for mankind. Basel III on its own will not prevent another crisis.”

King is also beginning to ask very fundamental questions about how banking operates as this extract from a recent speech demonstrates:

“What we cannot countenance is a continuation of the system in which bank executives trade and take risks on their own account, and yet those who finance them are protected from loss by the implicit taxpayer guarantees…  Of all the many ways of organising banking, the worst is the one we have today.”

And, newly revealed data from the Federal Reserve shows just how close to global financial meltdown we came. Investment Bank Goldman Sachs has frequently insisted it could have survived without taxpayer support.  Fed data, released last week, tells a different story. At the height of the crisis, Goldman Sachs tapped one source of emergency funding 84 times borrowing almost $600 billion just to stay afloat.

Even with the promised ‘restraint’, it is likely that UK banks are preparing for another round of staggering bonuses, oblivious to the debts they bear to society. The banks claim that these payouts are necessary for attracting the best staff. But is that really true? Psychologists at MIT found that when students were set a task that required even the most basic cognitive skill, a larger reward actually reduced performance.

And there’s living proof that bonuses aren’t necessary for success. Sweden has a major bank, Svenska Handelsbanken, which doesn’t pay any bonuses at all. If banks operated in public interest, there would be no need for a ‘Big Society Bank’. It is time to take back our banks….

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

25 Responses to “New campaign to up the ante on bank reform”

  1. Samuel Tarry

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  2. Adam Young

    Via @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  3. John Ruddy

    Lets also not forget that when pressed on the “Labour caused the crisis” line the tories use, they fall back on the low level of banking regulation. They conveniently forget that they were pressing for it to be even less, and of course now they are aiming to go back to the pre-crisis regime. Pathetic.

  4. matthew fox

    The argument we can’t instigate bank reform without international agreement, undermines the whole notion of UK sovereignty. Conservatives keep banging about the erosion of the nation state by Europe, but quite happily let other countries veto how we govern our banks.

    I get the feeling, when Parliament rises for Christmas, the bankers will get their bonuses.

  5. Diane Hain

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  6. John Turner

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  7. pam lorenz

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  8. Alex Marsh

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  9. Self-restraint can’t be the cure for the persistent merchant banker « Alex's Archives

    […] excellent vegetable dansak I was eating this evening was rather spoilt by coming across a post on Left Foot Forward, picking up on an article in the FT earlier this week. Ruth Potts reports that Young Master Osborne […]

  10. Wendy Maddox

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  11. World Development

    New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

  12. Jonathan Bartley

    RT @wdmuk: New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

  13. britesprite

    RT @wdmuk: New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

  14. Anon E Mouse

    These banks are private businesses and accountable to their shareholders.

    If Britain’s worst Prime Minister ever, the useless Gordon Brown, had left the banks to fail big one’s would have bought small ones and the taxpayer bail out wouldn’t have been required. It’s how capitalism works.

    This article is simply a politics of envy thoughtless attempt to suggest socialism. Something this country, like every other country that’s tried it doesn’t need…

  15. nef

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  16. Ira

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  17. bwa design

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform: http://bit.ly/hCHsc1 writes @theneweconomics's Ruth Potts

  18. Keith Parkins

    RT @wdmuk: New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

  19. Nick H.

    RT @leftfootfwd: New campaign to up the ante on bank reform http://bit.ly/hqqZu8 – Push, push, push…….('till I get my satisfaction).

  20. Robin Hood

    RT @wdmuk: New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

  21. Hazico_Jo

    RT @wdmuk: New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

  22. Jake Hewkin

    RT @wdmuk: New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

  23. The Dragon Fairy

    RT @wdmuk: New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

  24. Tom Salfield

    @jdaviescoates its heartening that Governor of the Bank of England, Mervyn King, agrees with what we've said for years! http://goo.gl/QUTKz

  25. Wendy Maddox

    RT @wdmuk: New campaign to up the ante on banking reform: http://bit.ly/ikmTka

Leave a Reply