The Department for Work and Pensions is under pressure to improve levels of transparency and accountability following a FullFact.org investigation yesterday.
The Department for Work and Pensions is under pressure to improve levels of transparency and accountability following a FullFact.org investigation yesterday.
A press release from Iain Duncan Smith’s department on 14 September led to headline stories in the Sun and the Daily Mail – the Sun claiming one in thirty Britons have never had a job and the Mail saying 1.5 million Britons had never worked in their life. These figures tie in well with the Coalition’s pugnacious rhetoric condemning “benefit scroungers”.
But as FullFact reported, these figures were not part of a publicly accessible investigation:
“… the DWP’s press officer seemed co-operative, promising to forward us the findings that had been released to the papers.
“This afternoon, two days and several phone calls later, we were finally emailed the press release. It contains the statistics reported in both papers, the Employment Minister’s accompanying comments and a briefing about the government’s upcoming Work Programme.
“But the only source referenced is last week’s ONS (Office for National Statistics) research on workless households, which revealed nothing about the number of Brits who have never been employed.”
Left Foot Forward have ourselves inquired into the source behind the figures. This morning a DWP spokesman told us they were the result of an investigation conducted internally by the department, and were therefore separate from the ONS research; he insisted that the figures were:
“…all quality assured and double checked to ensure they were as robust as possible.”
This is not the first time the DWP have provided mysterious figures on the jobless. Last month Left Foot Forward revealed a disturbing distortion of statistics, which led to newspapers lambasting the 250,000 households where no-one has ever had a job. In the light of the figures, the Daily Telegraph’s Jeff Randall spoke of “clobbering dole cheats“.
Once again, the figures were released in a press release and were not part of an official published report. This time, they were found to be erroneous in number and misleading in presentation; as Left Foot Forward’s Nicola Smith pointed out:
“Many of the households included in the analysis are likely to be made up of people the Government does not expect to work and has committed to protecting – severely disabled people and single parents with very young children.”
6 Responses to “The great DWP conjuring act on worklessness figures”
The great DWP conjuring act on worklessness figures « The best Labour blogs
[…] More… […]
Toby Warren
I must admit, Toby Thomas paints a strong argument here. This opaque department should lift the shutters, and change that frosted glass for normal, properly see-through glass. Transparency? Right now, we would welcome translucency.
SMS PolicyWatch
RT @leftfootfwd: The great DWP conjuring act on worklessness figures: http://bit.ly/auLjqN reports @tobyjthomas
Robert
new Labour were also brilliant at using fact and figures from the ONS. They sent me a letter after I said the work less numbers in my area were much higher then Labours 2%, my councils unemployment figures said it was 22% and the CAB said it was close to 28%, but Labour stated the ONS facts had been checked doubled checked, six weeks later the Labour government had it hand slapped for the misrepresentation of figures, so it’s what parties do they lie.
Heskin Radiophonic
Iain Duncan Smith seems to invent jobless figures that appeal to right-wing prejudices: http://is.gd/fjeXb