Big society gone mad?

Hidden in Mr Cameron's appeal to mobilise people in the national interest, is a further, pernicious attack on law that in fact protects all of us.

Our guest writers are Steve Tombs and David Whyte, authors of a new book, Regulatory Surrender, published by the Institute of Employment Rights

“Your country needs you,” says the prime minister. “We’ll devolve power, but you need to take it.” And in this moment, we understood that the big society meant nothing more nor less than a revised version of Mr Blair’s active citizenship agenda. It is an appeal with a, quite literally, dangerous flip-side. For as the big society rolls out, the red tape that gets in the way of the active citizen is rolled back.

So, hidden in the appeal to mobilise people in the national interest, is a further, pernicious attack on law that in fact protects all of us. We are currently in the midst of two reviews of regulation – red tape, as its opponents like to denigrate it – that support Mr Cameron’s full frontal assault on the bureaucratic state.

One is under the stewardship of Vince Cable’s ‘Reducing Regulation Committee’; a second is led by Mrs Thatcher’s former trade and industry secretary Lord Young. It is clear now that there is a direct link between the big society and the deregulation assault.

On Sunday, Lord Young toured media studios claiming that he will end the so-called compensation culture and introduce a “good Samaritan” law that will protect those that volunteer for public service from being tied up in health and safety bureaucracy. His report, long delayed but imminent, will further undermine health and safety protection for workers and members of the public. So, when Cameron claimed today that his government will “scrap those health and safety rules that put us off” he is marking out a good old fashioned de-regulation agenda.

The rationale for all of this is the tabloid consensus that schools, clubs, businesses and in fact all of us are over-regulated, over-burdened and completely tied up in red tape – health and safety, in short, has ‘gone mad’. But this simple and increasingly powerful claim – a combination of anecdotes, half-truths and downright myths – conflates a series of quite distinct issues.

It is indeed the case that there are more bureaucratic rules controlling local authorities, and that this has paralysed a lot of mundane activities through the application of petty rules. But this is quite distinct from the claim that ‘health and safety has gone mad.’ There is big contradiction that runs through the hyperbole that Mr Cameron has so readily exploited.

For, ironically, those who create the most risks in our society – and those that have the most power to do something about those risks – have actually been subjected to far less regulatory scrutiny in recent years. Businesses are relatively free, and becoming freer, from any oversight by the government safety regulator, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE).

The HSE is currently only able to investigate a fraction of deaths caused by work that, according to TUC estimates, kills more than 20,000 per year. Many times more people are killed each year in the UK by businesses than in headline-grabbing murders. And evidence from the HSE’s own research indicates that a large majority of those deaths would be avoided had businesses complied with the law.  Businesses kill and get away with it. Few (often less than a hundred) end up in the courts – and the outcome is generally a paltry fine.

Health-and-Safety-Executive-prosecutions-and-inspections

What Mr Cameron didn’t mention in his speech is that a pretty good hatchet job has already been done on the HSE… by New Labour. A succession of deregulation initiatives and Bills have emasculated the UK safety regulator and refocused its law enforcement strategy to the point that a business can now expect to be visited, on average, once every 38 years. The impact on the HSE of three Labour governments has been dramatic. HSE now investigates a paltry third of safety offences it did 10 years ago. Prosecution of offences has fallen by 48 per cent in the same decade.

The upshot of this is that the majority of some pretty gruesome injuries are not now even investigated by the HSE. Two thirds of all amputations, a quarter of all major burns and two thirds of all major poisonings and gassings reported to HSE go uninvestigated.

This is hardly a picture of health and safety gone mad, nor of bureaucracy holding back business, the economy, or us as potential volunteers in the big society. Regulation was put in place for a reason. The real crisis in health and safety is not to be found in petty safety rules, but in the failure to hold those who kill, injure and ruin lives through illness to account. The flip side of Cameron’s appeal today is dangerous indeed.

