Celtic warnings over AV poll date

With controversy about the Government’s Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill rumbling on, voices from the devolved administrations have expressed their concern with the planned timing of the vote.

Wales’ Chief Electoral Officer has declared it “vital” that the Welsh public have full confidence in the electoral system, ahead of next year’s elections.

The comments, by Ian Kelsall will once again raise concerns about the problems that could be caused by holding on the same day votes for the devolved institutions and local councils, a referendum on the Alternative Vote, and a Wales-only ballot on further powers for Cardiff Bay.

In 2007, the Scottish Parliamentary Elections were marked by scenes of chaos as voters were faced with multiple ballot papers, each under a different system.

In the latest warning, Kelsall concludes:

“Next year voters in Wales will have several opportunities to have their say at the ballot box.

“It’s vital that they have confidence in the electoral process and the UK Government addresses some of the areas where change is needed.”

His remarks come as over 40 Conservative MPs signed a parliamentary Early Day Motion (EDM 613) expressing their concern that the proposed date of the AV referendum would clash with the elections to the devolved bodies. In doing so, the motion cited Electoral Commission advice in 2002, which made clear its unease at holding referendums on major policy issues on the same day as other polls. Among the concerns it raised was a warning that:

“There is a risk that the dominance of the referendum issue would influence other polls to an extent that may compromise the electorate’s will in those other polls.”

Meanwhile, the Interim Electoral Management Board for Scotland has written to both Nick Clegg and Scottish Secretary, Danny Alexander to express its concerns at holding a poll on AV at the same time as elections to Holyrood. In particular, the board warned:

• Holding a referendum on AV would need to be administered based on Westminster constituencies, while polling for Holyrood elections is administered based on different boundaries. This could mean some people having to cast their votes at two separate polling stations.

• Under current law, the elections would also have to be treated as two separate polls, requiring two voting cards and two lists of eligible voters.

What is more, following the chaotic scenes that followed the 2007 Scottish Parliamentary Elections, the report into the fiasco, drafted by Ron Gould cautioned against combining more than one poll in two days (p. 114 – 115).

Responding to the latest developments, Shadow Scotland Office Minister, Ann McKechin said of the ConDem coalition:

“It is an act of disrespect not to have even thought about the consequences for Scotland.”

Speaking in the House of Commons however, Nick Clegg said that it was “disrespectful” to suggest that voters “could not make two different decisions at the same time.”

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

10 Responses to “Celtic warnings over AV poll date”

  1. House Of Twits

    RT @leftfootfwd New post: Celtic warnings over AV poll date http://bit.ly/91pURl

  2. Mr. Sensible

    The question relating to the date of the referendum is, I think, a case of ‘6 of 1 and half a dozen of the other.’ There are arguments that it would be easier and cheaper to have it on the same date as the local and devolved elections, but not everywhere in the country has elections, I don’t think.

    There’s definetly tention in there, and if the government loses at second reading of the bill, as it could, we could have some fun.

  3. Will Straw

    I should say that I’m not convinced by these arguments. Surely the Welsh and Scots can chew and eat gum with a bit of sensible administrative help.

  4. Ekimia

    Celtic warnings over AV poll date | Left Foot Forward: With controversy about the Government's Parliamen… http://bit.ly/aa1F7E Just Click

  5. Anon E Mouse

    Ed Jacobs – Who the hell does this Ian Kelsall think he is?

    Is is saying people in Wales are too stupid to understand this system?

    The man needs sacking…

  6. Philip Cane

    From @leftfootfwd: Celtic warnings over AV poll date from Cardiff, Holyrood and Electoral Commission http://bit.ly/91pURl #No2AV

  7. Vote No To AV

    From @leftfootfwd: Celtic warnings over AV poll date from Cardiff, Holyrood and Electoral Commission http://bit.ly/91pURl #No2AV

  8. Martell Thornton

    Celtic warnings over AV poll date | Left Foot Forward: Meanwhile, the Interim Electoral Management Board for Scotl… http://bit.ly/b5Qdxg

  9. Edward Carlsson Browne

    I do wonder if this might not be a tactical mistake by the coalition. Wales and Scotland are going to be hit fairly hard by the reduction to 600 seats. There won’t be anything that can stop that by May, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it engenders an anti-AV backlash. And given that turnout will be higher there, that could be the last thing Cleggeron want.

Leave a Reply