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

24 Responses to “Big society gone mad?”

  1. zopalok

    RT @leftfootfwd: Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – The coalition's pernicious attack on health and safety law

  2. House Of Twits

    RT @leftfootfwd Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – The coalition's pernicious attack on health and safety law

  3. Paul Crowley

    Health and safety: two graphs everyone must see http://j.mp/a6C2ud

  4. Andrew Tindall

    RT @leftfootfwd: Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – The coalition's pernicious attack on health and safety law

  5. Shamik Das

    RT @leftfootfwd: Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – The coalition's pernicious attack on health and safety law

  6. Dr Shibley Rahman

    RT @leftfootfwd: Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – The coalition's pernicious attack on health and safety law

  7. Pozorvlak

    RT @ciphergoth: Health and safety: two graphs everyone must see http://j.mp/a6C2ud

  8. Denny

    "Businesses kill and get away with it." RT @ciphergoth: Health and safety: two graphs everyone must see http://j.mp/a6C2ud

  9. Harry Harris

    RT @leftfootfwd: Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi

  10. Lynn Hancock

    RT @leftfootfwd: Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – excellent article on the real story behind elf and safety.

  11. Christiaan Kwant

    yall know @RadioBigBoy Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – The coalition's pernicious attack on health and safety law hke… (0.o)*

  12. Acid Fascists

    RT @leftfootfwd: Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – The coalition's pernicious attack on health and safety law

  13. Alex Hern

    Two thirds of all amputations reported to Health and Safety go uninvestigated. But hey, gotta cut all that red tape. http://twurl.nl/aoi1mi

  14. Jon H

    RT @lynnhancock: RT @leftfootfwd: Big society gone mad? http://bit.ly/bMv5hi – excellent article on the real story behind elf and safety.

  15. Mr. Sensible

    The ‘Big Society’ is a big con anyway.

    It is a mask for cuts.

    And, I think you could say, ‘Health and Safety Gone mad’, gone mad!
    🙂

  16. Paul Miller

    Two thirds of all amputations, a quarter of all major burns and two thirds of poisonings and gassings uninvestigated. http://bit.ly/9j0FYa

  17. Note to Self

    Well-presented arguments and points.
    Shows Cameron’s Blairlike charm to be the coldhearted propaganda your instincts tell you it is.
    More like “Health And Safety Gone..”

  18. andrew

    Really very concerning. I hope the fight against Cameron and the Lib Dems is more sophisticated than threatening strikes though. That just isn’t going to win support from the public who will be paying more taxes and getting fewer services etc.

  19. David Douglass

    There is no doubt that in large scale industry and workplaces, workers must direct the level of health and safety and ensure our survival and health and well being. As a life long coal miner I of course fight for and have fought for that. BUT dont tell me the Blair Brown government didnt have a bonazar of legislation and mind blowing control freakery.
    They forced their way into every aspect of our lives and tried to control everything we do, the way we think, the things we can do etc. We need free of huge swathes of this zombie making culture which has robbed working people of the right to make decisions about themselves and kids to have a normal life. I dont care who does it it needs doing. By trying to pretend everything is vital and the sky is falling in,you actually cheapen the serious arguements for workers control of safety and planning in the workplace and society. Note not solicitors and lawyers or politicians or busybody middle class law and order freaks- workers !
    We need to decide what needs doing and what is our choice and our own business, from climbing trees, to drinking, making bonfires or feeding ducks.

  20. Ronnie Draper

    The aims of the Young report have little to do with easing the burden on business or with reducing of red tape. It is another example of undermining the rights of workers in the workplace. The reduction of protective legislation paired with the decimation of the Health and Safety Executive will guarantee that unscrupulous employers will cut corners and we all know that cut corners cost lives.

  21. Health and safety laws matter - every day 60 people die due to work | Left Foot Forward

    […] threat of law enforcement from employers who kill and injure their workers. As we pointed out in an earlier blog for Left Foot Forward, there is no evidence that workplaces are over regulated, but the very […]

  22. Health and safety laws matter - every day 60 people die due to work | Left Foot Forward

    […] threat of law enforcement from employers who kill and injure their workers. As we pointed out in an earlier blog for Left Foot Forward, there is no evidence that workplaces are over regulated, but the very […]

  23. Health and Safety cuts: Criminal businesses let off the leash | Left Foot Forward

    […] we pointed out in an earlier article on Left Foot Forward, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) now inspects a third of the workplaces it did a decade […]

  24. Grayling’s tabloid pandering gone mad | Left Foot Forward

    […] reports there are still as many as 20,000 deaths a year caused by work. Last year Left Foot Forward reported only a fraction of deaths and workplace injuries ever came to the attention of the HSE, with it now […]

Leave a Reply